As the central authority of the Mughal Empire collapsed and was replaced with multiple centres of power and culture, in historiography the eighteenth century in North India is often considered through the lens of crisis, disintegration and instability.Footnote 2 Delhi, decentred, became only one of a number of areas of social and political negotiation, partially eclipsed by new cities of probably greater political and cultural significance. These cities had been founded by notables and officials of the declining empire who established themselves as independent rulers: Farrukhabad, Najibabad and Rampur under the Rohillas, Faizabad and Lucknow under the nawabs of Awadh and Murshidabad in Bengal.Footnote 3 Similarly, a number of the towns and administrative centres (qasbas) in Awadh, – for example, Nasirabad, Sandila, Sihali (the hometown of the divines and sages of Farangi Mahall in Lucknow), Kakori and Khayrabad – rose to prominence, producing their own forms of courtly and learned culture that provided scholars and literati for the new centres such as Lucknow. In this sense, the qasbas were depositories and determinants of the contested Islamic traditions: Sunni vs. Shiʿi, scripturalist vs. rationalist, nomocentric vs. mystically inclined.Footnote 4 Of great significance in this process was the rise of successor states and new centres that had been founded and ruled by Shiʿi notables, usually of Iranian origin, who promoted their faith to legitimise their authority, patronising both the culture and scholarship of the Shiʿi learned classes.
The most prominent of these areas was Awadh, focusing first on Faizabad and then later on Lucknow. Given the previous marginality of the Shiʿi presence in North India (at least beyond some limited elite circles at the Mughal court, especially in the reign of Jahangir), the power that lay with the Shiʿi notables in these new centres, as well as at the court in Delhi, meant that Shiʿi thought and practices flourished throughout the century. In the face of this new challenge, there was a striking response from Sunni elites, both political and religious. In the eighteenth century there was a spike in polemical literature produced by both sides in the shape of learned theological treatises, popular disputational tracts, poetic invectives, and commemoration and satire. The new Persianate and Shiʿi centres of power encouraged new waves of migrations of scholars and literati to India, especially Iranian Shiʿi ʿulamaʾ, who found a welcome home in Awadh as recounted by Hazin-i Lahiji (d. 1766) and Aqa Ahmad Bihbahani (d. 1819), although they did not fail to grumble about the weather and the stupidity of their generous hosts.Footnote 5 While Shiʿi commemorations, particularly during Muharram, were established and patronised by notables, they became more prominent in the period and led to Sunni condemnations especially at the centre of empire in Delhi.Footnote 6
It is within these new contexts - the challenge of power, new opportunities of patronage and the ascendance of Shiʿi power - that the career of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli and his role in the formulation of a new Shiʿi theological and political dispensation in Awadh needs to be examined. For those familiar with North Indian Shiʿi Islam, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli (1753–1820) is a well-known scholar credited with the formation of a rationalising hierocracy in the new Shiʿi polity of Awadh in North India at the end of the eighteenth century. The processes by which the elites established Twelver Shiʿi doctrines and their practices, disseminating them so much that they still provide the basic motifs and parameters of modern Shiʿi identity in the subcontinent, have been studied by Juan Cole and others. Awadh witnessed the development of a political theology, the establishment of institutions of learning and commemoration, and the production of literature for disseminating Shiʿi ideas in the scholarly and elite Mughal languages of Arabic and Persian as well as in the vernacular Urdu. At the heart of Awadhi culture lay a vernacularisation and naturalisation of Shiʿi Islam within an Indian milieu.Footnote 7
While his polemical works countering anti-Shiʿi texts such as Tuhfa-yi isnaʿashariya [Gift for the Twelver Shiʿa] of Shah ʿAbd al-ʿAziz (1745–1823), and his attacks on Sufis and Akhbaris who contended with him over the central questions of spiritual authority, have been the subjects of some studies, the broad outlines of Dildar ʿAli's philosophical works and philosophical theology – which provided the foundations for these polemics and exchanges – have been rather neglected. This article will draw upon his major theological texts, such as Mirʾat al-ʿuqul fi ʿilm usul al-din [Mirrors of the intellect expounding the science of the principles of the faith], better known as ʿImad al-Islam [The foundation of Islam], his anti-Sufi polemic al-Shihab al-thaqib [The lightening strike] and his condemnation of Akhbarism, Asas al-usul [The basis of jurisprudence]. Significantly all of these works were written in Arabic, demonstrating his scholarly credentials and reflecting his desire to establish the new theology on a firm foundation to demonstrate the contribution of Indian Shiʿi ʿulama to the new directions in thought and institutional practice emerging in Iran and Iraq. The most important of these is ʿImad al-Islam. Divided into the classic five-fold scheme of Shiʿi theology, it not only demonstrates the contribution of the ʿulama of India to Shiʿi thought towards a “new theology”, it also posits the basic metaphysical foundations for the critique of others, whether Sunni scholars of Farangi Mahall and elsewhere, Sufi pirs or traditionist Akhbaris. It was widely disseminated and popular in scholarly Shiʿi circles well beyond the annexation of the Awadh state. In some concluding remarks, this article will also consider some of the critiques of his work.
