Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:33:43.373Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Coherent instability in wall-bounded shear

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 April 2018

M. J. Philipp Hack*
Affiliation:
Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
Parviz Moin
Affiliation:
Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: mjph@stanford.edu

Abstract

The mechanism underlying the coherent hairpin process in wall-bounded shear flows is studied. An algorithm for the identification and analysis of flow structures based on morphological operations is presented. The method distils the topology of the flow field into a discrete data set and enables the time-resolved sampling of coherent flow processes across multiple scales. Application to direct simulation data of transitional and turbulent boundary layers at moderate Reynolds number sheds light on the flow physics of the hairpin process. The analysis links the hairpin to an exponential instability which is amplified in the flow distorted by a negative perturbation in the streamwise velocity component. Linear analyses substantiate the connection to an inviscid instability mechanism of varicose type. The formation of packets of hairpins is related to a self-similar process which originates from a single patch of low-speed fluid and describes a recurrence of the dynamics that leads to the formation of an individual hairpin. Analysis of the evolution of several thousand turbulent hairpins provides a statistical characterization of the principal dynamics and yields a time-resolved average of the hairpin process. Comparisons with the transitional hairpin show qualitatively consistent trends and thus support earlier hypotheses of their equivalence. In terms of the causality of events, the results suggest that the hairpin is a manifestation of the varicose instability and as such is a consequence rather than a cause of the primary perturbations of the flow.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2018 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.The skin-friction coefficient of the K-type (solid) and H-type (dashed) simulations. Turbulent correlation from White (2005).

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Sample representation of a cube in the digital grid. (b) The octant neighbourhood $N(v)$ of the point $v$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The 26-point neighbourhood of a point $v$ in the digital image with coordinate system.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Application of the morphological thinning algorithm to reference topology. (a) Binary image with isosurface at $Z=0.5$. (b) Voxels representing the medial axis.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Graph generation from medial axis. (a) Connectivity of the medial axis voxels. (b) Graph with links and node.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Isolated hairpin vortex from the late stage of K-type transition (isosurface of the $Q$ criterion) with medial axis link (black line).

Figure 6

Table 1.The topological filtering criteria applied in the identification of the hairpin process.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Time series of hairpin formation during the late stage of K-type transition. Isosurfaces of $u^{\prime }=0.20$ (white), $u^{\prime }=-0.20$ (black) and $Q=5$ (red). An animation is available in movie 1 of the supplementary material at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2018.202.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Time series of hairpin formation during the late stage of K-type transition. Isosurfaces of $v^{\prime }=0.05$ (white), $v^{\prime }=-0.05$ (black) and $Q=5$ (red). An animation is available in movie 2 of the supplementary material.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Velocity profiles at the centre of the hairpin at $x=2.66$, $z=0.15$ and $t=t_{0}+1.03$. (a) Local mean (solid) and instantaneous streamwise velocity. (b) Streamwise (solid), normal (dashed) and spanwise (dash-dotted) velocity fluctuations.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Profiles of the Reynolds stresses at the centre of the hairpin $x=2.66$, $z=0.15$ and $t=t_{0}+1.03$: $u^{\prime }u^{\prime }$ (solid), $v^{\prime }v^{\prime }$ (dashed), $w^{\prime }w^{\prime }$ (dash-dotted) and $u^{\prime }v^{\prime }$ (dotted). (a) Temporal and spanwise mean. (b) Instantaneous.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Profiles of the enstrophy terms at the centre of the hairpin $x=2.66$, $z=0.15$ and $t=t_{0}+1.03$. Streamwise (solid), normal (dashed) and transverse (dash-dotted) components. (a) Temporal and spanwise mean. (b) Instantaneous.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Profiles of terms of the fluctuation kinetic energy budget at the centre of the hairpin, $x=2.66$, $z=0.15$ and $t=t_{0}+1.03$. Production (solid) and dissipation (dashed). (a) Temporal and spanwise mean. (b) Instantaneous.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Peak normal (solid) and streamwise (dashed) velocity fluctuations during hairpin formation as a function of time. (a) Linear scaling. (b) Logarithmic scaling.

Figure 14

Figure 14.(a) Isolated hairpin at $t=t_{0}+1.03$ with critical layer (blue). (b) Cross-section at $x=2.67$ with contours of $v^{\prime }$ from $-0.1$ (black) to 0.1 (white). The dashed line marks the instantaneous critical layer.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Isosurfaces of the primary eigenfunction computed at $t=t_{0}+0.74$. Streamwise, normal and spanwise components: positive (white) and negative (black).

