Peter Wien has written an excellent book, which offers a revisionist perspective that examines how actors in the Iraqi public sphere conceptualized the meaning of nationalism. Specifically, he proposes that Iraqi nationalists—intellectuals, politicians, and generals alike—did not wholeheartedly adopt Fascist and Nazi theories. Other voices, in fact, colored public debate.
One of the most important features of the book is its innovative approach to sources. Consciously turning a blind eye to British archival records, Wien privileges a comprehensive collection of Arabic autobiographies and memoirs, as well as the contemporary Arab press, a body of texts for which shared narratives and imagery create a discourse of their own. Following Manheim and Kosselleck, he concentrates on “generation” as a methodological category, identifying important differences between the Sherifians and the new effendiyya who entered public life in the 1930s. Rather than reinterpreting biographies of well-known intellectuals like Satiʿ al-Husri or politicians like Yasin al-Hashimi, Wien concentrates on lesser known, though no less important, journalists, editors, and writers. His analysis allows us to appreciate historical actors in their full complexity, highlighting the great diversity as well as the interconnections among members of the national elite who, as a result, are given a human face. We become familiar with Rufaʾil Butti, the influential editor of the daily Al-Bilad, and his attempts to understand Nietzsche's superman in relationship to questions of Muslim and Arab leadership. Another intriguing figure is the Shiʿi physician ʿAbd al-Amir al-ʿAlawi, whose biography fully exposes the contradictions typifying Iraq in the 1930s. Wien relates how this Nazi sympathizer came to befriend, and later to mourn, a Jewish pediatrician from Austria who found refuge in Iraq and ultimately committed suicide after failing to rescue his wife and daughter. Wien's inclusion of biographies of Jewish intellectuals—like the editor of the influential cultural magazine Al-Hasid, Anuwar Shaʾul—underscores the vital role played by Jews in a field believed by many historians to be staunchly pro-German. Reviewing the involvement of the Jewish intelligentsia in the campaign for the Palestinian cause during the 1930s, the book establishes that the term “Arab-Jew” was utilized in the Iraqi print market as early as 1938.
Wien's nuanced analysis of the Iraqi press rejects the assumption that it was simply a mouthpiece for different political parties. He takes the press seriously as a prism for understanding the construction of Iraqi national discourses, images of the nation and its youth, concepts of leadership, narratives of the past, and relations to Nazism and fascism. In this latter regard, Wien adds four new dimensions to the existing historiography of the period. First, he demonstrates that reflections on Nazism, fascism, and authoritarianism were situated in a larger discussion concerning concepts of political leadership in which Iraq's next-door neighbors and their leaders were more significant than overseas enemies or allies. Second, Wien argues that not all allusions to Germany should be understood as directly referencing sympathy for Nazism, as many of these narratives celebrated Prussian, rather than Nazi, models.
Third, in addition to reviewing the more familiar dailies, like Al-ʿAlam al-ʿArabi or Al-Istiqlal, Wien introduces other influential print media voices, such as the journal Habazbuz. Often written in the colloquial and featuring cartoons, this journal conveyed nostalgia for the Ottoman past and admiration of Kemalism, predominantly because both served as models for correct military conduct. Another interesting source is the often overlooked Sawt al-Shaʿb, a left-leaning journal with a social-democratic agenda that regularly condemned Nazi politics. Wien is aware, however, of the limits of this public sphere and recognizes that the deliberations concerning the Iraqi nahḍa were conducted in a virtual space that excluded the participation of both the Shiʿi south and the Kurdish north.
Fourth and finally, Wien employs new methodological insights—particularly works by Habermas, Manheim, and Mosse—as a means to understand sociopolitical Iraqi realities and the relationship between nationalism and discipline. Wien is less interested in whether certain phenomena (conscription, education) had their “origins” in German, Italian, French, or British thinking than in the ways in which such phenomena reflected the meaning of being modern in Iraq. Thus, youth movement organizations such as al-Futuwa are seen as powerful vehicles for constructing new notions of masculinity and disciplined behavior, and the conversation about militarism is contextualized in a gendered discourse about creating healthy male bodies in the service of the nation. The diversity within the public sphere and the conflict between generations change Wien's perspective of both the Kaylani coup and the anti-Jewish riots (the farhud) in its aftermath, during which over a hundred Jews were murdered. Rather than presenting the farhud as the well-orchestrated outcome of growing pro-German propaganda in both the state and the public sphere, he understands it as a moment of great chaos in which all sociopolitical boundaries were broken.
Some questions remain unanswered. Wien shies away from the British archive, aware of the colonial perceptions it projects. Still, his arguments might have been enriched by treating the British sources as insightfully as he treats Arabic source material. Second, Wien underscores the Baghdadi public sphere. One wonders, however, whether this sphere was the Iraqi public sphere. Although the Baghdadi press was definitely aimed at the new urban middle classes, other means of expression continued to exist. Neoclassical poetry, for instance, was an important political medium. Whereas some southern intellectuals were excluded from the Baghdadi public sphere, the south had its own culture, with literature written by ʿulamaʾ, journalists, and poets. The Najaf public sphere demonstrates that other issues—land, peasants' rights, tribal revolts—were no less important to members of the Iraqi community. The northern public sphere expressed itself in Turkish and Kurdish in the 1930s.
In addition, transregional networks were highly important. Wien recognizes the instrumental role of the Egyptian press in the Iraqi market. The fact that Iraqis read and wrote for journals published in Egypt, Syria, and Lebanon might lead to a new appreciation of the Arab print market in relation to Baghdad. Although I wholeheartedly support Wien's decision to include Shiʿi, Sunni, Jewish, and Christian intellectuals as part of a shared community of discourse and not to divide them by sectarian affiliations, Wien's findings might have been more complex if he had examined additional public spheres. Finally, Wien could have added more biographies of, or texts written by, social democrats or reform-minded individuals like Kamil Chadirchi, ʿAziz Sharif, ʿAbd al-Fattah Ibrahim, and Jaʿfar abu Timman.
This book represents an indispensable addition to earlier important works (by Marr, Tarboush, Cleveland, and especially Simon) on Iraqi nationalism and complements Davis's recent work emphasizing aspects of Iraqi pluralism. A paperback edition will benefit classes in Iraqi and Middle Eastern history. With recurrent nonsense in the media about “Islamo-Fascism,” it is important to teach a book that illuminates how Iraqi elites themselves nationalized and historicized the Islamic past, how Iraqi national narratives shared many features with those of other nation--states, and how a pro-Fascist outlook was also criticized in the culture of interwar Iraq.