Sayyid Dildar ʿAli was born into a family of Naqvi sayyids in Jaʾis-Nasirabad in Rae Bareilly district of Awadh in 1166/1752–1753.Footnote 8 His father Sayyid Muʿin bin ʿAbd al-Hadi was a local landowner and provided his son with the leisure to pursue scholarship. He began his early studies in the dars-i nizami tradition of intellectual disciplines with both Sunni and Shiʿi teachers: Sayyid Ghulam Husain Dakani Ilahabadi, Mulla Haydar ʿAli Sandilvi (d. 1225/1810, the Sunni son of the Shiʿi philosopher Mulla Hamdullah) and Mulla Babullah Barelwi Jaunpuri who were philosophers.Footnote 9 He later pursued his studies with the leading Shiʿi savant of Awadh, Tafazzul Husayn Khan (d. 1801) between 1769 and 1772, particularly focusing on astronomy and the exact sciences, and with the renowned Mulla ʿAbd ʿAli Bahr al-ʿUlum of Farangi Mahall (d. 1801) for two years at Shahjahanpur, the capital of Hafiz Rahmat Khan until his defeat by Shujaʿ al-Dawla in 1774.Footnote 10 He was also reported to have disputed with Mulla Hasan (d. 1794) of Farangi Mahall, both in Shahjahanpur and Lucknow. At this stage, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli was primarily someone with a keen mind for philosophy – while at the same time, consistent with the Shiʿi preferences in North India, a scripturalist Akhbari who was hostile to independent legal reasoning in the derivation of precepts. Such a combination seems contradictory and one wonders whether the insistence upon a juvenile scripturalism was used later as a trope to denigrate the position; while it is often asserted that the Shiʿa in North India were Akhbari up to this point, we do not have much contemporary evidence for this. However, it does indicate the success of the intellectual tendency of the dars-i nizami in influencing scholarship between the Sunni shaikhzadas of the towns of Awadh, extending to the Shiʿi landowners and ʿulama. After the defeat of the Rohillas, and the establishment of Lucknow as the new capital of Shujaʿ al-Dawla in 1775, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli moved there and soon came to the attention of the vizier Hasan Riza Khan (served 1776–1798), a Mughal notable married into the family of the nawabs and renowned patron of poets and scholars.Footnote 11
Given the absence of a serious class of ʿulama in the new state, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli was sent by Hasan Riza Khan to study in the shrine cities of Iraq in 1779. He was funded by the notable Almas ʿAli Khan who had urged the vizier to send some Akhbari-minded young scholars to Iraq to finish their education.Footnote 12 He was supposedly so attached to the Akhbari cause that the only book that he took to Iraq was al-Fawaʾid al-madaniya [Medinan arguments) of Muhammad Amin Astarabadi (d. 1626). He spent three years there, changed his position to an Usuli one, open to the use of independent legal reasoning, and picked up ijazas (certificates authorising juristic practice) from the eminent Shaikh Muhammad Baqir ‘Vahid’ Bihbahani (d. 1791). The latter was the scholar and religious leader in Karbala most responsible for eradicating Akhbaris from the shrine cities. His students included Sayyid Muhammad Mahdi Tabatabaʾi Bahr al-ʿUlum (d. 1799) and Shaikh Jaʿfar Najafi Kashif al-Ghitaʾ (d. 1813) – they also issued certificates for Sayyid Dildar ʿAli.Footnote 13 It was in Najaf that he first encountered al-Shawahid al-Makkiya [Meccan witnesses] of Sayyid Nur al-Din ʿAli al-ʿAmili (d. 1658), a refutation of Astarabadi, although he did not find it very convincing – a position that he later reiterated in his Asas al-usul. In Mashhad on his return to India, he received an ijaza from Sayyid Mahdi Shahristani Isfahani (d. 1803), a scholar with an established link to the court in Lucknow.
Back in Lucknow in 1781, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli became well established. The recipient of the patronage of Bahu Begum, he received the title of mujtahid al-ʿasr (leading jurist of the age) from Asaf al-Dawla,Footnote 14 and was by the end of his life such an important figure that he was the one who crowned Ghazi ud-Din Hayder in 1819 as the first King of Awadh.Footnote 15 He was awarded the income of nine tax-exempt villages as well as a stipend of 5,000 rupees.Footnote 16 Mulla Muhammad ʿAli Kashmiri wrote a treatise on the need for the new Shiʿi state to establish the Friday prayers and suggested Sayyid Dildar ʿAli as a worthy prayer leader; one source on the reign of Asaf al-Dawla even suggests that he was the first person to lead Shiʿi congregational prayers in North India.Footnote 17 Earlier Shiʿi ʿulama such as the Akhbari court mufti Sayyid Muhammad ʿAskari Jaunpuri (d. 1777) opposed the establishment of the congregational prayers partly in order not to arouse the hostility of the Sunnis. On the entreaty of the vizier, the first Friday congregation was held in Lucknow on the significant date of 13 Rajab 1200/May 1786.Footnote 18 Sayyid Dildar ʿAli used the pulpit at the recently completed Asafiyya mosque to spread his theology, and a collection of his sermons was published as Favaʾid-i Asafiya. He later wrote an independent treatise on the obligation to establish the Friday prayers. Through his link to the ʿulama in Iraq, ties were strengthened – more students went there to study and the Awadh state invested more in developing the infrastructure of the shrine cities, including the famous Hindiyya canal near Karbala to channel water for the city (funded by Asaf al-Dawla) and provided gifts for the upkeep and repair of the shrines themselves, especially after the Wahhabi attacks in 1801 and 1802.Footnote 19
Sayyid Dildar ʿAli established a dynasty of scholars known now as the khandan-i-ijtihad.Footnote 20 He had five sons, the most important of whom were the eldest Sayyid Muhammad (1784–1867), who continued his father's theological project writing works against Akhbaris and penning al-ʿUjala al-nafiʿa [The beneficial dawning] on Shiʿi theology, and under royal charter establishing Madrasa-yi Sultaniya in the 1840s, and his youngest Sayyid Husayn (1797–1856) known as Sayyid al-ʿUlamaʾ.Footnote 21 Sayyid Mahdi (1793–1816) died relatively young in Lucknow. Sayyid Muhammad continued his quietist policy, for which his father had been criticised by Ahmad Bihbahani, refusing to sanction jihad in 1857, relying on the traditional Shiʿi position of the impermissibility of declaring jihad in the absence of the Hidden Imam. Two other sons travelled and studied extensively in Iraq: Sayyid Hasan (1791–1844) and Sayyid ʿAli (1786–1843), who lived in Karbala and was closely associated with the Shaikhi (hence heterodox Shiʿi) leader Sayyid Kazim Rashti (d. 1843) who gave him an ijaza.Footnote 22 On 19 Rajab 1235/2 May 1820, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli died, having declared his son Sayyid Muhammad, who became known as Sultan al-ʿulama, his successor and the leading mujtahid and religious functionary of the state.Footnote 23 Posthumously he became known as Ghufran-i maʾab (the forgiven).