Figure 16

Figure 16.Isosurface of the $Q$ criterion computed for the primary eigenfunction at$t=t_{0}+0.74$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Hairpin packet formation in the transitional boundary layer. Time series of side view with contours of the streamwise fluctuation, $u^{\prime }$. Crosses and numbers indicate local minima of $u^{\prime }$, triangles indicate the heads of hairpins. The continuous white line marks the local boundary layer thickness.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Hairpin packet formation in the transitional boundary layer. Time series of side view with contours of the normal fluctuation, $v^{\prime }$. Crosses and numbers indicate local minima of $u^{\prime }$, triangles indicate the heads of hairpins. The continuous white line marks the local boundary layer thickness.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Trajectories of the local minima of the streamwise fluctuation during the late stages of natural transition. (a) Streamwise position as a function of time. (b) Normal position as a function of time.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Primary eigenfunction at $t=t_{0}+1.03$. Isosurfaces of positive (white) and negative (black) streamwise component.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Evolution of an individual hairpin in turbulent flow. Isosurfaces of negative (black) and positive (white) fluctuations of the streamwise velocity component with isosurfaces of the $Q$ criterion (red).

Figure 22

Figure 22.Evolution of an individual hairpin in turbulent flow. Isosurfaces of negative (black) and positive (white) fluctuations of the normal velocity component with isosurfaces of the $Q$ criterion (red).

Figure 23

Figure 23.Trace of the turbulent hairpin. (a) Streamwise position as a function of time. Location of minimal $u^{\prime }$ (solid) and mean flow trajectory (dashed). (b) Normal position as a function of time. Location of minimal $u^{\prime }$, mean flow trajectory (dashed) and local boundary layer thickness (dash-dotted).

Figure 24

Figure 24.Evolution of the peak fluctuations in the turbulent hairpin. (a) Streamwise component. (b) Normal component.

Figure 25

Figure 25.Primary eigenfunction of the turbulent hairpin process. Isosurfaces of negative (black) and positive (white) fluctuations. (a) Streamwise component, (b) normal component, (c) spanwise component.

Figure 26

Figure 26.The dynamically averaged turbulent hairpin process. Isosurfaces of positive (white) and negative (black) streamwise velocity fluctuations $u^{\prime }$ with isosurfaces of the $Q$ criterion (red) at selected time instants. An animation (see movie 3) is available as part of the supplementary material.

Figure 27

Figure 27.The dynamically averaged turbulent hairpin process. Isosurfaces of positive (white) and negative (black) normal velocity fluctuations $v^{\prime }$ with isosurfaces of the $Q$ criterion (red) at selected time instants. An animation (see movie 4) is available as part of the supplementary material.

Figure 28

Figure 28.Absolute values of the maximum (solid) and minimum (dashed) dynamically averaged velocity fluctuations within the sampling domain as a function of sampling time. (a) Streamwise fluctuations. (b) Normal fluctuations.

Figure 29

Figure 29.Probability density functions of the extremal levels of streamwise fluctuations for the sampled hairpins. (a) Minimum fluctuations. (b) Maximum fluctuations.

Figure 30

Figure 30.Probability density functions of the extremal levels of normal fluctuations for the sampled hairpins. (a) Minimum fluctuations. (b) Maximum fluctuations.

Figure 31

Figure 31.Trajectories of the centre positions of identified hairpin structures versus $x$ and $y$ (a) and $y^{+}$ (b). The grey line indicates the local boundary layer thickness.

Figure 32

Figure 32.Trajectories of the locations closest to the wall of identified hairpin structures versus $x$ and $y^{+}$. The fifth of the population located farthest from the wall (a) and the fifth of the population located closest to the wall (b).

Figure 33

Figure 33.Probability density function of the frequency of occurrence of hairpin structures. (a) As a function of the streamwise coordinate. (b) As a function of the dimensionless wall distance.

Figure 34

Figure 34.Histogram of the spanwise extent of hairpin structures. (a) As a function of the streamwise coordinate and the physical wall distance. (b) As a function of the streamwise coordinate and the dimensionless wall distance.

Figure 35

Figure 35.Histogram of the lifetime of hairpin structures. (a) As a function of the streamwise coordinate and the physical wall distance. (b) As a function of the streamwise coordinate and the dimensionless wall distance.

Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 1

Animation of hairpin formation during the late stage of K-type transition. Isosurfaces of $Q=5$ (red), $u'=0.20$ (white) and $u'=-0.20$ (black).

Download Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 7.8 MB

Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 2

Animation of hairpin formation during the late stage of K-type transition. Isosurfaces of $Q=5$ (red),

Download Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 7.7 MB

Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 3

Animation of the dynamically averaged turbulent hairpin process. Isosurfaces of $Q$ criterion (red) and positive (white) and negative (black) streamwise velocity fluctuations $u'$.

Download Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 3(Video)
Video 3.8 MB

Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 4

Animation of the dynamically averaged turbulent hairpin process. Isosurfaces of $Q$ criterion (red) and positive (white) and negative (black) streamwise velocity fluctuations $v'$.

Download Philipp Hack et al. supplementary movie 4(Video)
Video 3.7 MB