No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
The sacred debts of Kyle S. Sinisi's title refer to expenditures and losses by loyalist states and private claimants related to the U.S. Civil War. His fascinating history examines not so much the cost of the Civil War as the processes by which states, the federal government, and private claimants jockeyed to determine just who would pay, how they would pay, and when they would pay. Sinisi's first chapter summarizes central government reimbursement of colony or state war-related expenditures in the colonial and antebellum periods, including the 1790 assumption of state Revolutionary War debts by the federal government. Despite this precedent, the Civil War claims required the evolution of a much extended federalism and Sinisi persuasively justifies his study as providing a window into “… the working system of intergovernmental operations.” (p. xi)
Congress initiated the intergovernmental operations that Sinisi examines when it passed, on 27 July 1861, a broad act to indemnify the (loyal) states for war related expenses. In the turbulent summer of 1861 scrutiny of the act was minimal and its passage hasty, leaving much room for bureaucratic interpretation. That interpretation fell to the Treasury Department and its ill-humored Secretary, Salmon Chase. Federal expenditures rose from $172, 000 per day at Lincoln's inauguration to over $1,000,000 per day by the summer. Secretary Chase, described by Sinisi as the perfect bureaucrat, was concerned more with the potential size of federal liability in the event of the law being interpreted broadly than he was with his political popularity. He therefore established stringent rules for settling state claims. Chase's indemnity rules required that claimants present original vouchers or receipts, use standard categories, and adhere to set military pay schedules, transportation rates, and supply costs. The paper trail flowed into Treasury's Office of the Third Auditor for recording, traveled to the War Department for validation, then returned to the Third Auditor's office for painful verification of each expenditure. The time and effort involved, especially before the era of office machinery and cheap telecommunications, or even standard forms, guaranteed that Chase's rules would embroil the claimants and the federal government well into the twentieth century, even as they apparently succeeded in limiting fraud and corruption.
Sinisi's description of the claims process alone is worth the price of the book. He continues with more detailed examination of claims by three states: Missouri, Kentucky, and Kansas. These states, he contends, convey the range of claims settlement processes, but also differ significantly from each other both in initial circumstances and in their pursuit of claims. Both state and private claims emanated from these three state's systems. Some states paid for their war expenditures by raising taxes; others sold bonds. Those states that financed war expenditures through debt pushed for indemnity payments to include interest on their war-related debts. Missouri and Kentucky entered the war as loyalist slaveholding states; Kentucky in particular had a strong Confederate following that led Washington to doubt its loyalty and to act accordingly. In 1861, Kentucky was in good fiscal health, but Missouri faced a large state debt and perilous financial circumstances. Missouri's fragile finances led it to seek compensation through congressional action rather than the Third Auditor's Office. Missouri's success with Congress in 1862 set the precedent for other claimants to by-pass the Treasury Department thereby complicating the claims process. Because Kansas became a state only in 1861, it entered the war with virtually no state government apparatus. Kansas and Missouri both faced incursions from rebel raiding parties that had to be defeated with attendant damages. Sinisi describes in detail the varied use in these cases of state employees as agents to press war claims, contrasting this approach with the use of private agents who received a percentage of their collections. He compares actions under the 1861 Indemnification Act with those that pressed Congress for special legislation. He considers how states arrived at claims figures and also the roles of state and federal claims courts. His description of the speculative sale and resale of private claims at discount is fascinating.
Sinisi's book does not contain cliometric tests of hypotheses about the extent of federalist cooperation or corruption in the late nineteenth century. Its analysis is verbal rather than quantitative, though it does provide amazing detail based on primary sources including the Congressional Record, local newspapers, state legislative papers, and private letters, speeches, and journals. The complex details never become mind numbing, however, as his narrative guides the reader through the complexities of nineteenth-century politics and bureaucracies. Sinisi's book on this interesting era of intergovernmental activities is both informative and engaging.