In recent years George Gershwin scholarship has experienced a revival—something a man of the theater surely would have enjoyed. This resurgence is witnessed in special Gershwin sessions at annual meetings of the Society for American Music, prominent articles in JSAM and other scholarly journals, and a soon to be completed critical edition of Porgy and Bess by Wayne Shirley.Footnote 1 Front and center in this assemblage of scholarship is Howard Pollack's substantial 900-page biography, George Gershwin: His Life and Work.
The sheer bounty of information in this book marks Pollack as one of a very small group of true Gershwin scholars. The first eleven chapters (some 215 pages) concern Gershwin's “life,” and the remaining twenty-five chapters (nearly 500 pages) are given over to the composer's “work,” the most comprehensive summation of Gershwin's oeuvre ever assembled. Pollack integrates a stunning array of sources—it is the rare paragraph without at least one footnoted reference. His research involved a thorough combing of primary documents housed in the Gershwin Collection at the Library of Congress and the archives of the Ira and Leonore Gershwin Trusts, as well as all available secondary literature—scholarly, journalistic, and other. Pollack incorporates several of his own recently conducted interviews, ranging from Gershwin's onetime girlfriend Kitty Carlisle, to Ira Gershwin's nephew and estate trustee Michael Strunsky, to renowned Gershwin interpreter Michael Feinstein. Sixteen inserted plates enhance the text with almost fifty images, several published here for the first time. Back matter includes a hundred pages of endnotes, an extensive selected bibliography, and a meticulously compiled index, itself nearly sixty pages in length.
Although to scholars of American music it may now be well established that Gershwin owed his success not simply to inherent talent, but also to extensive training and considerable effort, the fact that Pollack returns to this point throughout the first portion of the book suggests that constructions of the composer as unlearned continue to abound. A primary objective for Pollack, then, is to challenge twentieth-century depictions of the composer as either a “childlike” (modest and naive) or “flawed” (ambitious and vain) genius (701). Such visions of Gershwin have largely obfuscated his position in the scholarly literature. To this end Pollack's separation of his book into two parts serves an important function. The first section, through the exploration of Gershwin's musical education (formal and informal, classical and popular) and his associations (personal and professional), forms an extended argument for taking Gershwin's music seriously—not only his compositions for the concert hall, which have long dominated scholarship on the composer, but also his equally important works for the stage. Detaching Gershwin's life from his work also allows Pollack to explore more fully aspects of the composer's biography at the outset, enhancing considerations of his music that follow in part 2. On its own, either portion represents a significant contribution to Gershwin scholarship; together, an unparalleled portrait of the composer emerges.
One of the strengths of Pollack's volume (and reasons for its length) is this method of bringing aspects of Gershwin's career into greater focus by placing them in relation to the broader world in which he lived. The author achieves this contextual richness through frequent excursions, which at first appear tangential to the central narrative, but in fact detail key figures and musical trends that directly or indirectly influenced Gershwin. In a chapter titled “Gershwin and the New Popular Music,” Pollack introduces not only likely musical personalities of the 1910s, such as W. C. Handy and James Reese Europe, but also Vernon and Irene Castle (57–59). This popular dance duo makes no appearance in previous Gershwin biographies. Although the composer never worked with the Castles directly, Pollack revealingly connects their popularization of various social dances, such as the foxtrot, to Gershwin's early compositional output: “The majority of his piano rolls, for instance, were fox-trots, as were many of the numbers from his shows. Even the great ‘Andantino’ theme from the Rhapsody in Blue could be described as in fox-trot rhythm” (58).
Pollack also uses such narrative diversions to probe larger academic questions. In a chapter titled “The Popular Pianist,” Pollack details the mechanics and cultural significance of player pianos in the first quarter of the twentieth century (66–71). Although such information appears in other publications, its specific location here interrogates the extent to which Gershwin's piano rolls can serve as accurate documents of his pianism.