The role of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli in promoting a new Shiʿi theology should be viewed within the context of the relationship between the ʿulama and power in the new Awadh state. Lucknow was a major centre, built as a Shiʿi city under Asaf al-Dawla once the capital shifted in 1775 from Faizabad, with the new Bara Imambara, Asafiya mosque and other major monuments to inscribe the faith of the rulers on the public space.Footnote 24 The court, like the Safavid one before it, actively promoted popular Shiʿi practice, established institutions, imambaras and similar public buildings.Footnote 25 A key feature of popular Shiʿism was the crafting of a new literature of mourning for the martyrs of Karbala through marsiyas. Its centrality to poetry in the city was such that some have judged the Lucknow ‘school’ of Urdu literature to be inferior because of its excessive panegyrics and dirges, especially on religious topics, unbridled eroticism untempered by mystical love and the privileging of Arabic and Persian constructions and terminology over Hindi.Footnote 26 In this sense, some literary critics have considered the literature of Awadh to be artificial, reflecting the affected decadence of the nawabi court. The marsiya itself was primarily a mode for the naturalisation of a Shiʿi poetical consciousness and the popularisation of its sentiment within an Awadhi context and cultural idiom – a process successfully patronised by the nawabs and produced by poets such as Mir Anis (d. 1874) and Mirza Dabir (d. 1875).Footnote 27
Alongside the state's identity, its promotion of Shiʿi culture, within the market of ideas in North India, there was a need for a theology to bolster the ideology of the state as a vigorous Shiʿi kingdom. This was provided by Sayyid Dildar ʿAli. The core of this article's argument is that the promotion of a new Shiʿi theology had three elements: the first was the establishment of the rational method and an intra-Shiʿi championing of the Usuli method against Akhbari scripturalism; the second was a challenge to the power of Sufi shaikhs, both Sunni and Shiʿi, and a marginalisation of mystical speculation, especially monorealism, (wahdat al-wujud) among the Shiʿa; and the third was a rational and polemical defeat of Sunni theology. The last would emphasise the triumph of Shiʿi Islam in Awadh, displacing the ideology of the qasbas and the shaikhzadas – the latter included the deployment of the intellectual tools of the dars-i nizami against its progenitors in the Farangi Mahall. These were achieved through the production of texts, perpetuated and disseminated through presses and teaching circles, and by means of political influence and policy at court, especially through Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's scholarly network. His aim was to forge a distinctive Shiʿi identity in the service of the state.Footnote 28
Establishing Usuli method and reason
A key element in establishing the Usuli rational tradition lay in attacking the Akhbariya, following the method of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's teachers in Iraq. Soon after his return to Lucknow, and probably before 1786, he wrote Asas al-usul [The foundation of jurisprudence], which was used later as a textbook by his sons at their seminary and had already been lithographed in Lucknow in 1848 by the Muḥammadiya press. The choice of Arabic as the medium of composition was significant – other works were written in Persian but Arabic was used to demonstrate his scholarly credentials, especially as he would usually send his works (as would his students) to the scholars in Iraq for their recognition. His fundamental goal was to delegitimise the Akhbaris’ strict adherence solely to the text and to justify the use of reason in the derivation of law – hence to legitimise the process of ijtihad (independent legal reasoning).
In his introduction, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli makes it clear that he wrote the work to establish the fundamental importance of reason as a divinely bestowed act of grace; it is ʿaql [reason] that distinguishes humans, and its correct use obviates the possibility of being deceived and deluded.Footnote 29 This is entirely consistent with classical Shiʿi theology that privileges the innate faculty of reason as an act of grace and inner revelation provided by God to facilitate believers’ ability to fulfil their moral obligations.Footnote 30 His interest lies in the use of reason for deriving law and the ethical precepts that ought to be followed in ritual practice and social transactions. This is because, as he says, the best intellectual inquiry after reflection upon the theology of the nature of divine unity is to understand the law and how to derive it since that truly is the ‘best inheritance of the Prophet and the Imams’. He may have emphasised this in order to locate jurisprudence and legal theory at the heart of Shiʿi scholarly endeavour, particularly placing philosophy below it. This was significant given the dominance of philosophy in the dars-i nizami curriculum. He clarifies that he wrote the work because he had not been convinced by previous refutations of the akhbariya, especially Astarabadi’s, of their manifesto al-Fawaʾid al-madaniya Footnote 31 He criticises false accusations against scholars of the past, especially defending Ibn Mutahhar al-Hilli (d. 1325), who was accused by Astarabadi of inventing legal theory in the Shiʿi context as a discipline borrowed from the Sunnis. Sayyid Dildar ʿAli argues that the accusation is false: that, in fact, the Shiʿa had practiced rational inquiry in respect of the derivation of law much before the medieval period. In opposition to the Akhbari claim of a historical rupture between the tradition of the Imams and their companions and the later medieval Shiʿi tradition influenced by Sunni jurisprudence and Muʿtazili theology, he argues for a rationalist continuity from the companions of the Imams through to his own teachers.Footnote 32 As ever, one discerns the invention of a tradition extending back to the age of the Imams as a means for establishing the authority of his rationalist agenda. Setting aside the naive hermeneutics of the Akhbariya, he insists on the necessity to evaluate critically the texts attributed to the Imams, especially in the light of the two key hermeneutical tools of legal theory, namely reason and juristic, scholarly consensus.
