Mulata Nation explores representations of the mulata in Cuba and parts of its diaspora between the mid-nineteenth century and today. The book captures a series of snapshots of key moments throughout this period through an analysis of a broad range of visual and performative texts, including marquillas cigarreras (illustrated cigarette wrappers), popular theatrical productions, popular magazine covers, film, art and photography. Alison Fraunhar contends that these evolving images of the mulata serve as markers of Cuban national identity and reflect the values, ideologies and agendas of the historical moment in which they were created.
The book is arranged into five substantive chapters. Chapters 1, 3, 4 and 5 each examine a specific form of artistic representation and a distinct time period, while Chapter 2 covers a broader chronological frame, and a range of artistic genres.
Chapter 1 sets an important foundation for the book by introducing some of the key images and tropes that characterised Cuban costumbrismo, and continued to reverberate in the art of subsequent periods. In Chapter 1, Fraunhar situates her analysis of mid-nineteenth-century marquillas cigarreras within a broader discussion of common racialised and gendered tropes prevalent in costumbrista literature. Artists of this genre deployed proto-nationalist imagery in the depiction of scenes, narratives and characters widely understood to be typically Cuban. The highlight of the chapter is the descriptive account of a 15-scene illustrated series of marquillas called ‘Vida y muerte de la mulata’ (‘Life and Death of the Mulatta’), which depicts the mulata at three life stages: youthful beauty, subsequent success and early ruin. The series alludes to key racialised and gendered tropes defining the late colonial moment: interracial sex between White men and Black women, the birth of mixed-race offspring, the sexualisation and commodification of mulata girls and women, and the moral contempt in which colonial society held women of African descent. Fraunhar suggests that the duality inherent in these representations of the mulata symbolises the paradoxes of an emergent Cuban nationalism in the mid-nineteenth century, a period defined by the consolidation of capitalism and the struggle for independence.
Chapter 2, which discusses both the nineteenth and the twentieth centuries broadly, suggests that the racialised and gendered representation of these tensions in national identity carried through to the republican period. Fraunhar argues that the dual images – one identifying her with the nation, and the other framing her as hypersexual and morally degraded – illustrate a central conflict in postcolonial culture, as Cubans struggled to forge a modern national identity.
In Chapter 3, Fraunhar identifies representations of the mulata as the spiritual and national body in three artistic genres during the republican period. High-modernist fine and graphic art cast the mulata at the intersection of two dominant Cuban spiritual figures, the Virgen de la Caridad del Cobre and its Yoruba counterpart, Ochún. Popular magazine illustrations, such as those appearing on the cover of Carteles in the 1920s and 1930s, emphasised a more eroticised image of the mulata that often revived the scenes depicted in the marquillas. Yet, members of the vanguardia, such as Grupo Minorista painter José Hurtado de Mendoza, depicted an alternate vision of modernity, recasting the mulata as a liberatory body invoking both nationality and nature. Chapter 4 traces the parallel deconstruction and reification of the sexualised image of the mulata in Cuban film between the 1960s and the 1980s as a reflection of revolutionary effort to redeem the mulata as a symbol of its victory. Whereas the mulata had served as a powerful rhetoric of consumerism prior to the Revolution, by the 1960s these images came to communicate social messages. The fall of the Soviet Union and the onset of the Special Period, however, prompted the recommodification of the mulata body. Chapter 5 explores the deployment of eroticised images of the mulata to attract tourism and entrepreneurship to Cuba during the Special Period. In this chapter Fraunhar extends her vision beyond the conventional boundaries of cisgender, showing how existing tropes of mulataje are revived, appropriated and transformed in drag performance and queer culture in Cuba and abroad.
Overall, Fraunhar finds three key themes in the representations of the mulata she surveyed. The mulata served as a national allegory: images of this racialised gendered figure often embodied the transculturated spirituality of Yoruba and Catholic faiths. They also emerged and re-emerged as intensely eroticised bodies. She concludes that these qualities that are attributed to the mulata, in their recurrence and evolving character, have reflected shifting ideologies and realities, ones that, like the mulata herself, resist containment (p. 216).
The range of artistic genres covered in this book is truly impressive. The reader will delight in the array of full-colour images accompanying each chapter. Moreover, the book offers deep and sustained engagement with many of the important works of scholarship on race and gender in Cuba. However, considering the prevalence of the mulata in Cuban popular culture, many of the themes Fraunhar discusses have been taken up previously by other scholars. The book does miss an opportunity to engage with a few of these key texts. In particular, Melissa Blanco Borelli's monograph She is Cuba (Oxford University Press, 2016) examines the ways mulatas constructed their own identities through movement and performance. Karen Y. Morrison's Cuba's Racial Crucible (Indiana University Press, 2015) also analyses many of the same racialised gendered tropes that shaped representations of the mulata through historical and historiographical sources. Rafael Ocasio's Afro-Cuban Costumbrismo (University of Florida Press, 2012) explored the depiction of African-descended characters in a genre that forms the foundation of Fraunhar's analysis. Given the sheer breadth of the visual sources Fraunhar examined, Mulata Nation would have been strengthened by a discussion of how this more expansive frame suggests revisions or innovations of existing explorations of the relationship between mulata representations and Cuban nationality. Engagement with these and other works might have offered the chance to sharpen the book's central argument and refine the content of the substantive chapters to spotlight the author's unique contributions to the field.
