This eclectic collection of essays by scholars based in the United States, Canada, Cuba and the United Kingdom has its origins in a conference held at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario, on the 50th anniversary of the Cuban Revolution in 2009. As its title suggests, the book divides neatly into three sections on international relations, internationalism, and transnationalism, with six essays in each. The collection is edited and introduced by Catherine Krull, with a short foreword by renowned Cubanist Louis A. Pérez Jr.
Krull's comprehensive introduction deals with the overarching themes of the volume's chapters in turn. It gives, for example, an overview of some counterproductive and harmful US policies toward Cuba over the years. But there is always a difficult balance to achieve between summarising an edited volume's contents and stealing some of the thunder from the contributing authors’ arguments.
The section on international relations begins with two authoritative chapters, the first on the history of and continued possibilities for US–Cuban cooperation, and the second on Cuba's armed forces as an adjunct of the island's foreign policy. Karen Dubinsky's chapter then gives us a fascinating but sobering analysis of the way that children have been pawns and victims of the long-standing tensions between Havana and Washington. The spectre of Operation Peter Pan and the departure of 14,000 Cuban children from the island starting in early 1961 casts a long shadow over a problem symbolised more recently by the drawn-out saga of the Elián González case that began in 1999. Dubinsky analyses some of the Cold War rhetoric that led to such paranoiac and harmful migration and the separation of family members over generations.
Asa McKercher's chapter on Canadian policy toward Cuba studies Ottawa's determination not to let weightier interests in its relations with Washington affect its foreign policy toward Cuba. But there should be no pretence that Ottawa's ‘quick’ recognition (p. 110) of the new revolutionary government just over a week after Fulgencio Batista's hasty escape from Havana was not related to the timing of Washington's recognition a day earlier. Ditto the recognition by nearly all Western governments that maintained vitally important political and economic relations with the United States, which had acted as the de facto doyen of foreign governments in Cuba ever since the island's nominal independence in 1902. The British ambassador in Havana, for example, conveyed London's official recognition of the new provisional government within an hour of Washington doing so on 7 January. The statement that ‘Cuba was just another state’ (p. 111) for Canadian policy-makers might appear disingenuous despite the outward appearance of normality that Ottawa was at pains to display. This chapter, based naturally on predominantly Canadian sources, forcefully argues that Ottawa's policy vis-à-vis Havana has been ‘remarkably consistent’ (p. 120). The topic reminds us that there is a rich vein of material to be researched outside the well-mined Havana–Washington axis.
The late Max Azicri begins the section on internationalism with a chapter analysing the Cuba–Venezuela alliance. He highlights Washington's limited ability to impact negatively on the alliance, and underlines the long way that it has to run. Kevin M. Delgado recognises that he is altering the term ‘internationalism’ from its common usage in his very personal chapter on santería. He questions the authenticity of some practitioners of the syncretic Cuban religion and the dubious wares they peddle to foreign tourists. The subject matter here sits slightly at odds with other essays in the section.
A contribution by Robert Huish on Cuba's medical internationalism asks some pointed questions about what for some realists in international relations is a hard-to-fathom policy. Like Cuba's earlier internationalist military interventions in Africa, the policy seems to run against the norms practised by states in pursuing only unenlightened self-interest. What, might one ask, is in it for Cuba? There is evidently some political objective in all of this, and Huish helps us discern it. In tandem with the frequency of humanitarian emergencies is the astonishing speed with which Cuba's medical authorities can act in deploying their health practitioners to almost any point on the globe. This compares most favourably with the pedestrian reaction of governments with highly developed economies and far greater financial resources.
One particular highlight in the volume is the perceptive chapter by Ana Serra on foreign views of the Special Period in Cuba, wherein she makes a very interesting analysis of the fictional take on those years by Spanish writers, particularly two left-leaning authors. The context here is Spain's own experience of lengthy dictatorship under Generalissimo Franco and the idealised Spanish Second Republic that preceded it. In this light it would be interesting one day to read an analysis of positions taken on Cuba by foreign academics and resident foreign correspondents to see how their own political backgrounds and allegiances inform their views of the island's reality.
The volume ends with a flurry of excellent chapters. Susan Eckstein expertly dissects transnational ties between Cubans on either side of the Florida Straits, concluding with plenty of evidence that full transnational engagement between the communities has only been possible since the collapse of the Soviet bloc. In a chapter by John D. Holst on social justice, it is heartening to note that harsh and prolonged political dogmatism has not extinguished the altruism of educators and health practitioners. While sentimentalism might enter into views of Che Guevara, where hard-nosed appraisal of his contribution might have been preferred, it is good to see that idealism still prevails after 50 years (and counting) of realist foreign relations and their continuing negative effects.
It is useful to have so many thoughts under one cover on such a variety of Cuba-related topics. A volume on economic reforms would be out of date before its publication – such is the current speed of change on the island – but this is not the case with this collection of essays, from which Washington and the first wave of Cuban emigrants to the United States do not emerge well.