Following the Usuli method, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli divides the text into four sections (maqasid). The first two relate to the nature of the scripture, both the Qurʾan and reports from the Prophet and Imams; and in what sense once one has investigated the probity and reliability of the text, especially in the case of hadith, one needs to investigate how that text can constitute a proof or a material cause for deriving a ruling. The second section is more extensive – the hadith are far more copious and significant for the formulation of the law than the rather restricted number of Qurʾan verses that deal with such matters. The third section is on scholarly consensus, which was controversial since it was felt that consensus is rarely obtained. It was further problematic because it was a tool used by Sunnis to marginalise the Shiʿa and their adherence to the charismatic and absolute authority of the Imam. But perhaps the most important is the fourth section on the nature of the probative force (ḥujjiya) of reason alongside what the emerging tradition was calling the procedural instruments (usul ʿamaliya) such as precaution that were used by jurists to provide guidance for believers in the absence of clear textual proofs and established legal precepts. This section is divided into six chapters (fusul). The first relates to a key theological premise: that both the moral good and the moral evil are accessible to rational discernment independently of revelation (al-husn wa-l-qubh ʿaqliyan).Footnote 33 Just as humans arrive at a recognition of the existence of God and the moral obligation that it entails through reason, so too can they broadly understand, rationally, in the absence of scriptural diktat, fundamental issues of moral goods and evils. This was significant, not only because the Akhbaris disputed the position but also because the Farangi Mahall scholars, on account of their adherence to Maturidi theology as evinced in the Musallam al-thubut of Muhibbullah Bihari (d. 1707) and its commentary by Bahr al-ʿUlum, criticised the unfettered use of reason as an independent moral compass, targeting the Shiʿa.Footnote 34 On the basis of rational discernment, the next chapter provides the procedure for establishing the prohibition or compulsion of an act based purely on reason. This is followed by a theological consideration of the status of acts before revelation came – a key rational problem indicating that revelation is not necessary to establish whether an act is permissible or prohibited. Attached to this is a discussion of the basic permissibility of acts in the absence of a prohibition (asalat al-ibaha).Footnote 35 The fourth chapter is on the rational principle of the presumption of the status quo ante (al-istishab): unless one has positive proof to the contrary, one assumes that a previous state still obtains – the classic example is the state of ritual purity such that as long as one is not aware of a cause of the loss of the purity, one assumes that it persists. The penultimate chapter looks at forms of argumentation, on legal syllogistics. The final chapter considers the problem of potential confusion between different rationally derived positions and the recommendation of precaution (al-ihtiyat). The text demonstrates his skill as a trained jurist, capable of formulating rational arguments in defence of his positions.
The extensive nature of the rational argumentation and the formulation of a clearly laid out set of principles makes Asas al-usul suitable as a school text, which one suspects was certainly part of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's intention. In fact, one can discern in each of his theological endeavours an attempt to establish his own particular contribution through the production of a text that could be perpetuated in a pedagogical setting. Alongside the text, Usuli rationalism was promoted through a serious of shorter texts in Persian that he wrote either as collections of responsa and through his sermons from the Friday pulpit, the first set of which, Fawaʾid-i Asafiyya, were based on the first year of official Friday congregational prayers in Lucknow in 1200/1786. The establishment of Friday prayers, further defended in a Risala-yi jumʿa, provided a pulpit for the dissemination of official religious doctrine, and especially a vehicle for promoting his own authority and providing a platform for criticising and marginalising his rivals at court. Other institutions used to promote this element of the new theology were official appointments of Shiʿi jurists to the judiciary, the imposition of Shiʿi systems of taxation and the development of informal circles of learning around him into the official Madrasa-yi Sultaniya under his son Sayyid Muhammad.