Gershwin's musical exploration emerges continuously in the “life” portion of this book. Although Pollack eventually treats the composer's later failed attempts to study with Maurice Ravel, Nadia Boulanger, and Igor Stravinsky, as well as his more successful ventures with Henry Cowell, Wallingford Riegger, and Joseph Schillinger, he places special emphasis on Gershwin's early training. For example, Pollack points to Susan Neimoyer's recent dissertation on Gershwin's early formal instruction as evidence that “challenge[s] the common notion of Gershwin as an untrained composer who, after the Rhapsody, attempted to redress his lack of schooling through some serious, if fitful, study. In fact, even as a young man Gershwin acquired a much more extensive musical education than typically acknowledged, and though he continued his studies after the Rhapsody, that only extended long-standing goals” (38–39).Footnote 2
Although Pollack thoroughly explores Gershwin's connections to the classical music of Europe and America, he states that Gershwin “did not cultivate the sort of solidarity found among those circles associated with Varèse and Cowell or Copland and Sessions.” Rather, Gershwin's “greatest affinity and loyalty were always to Broadway composers, including those, like Duke and Levant, who were, like himself, active in more serious realms as well” (156). By establishing Gershwin's ongoing presence in the Broadway community, even as his concert career flourished, Pollack emphasizes the “deep connection between his music and the popular theatrical genres of his time” (xiv). As such, Pollack begins to address connections between Gershwin's concert music and the Broadway stage that have long remained underexplored in the historiography of the composer.
A great accomplishment of this book is Pollack's thorough and insightful account of Gershwin's complete output—from his earliest known composition, “Ragging the Traumerei” (ca. 1913) to posthumous songs completed by his brother Ira for the 1964 film Kiss Me, Stupid. The twenty-six chapters in the second portion of the biography are largely chronological, with some covering several years—such as the chapter “From Morris Gest's Midnight Whirl (1919) to The Perfect Fool (1921)”—and others focusing on just a single project—such as the chapter “Of Thee I Sing (1931).” In the case of Porgy and Bess (1935), which has received the most scholarly attention of any work by Gershwin, Pollack divides his coverage into four adjacent chapters: the creation of the work, its first production, revivals, and its history of recordings on disc and film.
Pollack telescopes this same fourfold set of concerns addressed by his multichapter assessment of Porgy and Bess onto each composition discussed in the second portion of this volume. Whereas previous book-length studies of Gershwin tended to consider his works only in a historical context, Pollack considers both genesis and reception. To the extent that each work has maintained a cultural presence, this approach allows for a more thorough assessment of the works' respective legacies throughout the twentieth century. Pollack considers not only what Gershwin's music meant historically, but also what challenges it presents us today. For example, he notes the transformation of Funny Face (1927) from its original Broadway presentation through a 1957 Paramount Pictures film, regional revivals, and a successful reworking of the music into a new book for the 1983 hit My One and Only as part of a larger consideration of “accommodating the composer's musical-comedy scores to late-twentieth-century expectations and sensibilities” (416).
In addition to reception, Pollack's compelling presentation of Gershwin's compositions owes much to its expanded integration of primary source materials. The much-heralded 1982 discovery of musical theater manuscripts in a Warner Brothers warehouse in Secaucus, New Jersey, recovered much Gershwin-related material. Although scholars have been reaping the benefits of this treasure trove for many years (see Tommy Krasker's recorded reconstructions of shows such as Oh, Kay! and Pardon My English on the Nonesuch label, for example), Pollack's biography is the first to integrate a broad consideration of these materials. Also of note is the author's insightful integration of Gershwin's various “tune” and “theme” notebooks, sketches, and outlines, first introduced in his discussion of Gershwin's creative process in part 1 (178–79). See, for example, his analysis of the sketches for An American in Paris in support of a “self-portrait” reading of the composition, which leads Pollack to conclude: “No other piece by Gershwin seems quite so confessional” (436).
Pollack supports his evaluation of Gershwin as “fundamentally a man of the theater” (xiv) with considerable coverage of Gershwin's stage works, including his revues and musicals both on Broadway and in London's West End. For each work the author examines its creation and composition, considers various aspects of the songs (often including a brief harmonic, melodic, or lyrical analysis), provides sketches of related key personnel (the producers, stars, musicians, creative team, etc.), and presents a full synopsis of the plot. This final aspect represents an important accomplishment, given the fragmentary nature of surviving scripts and other book-related materials. Pollack even manages to reconstruct the 1921 musical A Dangerous Maid, for which no known book survives (255–56). These plot summaries detail the specific location of musical numbers within a given show, thereby reattaching Gershwin's songs to their original context. This process allows the author to draw out the inherent dramatic integrity of songs long considered simply from a melodic or a harmonic point of view. See, for example, his discussion of the variable appearance and interpretation of “Someone to Watch over Me” in Oh, Kay! (1926; 384), or the purposeful “Stephen Foster–like ambiance” of “Liza” in Show Girl (1929; 456).
