The study of the interconnections between theatre and philosophy has been an especially active area of scholarship lately, but few authors have sought to encompass the relationship so totally as R. Darren Gobert in his groundbreaking The Mind–Body Stage. Everything from playhouse sightlines to theatre architecture, acting styles to dramaturgical tropes bear the imprint, Gobert argues, of Descartes's revolutionary conceptualization of subjectivity. One might expect no less from an intellectual shift so epochal: in the philosopher's famous cogito lies one of the origin points for the very concept of the self in its identifiably modern form.
That Descartes has not previously been considered so foundational to theatre history is in part, as Gobert demonstrates, the product of a long tradition of misreading. Associated with a strict mind–body dualism derived largely from his early writings, Descartes's philosophy can seem an uneasy fit for the embodied arts of the stage. Yet there is a profound divergence, Gobert shows, between the nuance of Descartes's writings and the ways in which they “came to be distorted into the received wisdom of ‘Cartesianism’” (6–7). To read Descartes closely and with particular focus on the later works is to discover the philosopher nearer the way in which he was known to his contemporaries, and it is consequently to see anew the changes in theatre and drama that his work helped to establish.
Gobert's book begins with the work of this reconsideration, accomplished—appropriately enough—by means of the theatre. His first chapter considers the 1649 ballet The Birth of Peace, performed at the court of Queen Christina I and written by her illustrious tutor and court philosopher, Descartes. A celebration of the end of the Thirty Years' War and all the misery and terror it entailed, the ballet in Gobert's reading highlights the body's “central role in understanding” and “restores the body to a place of prominence” (12) in the philosopher's thought. Reconstructed in its royal palace performance in exacting detail and placed in dialogue with other works from the waning days of Descartes's life—most especially his six-year letter exchange with Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia—the ballet gives embodied evidence of a profound maturation in his thought beyond his early dualism.
Equipped with this new perspective, Gobert turns his attention to the drama that flourished in Descartes's wake. Cartesian philosophy, he argues, augured a change from a dramaturgy premised on the Aristotelian dyad of pity and fear to what he identifies as a dramaturgy of emotional wonder. If the developing concept of subjectivity left little intellectual room for simultaneous and universal emotions of the sort posited by Aristotle, wonder—the encounter with the novel—retained the possibility for endemic effect. Hence the era's fascination, as in Pierre Corneille's Nicomède, with plots of return, revelation, and surprise: the necessary dramaturgy of a world where the concept of mass spectatorship was giving way to the idea of the individualized observer.
Nowhere would this shift be more strongly felt, however, than in the era's conceptualization of the actor. Seventeenth-century Paris saw a decisive transformation in the practice of the actor's art, with the stylized manner of the Hôtel de Bourgogne troupe vying for prominence with and ultimately ceding to the more natural style of Molière. What Gobert uniquely reveals within this transition is the powerful role that philosophical shifts played in making possible this change within theatre practice, the divergence in acting styles paralleling a more general evolution in the ideation of subjecthood. For Molière to inform his actors to “make yourself appear as if you are who you are playing” (105) demands an adherence to a certain concept of the self that is effectively invisible to us for its contemporary ubiquity but that would have been in many ways profoundly new to his contemporaries. Here the actor is asked “to provide his or her unique subjectivity in the service of expressing that of the character, to make visible the invisible workings of not only the character's soul but also the actor's own” (106).
Equally transformative at the time—and equally commonplace to us—was the development of new modes of theatrical architecture to house such performances. Cartesian subjectivity, Gobert writes, “gave birth to objectivity” (146) as its counterpoint, a view wherein “objects are meant to be regarded dispassionately” (159) by the isolated subject. Aiming toward a new ideal of removed, dispassionate, and individual observation, the theatres of the period began literally to change their shape. The era under Gobert's consideration includes the advent of the proscenium, the move toward seating standing spectators, and the first steps toward removing seats onstage. In the playhouses of eighteenth-century France and England, in other words, began the institutionalization of a version of theatrical spectatorship premised on contemplative observation that we still recognize today and on a concept of the individual subject that is equally familiar.
In this way, Gobert's work is both entirely enveloped in and entirely transcendent of its eighteenth-century subject. Theatre scholars of the period will find the book indispensable, connecting in new ways the era's major intellectual trends with the dramaturgical and material history of its theatres. And insofar as this period and its philosophy formed a crucible for the developing concept of the modern subject to which nearly all later drama has in some way held, all scholars with an interest in the intellectual foundations of Western theatrical practice will need to turn to Gobert's work. His is that rare book that speaks across periods, but it is also one that speaks across disciplines, revising the study of Cartesian thought specifically through the philosopher's involvement with the stage—rewriting philosophy by way of the theatre, as it were. As Gobert reminds us in his introduction, though theatre and philosophy may behave institutionally “like Punch and Judy in the fairground booth of the academy” (3) they “have always been part of the same show” (7).