Attack on Sufism
The second element of the new theology was the attack on Sufism, on the ideas of Sufi metaphysics and the authority of Sufi shaikhs among the nobility of Awadh. Sufis had been recipients of court patronage and constituted a clear threat to claims of clerical authority articulated by the Usulis and required both a political and an intellectual response. Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's main work in this endeavour was Al-Shihab al-thaqib [The lightening strike], again written in Arabic for scholars and dedicated to his patron Sarfaraz al-Dawla Hasan Riza Khan. The text begins with an eloquent proemium in rhyming prose (sajʿ) to demonstrate his ability in Arabic. He laments the fact that people are turning to Sufi shaikhs, away from the teachings of the Prophet and his successors who are the true authorities and proofs of God. To this end, he cites two themes of anti-Sufi writing well attested in Safavid works. First, the Caliphs in early Islam had promoted Sufis and philosophers to turn people away from the family of the Prophet. He cites the example of the ʿAbbasid Caliph al-Maʾmun (d. 833) who tried to humiliate the eighth Shiʿi Imam ʿAli al-Rida (d. 818) by setting up disputations with theologians and philosophers, using “heresy” to create discord and strife and distract people from the Imams.Footnote 36 Sufism was thus a conspiracy to destroy Shiʿism. Second, the Imams themselves had condemned Sufis as “representatives of Satan”, and had condemned philosophers as corruptors of the people. The very survival of Shiʿism was only due to the diligence and courage of the “true ʿulama” who had opposed Sufis and philosophers and “made their heresy and unbelief” clear to the community. It is the scholars who had, and have, the authority to condemn heresy and provide guidance for the people.Footnote 37 Since the ʿulama are arbiters of the true faith, they have the authority and obligation to fight against heresy. It is therefore clear that Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's argument is concerned with bolstering his own authority, and that of his class of jurists opposed to Sufism. In the Safavid period, with the work in particular of Mulla Tahir Qummi (d. 1098/1688), one discerns this connection between the illegitimacy of Sufism and philosophy, especially because the latter entails an acceptance of the doctrine of being espoused by the former – and this is clear in al-Fawaʾid al-diniya [Religious Arguments] and Hikmat al-ʿarifin [Philosophy of the mystics].Footnote 38 In these texts, the doctrine of the unity of being (wahdat al-wujud) espoused by the Sunni Sufi Ibn ʿArabi (d. 1240) is condemned in particular – and it is instructive that Sayyid Dildar ʿAli spends most of his time delegitimising this doctrine after a careful reformulation of it.
Al-Shihab al-thaqib is divided into four sections and a conclusion. The first section, comprising eight chapters, examines the doctrine of being as expressed by Sufis, philosophers and theologians and is a rational consideration of their argument, designed to show that the Sufi position on the unity of being, that all that exists is a singular reality whose referent is ultimately God, is not only intellectually indefensible and demonstrably false (in the standard Aristotelian sense of proof) but also confused. The second section, divided into six chapters, examines the scriptural texts adduced by Sufis, including Shiʿi Sufis like Sayyid Haidar Amuli (d. 1385), whose ideas and works were popular in India, in favour of the doctrine of the unity of being. Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's strategy here is not only to draw into question the reliability and probity of these texts, which in many cases of sayings attributed to the Prophet and the Imams are questionable in their ‘authenticity’ but also to raise the hermeneutical problem of how one ought to read and make sense of them. Where the texts are indisputable, such as Qurʾanic verses and some of the hadith, the argument that draws upon them to prove unity of being is disputed and disproved. The third section then moves onto claims made by Sufis. It is divided into two parts. The first disputes the validity of claims of inner revelation: Sufis claimed that they understood reality and could even verify texts through some process of inspiration or even revelation known as kashf. Deconstructing the notion of kashf and the claims and statements of famous (Sunni) Sufis of the past is an important element of his method in this section. Secondly, it could be taken as an indirect critique of Akhbari methodology since their thinkers, such as Shaikh Yusuf al-Bahrani (d. 1772), claimed to use kashf to verify the authenticity of sayings of the Prophet and the Imams. Part of the critique of kashf relates to the implication that it suggests a shortcoming on the part of the Prophet and the Imams – surely, as representatives of God, they should have informed their community of the truth of things. Their inability to do so is therefore shown up by the claims of Sufis to “know better”. The second part of this section relates to the “innovations of Sufis”, their embrace of music and dance as ritual practice – an important established theme of Safavid anti-Sufi texts – and their socially transgressive promotion of libertinism.Footnote 39 A common feature of heretication, clearly manifest in anti-Sufi texts as early as the medieval period, is the accusation of sexual licentiousness. The final aspect of this section relates to the “numerous sects’” among Sufis. Consistent with heresiographical method, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's enumeration of the sects among Sufis – he draws upon earlier texts such as Hadiqat al-Shiʿa [Garden of the Shiʿa] from the middle of the seventeenth century – is designed to show that if these people were so correct about their vision of reality, why did they disagree so much among themselves?Footnote 40 The fourth section is an attempt to respond to calumnies projected by Sufis against the jurists and an attempt at refuting them.
Divided into six chapters, the conclusion makes it clear why Sayyid Dildar ʿAli believes it necessary to write a condemnation of Sufism. First, he has a duty to enjoin good and forbid evil (an important obligation in Shiʿi theology) and as he sees Sufism as an evil, he is obliged to warn people. Second, he has a duty to warn people to steer clear of gatherings of innovation (bidʿa): the social popularity of Sufi practice in the towns of Awadh necessitates this warning. Third, since it is prohibited to follow the enemies of the faith – and here he means Sunni Sufis, who distract people from following the Imams and their representatives the Shiʿi jurists - he must warn them of this prohibition. Fourth, it is permissible, and indeed required, to curse innovators – and Sufis, as the texts cited by him from the Imams make clear, are innovators. Fifth, belief in the unity of being is clear heresy and must be proclaimed as such. Finally, as a jurist with a theological and moral obligation, he must call people to repent – once people are convinced of the evil of Sufi ideas and practices, they can repent and return to the fold of the faith. He follows up this text with a Persian version that is shorter entitled Risala-yi radd-i mazhab-i sufiya [Refutation of the religion of the Sufis]. While there is much in it that follows earlier Safavid patterns, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli makes his own contributions, especially in his exposition of the philosophy of being in the first section, demonstrating his skill in the tradition of Mulla Sadra (d. 1635), on whose Sharh al-hidaya [Commentary on the guidance], the main philosophical text of the dars-i nizami, he wrote a marginalia.
