In Diamonds in the Rough, Todd Cleveland examines African labor on the isolated mines of colonial Angola's Diamang Corporation. Cleveland sets out to answer, ‘Why, in light of the demanding labor regime in Lunda (in northeast Angola), did African mine workers not adopt a more militant posture?’ (3). This quiescence on the part of the Angolan miners, especially those fulfilling forced, contract labor, seems counterintuitive. After all, Angola was known as a site of a particularly brutal and long lasting form of forced labor. The historiography of Angolan labor emphasizes structural and corporal violence to understand how the system survived into the 1960s. Cleveland analyzes labor at the colony's largest and most profitable company and his nuanced argument is that in the case of Diamang, company pragmatism, paternalism, and profits; workers' occupational and social professionalism; and, the mines' geographical isolation, are the primary explanations for the quietude (3–4). This argument challenges historical interpretations that emphasize Portuguese colonial exploitation without considering the system's more pragmatic and paternalistic characteristics. The focus on African miners and their families is refreshingly original.
The book is part of Ohio University Press's New African Histories series, which promotes research on the lived experiences of Africans. One of the strengths of Cleveland's book is exactly this emphasis on how miners and their families experienced work and life on the mines. Cleveland based much of his research on the extensive Diamang archive housed at the Anthropology Department's Museum at the Universidade de Coimbra (Portugal). The level of detail about workers' experiences owes much to this extensive and hitherto little accessed archive. Interviews with several dozen former Diamang workers and administrators add insight into work and living conditions.
A hallmark of this book is Cleveland's organization of the chapters to follow the miners from the recruitment process in the villages of Lunda and beyond, work on the mines, life after the whistle blew, and the return back home after the completion of a contract. This is more than a clever gimmick because it allows the reader a window into the quotidian lives of individual miners and family members.
So often labor studies, especially in Africa, provide little description of workers' lived experience. Diamonds in the Rough fills in this lacuna. Cleveland's attention to women's work for the company and in taking care of their husbands on the mines adds weight to his argument about how company paternalism led to policies encouraging wives to accompany contract/forced laborers to the mines (a policy unique in colonial Angola, although practiced on other mines in Central Africa). According to Cleveland, wives were largely responsible for the stable, peaceful, and even harmonious village life of forced workers (163). This stability contributed to workers' ‘occupational professionalism’, by which Cleveland means workers' acceptance of Diamang's paternalistic role and their collective decision to reciprocate with cooperation and commitment to the job at hand. Over time, this worker professionalism largely replaced the sorts of confrontation and subterfuge characteristic of other mining and forced labor regimes in Angola and across colonial Africa.
Initially, I doubted this line of argumentation. After all, over decades Diamang relied on forced labor to meet its growing labor needs. However, Todd Cleveland makes a compelling argument based on exhaustive archival and oral sources for a more complicated and, ultimately, much more interesting history. In so doing he contributes an important case study to the historiography of mine labor in colonial Africa.
