Writing about Pinter is never easy. His plays were designed to thwart the kind of streamlined, thesis-driven mode of thought that dominates academia. However, in Harold Pinter: The Theatre of Power, Robert Gordon grapples with Pinter's habit of continual equivocation to create a book that manages to discuss these plays with impressive clarity while never stripping them of their complexity or their power.
One of the more productive strategies that Gordon employs is a phenomenologically based approach. The book is part of the Michigan Modern Dramatists series, which is specifically mandated to appeal to the “theatergoer,” and this emphasis on audience serves an examination of Pinter's work particularly well. Gordon's focus on the moment-to-moment impact of lines and physical business on live spectators produces startling insights into some of the most challenging aspects of Pinter's stagecraft. Pinter's oft-referenced habit of writing “pauses” into his work offers a useful case in point. “Pinter pauses” (7) are frequently misinterpreted by performers, directors, and critics as a sort of literary mannerism. Gordon, however, argues that they should be seen as unflinching moments of naturalism within a given scene. In his discussion of The Room, for example, many of the “pauses” that are written into the script are simply moments when Rose waits for a response from her unsettlingly mute husband Bert. As Gordon notes, these moments of silence “provoke the audience to question why he says nothing, thereby drawing attention to the subtext of his unexpressed thoughts and feelings and emphasizing the peculiarity of Rose's relentless stream of small talk” (14).
Gordon's phenomenological analyses of moments of stage action reveal that much of the theatrical tension in these moments is generated by the live spectacle of witnessing one person attempt to have an ordinary conversation while faced with an unwilling partner. Gordon argues compellingly that the moments that make Pinter's plays feel so unsettling are simply moments from our daily life that are usually (but not always) either unacknowledged, or else masked by social manners, conventions, or in the case of theatre, “naturalistic” dramaturgical conventions. Gordon displays repeatedly that much of Pinter's skill as a playwright is evidenced in the innovative methods that he employs to strip the social veneer away from those aspects of our lives that we find most unsettling.
Gordon continually reminds us of Pinter's substantial career as a stage actor, which preceded his playwriting career, and rightly uses this biographical information to support a performance-oriented analysis of the plays. Wisely, however, he never attempts to explain who Pinter was, why he wrote the way that he did, nor why his playwriting style changed over time. Gordon brings in biography when useful (or when unavoidable, as in Pinter's admission of the connection between the plot of Betrayal and his own affair), but these are always held as sidebars, with the primary focus continually oriented toward the plays themselves, particularly as entities for the stage.
Throughout the book, Gordon uses the idea of “power” as a unifying theme that runs in different variations throughout each of Pinter's plays. The book's ten chapters explore different variations in the struggle for power (territory, authority, gender, memory, etc.) in greater detail. Although the book moves through Pinter's plays in a largely chronological fashion, the themes dominate the organizational scheme, with plays discussed out of chronological sequence when necessary to explore a given theme. The result of this structural approach is that readers are able to see ideas and dramaturgical strategies develop from one play to another, without forcing a specific teleology onto Pinter's oeuvre as a whole.
Robert Gordon's exploration of Pinter's stage works is a major critical achievement. He produces ever-surprising insights, and his own rhetoric and erudition are impressive. The book will be of great use not only to theatregoers attempting to understand what they have seen onstage, but to actors and directors who are seeking the most theatrically productive approaches to these challenging plays. Harold Pinter: The Theatre of Power is quite simply a brilliantly conceived and exceptionally well-written academic text. It is certain to become one of the major critical works about the preeminent English playwright of the late twentieth century.