What is remarkable about this anti-Sufism is its condemnation of the doctrine of the unity of being. While this focus is clear in Safavid sources, there are also particular reasons for this, deriving from his context. First, we know that the school of Ibn ʿArabi and the doctrine of the unity of being was the dominant idea of Awadh Sufis, both among the Chishtiya and others, including major figures who were associated with the court.Footnote 41 Shah ʿAli Akbar Husaini Mawdudi Chishti of Faizabad (d. 1210/1795), who led his own Friday prayers (at a shrine in Ayodhya) that were frequented by Shiʿa and patronised by the vizier Sayyid Hasan Riza Khan and Shah Khairullah Naqshbandi, was one such prominent individual.Footnote 42 Mawdudi was a descendent of the founder of the Chishti order, a sayyid and known to have tafzili views (preferring ʿAli over Abu Bakr on the issue of succession to the Prophet). Hence, he was seen as a philo-Shiʿi, and a proponent not only of the use of devotional music but also an ardent defender of the monism of Ibn ʿArabi. He was an influential person at court. Implicitly the attack was on the Shah Wali Allah tradition, associated with the major theological figure of Delhi whose influence extended to Awadh and who was also known to have penned anti-Shiʿi polemics.Footnote 43 An attack on the unity of being was, therefore, intended to discredit and delegimitise such claims to religious authority. Second, the doctrine of the unity of being was popular among the Sunni ʿulama of Farangi Mahall who had traditionally provided the services of scholarship and justice for the Awadh state, and was therefore an attack on their legitimacy. Precursors of this are clear in the biographical sources that claim Sayyid Dildar ʿAli bettering both ʿAbd ʿAli Bahr al-ʿulum and Mulla Hasan in debate. Third, anti-Sufism was a major theme in the thought of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's teachers in Iraq – indeed, the son of Bihbahani wrote perhaps the major Persian anti-Sufi polemic of the period, the Risala-yi khayratiya.Footnote 44 Finally, the position on unity of being was also an attempt to enhance his own theological method since it was a doctrine that was already popular among Shiʿi scholars both in Iran and India. As such, he was drawing a line under the Safavid tradition that was open to such speculative metaphysics and mysticism and, instead, trying to return to a more pristine Shiʿi theology – as we shall see in his other major theological work, ʿImad al-Islam.
A New Theology
The third element of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's strategy was the writing of Mirʾat al-ʿuqul fi ʿilm al-usul to challenge the theology of the Sunni rationalists of Awadh. He took Fakhr al-Din al-Razi (d. 1210) as his main target because of the latter's centrality to scholars in India through his most important work, Nihayat al-ʿuqul [The pinnacle of the intellects]. The text covered five large volumes, one each on the theological divisions of the nature of God, his unity and attributes (al-tawhid); divine justice (al-ʿadl); prophecy (al-nubuwwa); Imamate (al-imama) and the resurrection and the afterlife (al-maʿad), and was copied extensively and lithographed in Lucknow consistently from the middle of the nineteenth century into the early twentieth century.
In the introduction to the first volume, Sayyid Dildar ʿAli clarifies his intention for writing the work: it provides a solid, rational basis for the faith, insisting upon the need for a reflective, reasoned approach to understanding God, humanity and the cosmos, and indicating what the acknowledgement of an existence of a wise and just God entails for believers.Footnote 45 He claims that particularly in India, but also beyond, there is a need for a book that “contains clear and eloquent proofs that guide people, that presents realities (haqaʾiq) and subtle arguments (daqaʾiq) so that the views of opponents both recent and from the past are easily defeated”.Footnote 46 He signals his targeting of the “Imam of the ʿAsharites” Fakhr al-Din Muhammad b. ʿUmar al-Razi when he cites from his Nihayat al-ʿuqul the three reasons why any work is outstanding. Razi says that these features are: deep and careful consideration of the views of others through access and examination of their works first hand; the derivation of proper apodictic proofs that yield true knowledge and certainty; and a wonderful and useful arrangement of the arguments and content so that one cannot just stick with the surface readings but must pay attention to detail. Sayyid Dildar ʿAli claims to go one better – he does all this and more through a deep meditation on the words of the Imams, eschewing all bigotry to provide independent positions and not just defend school doctrine, and by giving serious consideration to rational and scriptural proofs. These are important characteristics of the work that one can discern through the five volumes. He faithfully reproduces Razi's arguments and criticises them through adducing evidence from scriptural proofs and formulating rational responses. He takes independent positions, and often cites much earlier authorities such as the Baghdadi theologians al-Shaykh al-Mufid (d. 1022) and al-Sharif al-Murtada (d. 1044), thereby bypassing much medieval Shiʿi theology that was formulated by Nasir al-Din Tusi (d. 1274) and Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli (d. 1325). His polemical strategy is to reconstruct any early theological method that seems to be both rational and scriptural in opposition to what he might consider to be the excessively philosophical and theoretical approach of the medieval school of Hilla.