Because of its largely chronological organization, Pollack's presentation of Gershwin's oeuvre establishes intriguing bridges between the concert and the stage works, which would be less obvious if he took a thematic or genre-based organizational approach. Pollack offers, for example, the overture to Of Thee I Sing (1931) as “precedence” for the introduction of the Cuban Overture (1932), which also develops “bits and pieces of the A section's two principal themes in anticipation of their eventual arrival” (537). Likewise, the author asserts a link between the “harmonic sophistication” and “metrical dislocations” of the Concerto in F (1925) and the score to Oh, Kay! (1926), which “suggests further that Gershwin's concert pieces not only drew on but helped nourish his work in theater” (350). With such connections Pollack's Gershwin emerges not as the traditionally characterized crossover artist (moving from popular to classical), but rather as one who decided “from the very beginning [to] plant one foot on each side of the tracks and attempt to straddle them as firmly as he could” (40).
Unfortunately, the complete lack of musical examples detracts from many of Pollack's rich musical observations. Although we can only guess as to the reasons for this absence—copyright issues, cost of reproduction, the already extensive length of the book—it forces readers to locate sheet music on their own if they are to benefit fully from Pollack's multitudinous insights, and it highlights the pressing need for a Gershwin complete-works edition. We may not require a full score of Porgy and Bess to appreciate Pollack's extensive catalog of the opera's leitmotifs, but musical examples would certainly clarify the differences between the “jagged motive (act I, one after 22) and a downward cascading gesture (act I, two before 23) that depict the craps game” (584–85). The absence of examples becomes particularly aggravating where commercially available sheet music remains hard to locate. In the final sentence of chapter 14, Pollack punctuates his observation that Our Nell (1922) “engaged a country idiom twenty years before Oklahoma!” by stating that the “similarities between [Gershwin's] slightly daffy ‘Walking Home with Angeline’ and [Rodgers'] more quaint ‘Surrey with the Fringe on Top’ remain telling” (278). Without further explanation or a musical example, this potentially provocative observation loses all momentum.
Pollack has primed the investigative pump for anyone commencing work on Gershwin with the plethora of topics and issues he tackles. Just a few possibilities for future investigation include a thorough examination of Gershwin's London shows (both composed or adapted for the West End), how the teachings of Edward Kilenyi and Rubin Goldmark (previously connected only to Gershwin's concert works) came to bear on his popular songs, the “Music by Gershwin” radio broadcasts of 1934, and a reconsideration of the largely ignored revival of Strike Up the Band (1930), with greater focus on the political ideology of its eventually blacklisted book rewriter Morrie Ryskind.
This tome also has much to offer to the non-Gershwin specialist. Each chapter in the first section includes discussion of numerous cultural figures, not merely from the concert and stage world, but also from New York society, such as those in attendance at the parties of Cartier executive Jules Glaenzer and the racially integrated gatherings of critic Carl Van Vechten. Furthermore, courses on American music would benefit from the selective incorporation of chapters from Pollack's book—a sort of musicological “Choose Your Own Adventure” tailored to the focus of the class. Those interested in aspects of biography, including the myriad issues presented by undertaking a subject as popular as Gershwin, could read chapters 1, 6, and 11: “Gershwin and His Family,” “Gershwin among His Friends,” and “Gershwin the Man.” For a case study in a larger examination of how Broadway musicals were created throughout the twentieth century, read the second half of chapter 10 (“Working Methods”), which discusses his collaborative process with Ira, in tandem with any one of a variety of chapters on specific shows from the “works” portion.
Although piecemeal consumption of this book may fend off potential information overload, for the scholar it ultimately precludes a full appreciation of Pollack's incredible facility with American music and culture of this period. Like Edward Jablonski's Gershwin: A Biography (1987), the publication of Pollack's George Gershwin: His Life and Work will emerge as a watershed event in scholarship on the composer. It stands as a monument to all that we presently know about Gershwin as both man and musician and serves as an important new point of departure for the next generation of Gershwin scholarship.
