According to author Nurullah Ardiç, “the tragic demise of the Caliphate marked a significant milestone in the history of Muslim societies” (p. 307), a process indelibly linked to their “modernization” over the long 19th century. By studying this process, Ardiç's Islam and the Politics of Secularism fills a gap in the English-language literature on the “secularization” (and thus “modernization”) of the Ottoman Empire by way of its political and intellectual elite. While others have studied the role of education or popular culture as catalysts of Ottoman elite “Westernization,” Ardiç's clearly stated, oft-repeated argument centers “Islam” in the story. As such, his extensively researched and laboriously argued thesis relies on a counter-intuitive observation that debates between adversaries in the latter decades of the Ottoman Empire consistently referenced Islam to justify very different ideological claims. In other words, both “traditionalists” who “politicize” Islam and (here is Ardiç's innovation) so-called “modernist” reformers reached a point of accommodation in respect to “Islam's” expected role in late Ottoman society (pp. 25–38). This implicitly challenges the long-assumed tension between “religion” and “secular” politics.
As Ardiç demonstrates, the “tactical” use of “Islam” as a rhetorical tool can be gleaned from the vast literature published in the Ottoman Empire (and the larger Muslim world) during the empire's last fifty years. For Ardiç, who seemingly leaves no stone unturned in his detailed “discourse analysis” of Ottoman intellectual writings and speeches, the exchange between different sets of actors—some advocating for the strengthening of the state's open embrace of “secular” policies, others fearing the consequences of such a shift away from “tradition”—contributed to a monumental transformation of Ottoman society. Ardiç is convincing in this regard, as he tirelessly recounts the sociopolitical debates that would carry over into the early republican period, when the decision was finally made to abolish the Caliphate in 1924 (pp. 241–311).
At the heart of this debate are three groups pitted against each other during these final years of the Ottoman Empire: the “secularists,” who wished to destroy the Caliphate; the “modernists,” who saw political utility in the “institution”; and, lastly, the “traditionalists,” who believed the Caliphate held both spiritual and political authority worth preserving. Ardiç's close reading of these different factions’ arguments really gains value in his description of the subtle shifts in the content and tactics each group adopted over the period of time covered in the book. Here, Ardiç's thorough analysis of three distinct periods—the pre World War I second constitutional period (1908–16); a “middle phase” (1916–20); and the post World War I phase (1920–24)—takes up dozens of pages of close readings of these debates that should be invaluable to scholars. In his treatment of these exchanges, Ardiç is careful to repeatedly point out that “it was accommodation that mostly characterized the relations between Islam and secularism in the modernization of the Middle East” (p. 320). In other words, while diverse personalities ranging from Ziya Gökalp and Mustafa Kemal (Atatürk) to “modernist” ʿulamaʾ such as Seyyid Bey advocated for the termination of the Caliphate, they nevertheless resorted to Islamic references, in a manner Ardiç describes as “theological engineering,” to justify their positions (pp. 270–71). This revealing analysis of the “rhetorical strategies” of the “secularists” highlights just how far those future heroes of the post-Caliphate world had to accommodate the concerns of those who insisted that some things not change. This focus on the “tactical” use of “Islamic” themes in these late Ottoman/early republican debates is the innovative engine behind Ardiç's book, one that does require, however, some reflection on the context behind these “rhetorical concessions.”
In this respect, in each of his five substantive chapters Ardiç does only a fair job of discussing the immediate context behind these texts, summarizing in each chapter the impact that war, rivalries between political factions, imperial rivalry, coups, and economic crises had on shaping his sources. Unfortunately, this massive book repeats its main points over and over again, while blurring the nuances that linked outside events to the debates over the Caliphate. The reader sometimes feels that Ardiç writes about these debates as if they were taking place in a bubble. In other words, Ardiç could have done more to interweave the context he lays out at the beginning of each chapter with the rest of his analysis. In the process, he could have cut out significant portions of his examples to save for another book. Drawn from his dissertation, the present volume should have been broken up into at least two books. Ardiç, for example, did not need to prove his grasp of the discipline of sociology in an introduction that is at least thirty pages too long. Similarly, he did not have to offer so many full-length translated quotes from his impressive cache of sources. While having clearly mastered the issues through tireless research, Ardiç's hesitance to cut redundancies from his work tends to drain the reader's interest. Furthermore, as this book becomes too unwieldy even for the author, some methodological inconsistencies surface. For example, while it is clear that the author does not want to suggest it, he does have the tendency to present “Islam” as the causal agent in history when it is really the many individual and constituent groups who mobilize the discourses that Ardiç studies.
But these are minor quibbles. Ardiç generally is careful to tailor his reading of sources to make sure he does not essentialize “Islam” or Muslim agency. In sum, this detailed and innovative application of standard sociological methods to understand how a plethora of views “and rhetorical tactics” shaped the contours of late Ottoman intellectual life is welcome. Ardiç's book will prove invaluable to advanced students and established scholars of the period for years to come.