Once again written in Arabic, the primary aim of the text is to establish the author's scholarly credentials and to pursue the quest for independent positions to demonstrate his mastery of the tradition. The first two volumes make this quite clear. The theological traditions in Islam from the medieval period, especially as debated in the cycle of texts initiated by Tajrid al-iʿtiqad [The sublimation of belief) written by Nasir al-Din Tusi, and in the treatises on the proof for the existence of God (ithbat al-bariʾ) inspired by Avicenna's famous proof from contingency, tended to focus in extensive and minute detail on the examination of the nature of God's existence, his attributes, the nature of his knowledge and what that entailed for the possibility of human free will. The preliminaries to volume one follow this theological tradition by focusing on epistemology, in particular the process of reflection and the need to acquire an understanding and knowledge of what God is, and a discussion of ontology, the very nature of being. However, while he demonstrates his understanding of the theological and philosophical traditions, his main authorities are actually a collection of sayings attributed to the Imams al-Sadiq and al-Rida and the theological treatises of al-Shaykh al-Mufid, as well as some of the disputations of the companions of the Imams.Footnote 47 He approves of a prohibition on the more speculative tendencies in philosophical theology.Footnote 48
He distances himself from the Neoplatonic tradition of philosophy, citing with approval Avicenna's critique of both the reality of Platonic forms as well as the so-called identity thesis, namely that knowledge is a process of union between the human intellect and the transcendent active intellect, an epistemic union that often is used to symbolise the mystical union of the seeker to God.Footnote 49 Thus, because the identity thesis is associated with monism, it is set aside. He cites the traditional critique of the philosophers for their denial of a volitional creator and their espousal of a mechanistic first principle.Footnote 50 His anti-monism thus allows for a greater embrace of Avicennism against the school of Mulla Sadra, whom he cites but not always with approval. His rational concern is particularly with Shiʿi doctrines such as al-badaʾ (the notion that humans perceive God to be changing his decrees with respect to certain events), on which he ignores the medieval discussions and reverts back to both scripture and early theological positions, the rational nominalism of the divine attributes, and the denial of ocular vision of God in the afterlife.Footnote 51 Arguably, the whole of the second volume is on Shiʿi specificity with the emphasis on divine justice, although much of the discussion concerns the medieval debate on divine will and whether that is compatible with human free will.Footnote 52
Much of the text avoids the citation of contemporaries, something that might suggest that he did not feel that any of the scholars of his time were worth debating. However, he does cite the medieval tradition liberally, and in the fifth volume on eschatology he engages extensively with a figure whose works were very important in the dars-i nizami, Mahmud Jaunpuri (d. 1654).Footnote 53 In many ways, this is the most philosophically sophisticated volume, although once again, surprisingly, he fails to mentions some of the most important and controversial theories on the resurrection associated with Mulla Sadra. The volume culminates with a section on the importance of the Imams as those who usher in the eschaton – messianism that is central to Shiʿi theology is given a central eschatological role.Footnote 54
Much of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's work is thus quite innovative and serious. It does present a number of independent positions that are decidedly novel. He deliberately sets out to criticise the rational foundation of the philosophical theology of his intellectual rivals, the Sunni theologians in the towns in Awadh but also distances himself from the philosophical theology of the school of Mulla Sadra that had strong roots in India. But his intention is not just to present a new positive theology; it is designed to further a polemical rejection of the others, and thus complements his other writings in defence of the faith.
This latter theme relates to his engagement in polemics when responding to anti-Shiʿi works. Shah ʿAbd al-ʿAziz's Tuhfa-yi isnaʿashariya was arguably the most important anti-Shiʿi polemic of the precolonial period, and it spawned an extensive literature in support, in refutation and counter-refutation.Footnote 55 It was completed in 1204/1789-1790 in response to the fear of rising Shiʿi power and influence in North India. In his preface, Shah ʿAbd al-ʿAziz set out the reasons for writing the text:
In this treatise, we have gathered together the fruits of disputation that the Shiʿa have had with the ahl-i sunnat over the ages. . .In the place and time in which we live, the popularity and prevalence of Shiʿism has attained such a magnitude that there is hardly a house in which we do not find one or two men who have not embraced the Shiʿi faith or are not inclined to it. But most of them are ignorant and illiterate; nor are they acquainted with their ancestral faith. When the Shiʿa initiate discussions in the assemblies of Sunnis, they speak irreverently and incoherently. It was under these circumstances that this book was written with the view that at the time of disputation, the Sunnis should not deviate from the right path, and should not reject the principles of their faith. They should not allow doubts and suspicions to occur regarding some important issues.Footnote 56
The text was appropriately divided into twelve chapters: the first was on the appearance of the Shiʿi religion, repeating the old trope of anti-Shiʿi polemics that argued for a Jewish (and hence un-Islamic) origin for it through the semi-legendary figure of ʿAbdullah b. Sabaʾ.Footnote 57 He claimed that the Shiʿa have lied, changed, split and divided, confused and betrayed the Sunni mainstream and generally undermined the world of Islam, but most importantly since the rise of the Turkmen and the Safavids at the end of the fifteenth century, they have now politically dominated the Islamic East. The function of this first chapter is thus to establish why the Shiʿa are a threat who should be opposed. An important element of the process of the text, and this is consistent with Naqshbandi approaches to anti-Shiʿi polemics, was to insist that the ahl al-bayt had nothing to do with the Shiʿa but were very much part of the Sunni tradition, and, second, to focus on the accusations and cursing of key companions of the Prophet as a sign of unbelief among the Shiʿa. The second chapter attempts to undercover the Satanic ruses (makaʾid) of the Shiʿa whereby they attract, confuse and mislead believers, especially targeting elites.Footnote 58 The third chapter on the ancestors of the Shiʿa identified seven sects, all stemming from Ibn Sabaʾ, and perpetuates the common slander of sexual impropriety and licentiousness inherent in the Shiʿa gene.Footnote 59 The fourth chapter is an examination of Shiʿi ḥadīth and narrations in order to demonstrate their technical and actual weaknesses and contradictions in order to undermine the hermeneutics of Shiʿi polemical positions.Footnote 60 The fifth chapter turns to theology on the nature of God and critiques Shiʿi views on the rational recognition of God, the beatific vision and free will and broadly defends Ashʿari views.Footnote 61 The sixth chapter on prophecy critiques 16 doctrines on infallibility, the incumbency of prophecy on God and the relationship between prophets and imams.Footnote 62 The seventh chapter is on the imamate, a detailed examination of the scriptural evidence used by Shiʿi polemicists; it includes an important defence of the Sunni case for the succession of Abu Bakr as it deflects the views of those who were not Shiʿi but considered ʿAli to be superior and the rightful successor (a position known as tafzil).Footnote 63 The eighth chapter examines views on eschatology.Footnote 64 The ninth moves onto particular precepts in Shiʿi law, but actually focuses on the practice of cursing companions of the Prophet and on the inauguration of festivals.Footnote 65 The tenth deals with a long list of Shiʿi accusations (mataʿin) against the early caliphs and companions, especially Abu Bakr, ʿUmar, ʿUthman, and ʿAʾisha.Footnote 66 The eleventh chapter is on the peculiarities of Shiʿism, such as their myths, their bigotry and so forth.Footnote 67 The final chapter is on the Shiʿi principles of tawallaʾ and tabarraʾ - cleaving to the family of the Prophet and dissociating from and cursing those considered to be their enemies.Footnote 68
The Tuhfa had a number of prominent responses, which were solicited and commissioned.Footnote 69 Sayyid Dildar ʿAli and his students wrote some of the more famous ones. Sawarim-i ilahiya [Divine thunderbolts] critiqued the metaphysics of the text in Chapter 5; Husam al-Islam [The sword of Islam] addressed prophecy in Chapter 6; Khatima-yi Sawarim was concerned with chapter 7 on the imamate; Risala-yi ghaybat on the twelfth Imam; Ihyaʾ-yi sunnat [Revival of the prophetic practice) attacked the section on eschatology (maʿad) in Chapter 8; and Risala-yi Dhu-l-fiqār was about Chapter 12 on tabarra and walaya. His strategy is to accuse Shah ʿAbd al-ʿAziz of deliberately confusing Shiʿi positions and to focus upon the problems within the Sunni tradition between the Ashaʿira and the Maturidiya on key theological issues. He strongly, as is consonant with his other works, insists upon the centrality of reason as a standard in argumentation and the formulation of doctrine.Footnote 70 He consistently focuses upon Fakhr al-Din al-Razi as representative of the Ashʿari tradition and criticises him, referring often to the more complete accounts in his magnum opus ʿImad al-Islam.Footnote 71 Similarly, he uses the opportunity to attack Sufis and their doctrine of the unity of being (wahdat al-wujud), which he also does in his al-Shihab al-thaqib.Footnote 72 His sons and other students took up the challenge of refuting other chapters in the Tuhfa.
Conclusion
Although Sayyid Dildar ʿAli was a central figure, it took time for the institutions and practices of the Awadh state to become exclusively Shiʿi – the judiciary being a major case in point. There were insufficient judges trained in Shiʿi law, and the founding of a seminary to train them came after his death.Footnote 73 His scholarly endeavours were extensive and did amount to a new conception of Shiʿi theology, a vibrant but polemical bolster for the new realities of North India in a post-Mughal context. His works attacked classical opponents and concepts taken generally, but his interlocutors and contemporary readers could discern in the arguments attacks on his Sunni, Sufi, and Akhbari contemporaries. However, his conception of what it meant to be Shiʿi was not uncontested. Taking the three strands discussed above, each one was challenged. With regard to the Usuli case, Akhbaris did not just die out in North India. Mirza Muhammad Akhbari (d. 1817) was well received at court and he wrote a refutation of Dildar ʿAli.Footnote 74 Akhbaris also defended their positions and wrote refutations of Asas al-usul. One anonymous and contemporary refutation, dedicated to Nawwab Saʿadat ʿAli Khan, argues that, first, the faith is not based on reason as an independent standard but upon the understanding of the Qurʾan that derives from the explanations (bayan) of the Imams, and, second, that neither law nor theology can be based upon probability and conjecture (zann).Footnote 75 In support of his position, this unnamed critic cites a long list of Shiʿi Akhbari ʿulama and even brings the famous Muhammad Baqir Majlisi (d. 1699) to his cause, arguing that he denied that independent rational proofs were part of the Shiʿi tradition.Footnote 76 The fact that Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's sons and students continued to write against Akhbaris suggests that the case was never won, even if their discourse had become dominant. Insofar as the debate with Akhbaris was as much about clerical authority, it remains a feature of contemporary Shiʿism in South Asia.
Sufis also failed to disappear. Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's rival for the patronage of Hasan Riza Khan, Shah ʿAli Akbar Mawdudi, continued to have a following and wrote an important Sufi treatise defending the practices of music, the hermeneutics of kashf and the doctrine of wahdat al-wujud.Footnote 77 Another anonymous text written by a Shiʿi Sufi at the time of Saʿadat ʿAli Khan responds to al-Shihab al-thaqib. Drawing upon the work of the famous “Third Martyr” Sayyid Nurullah Shushtari (d. 1610), it argues that Sufism and Shiʿism are identical because they have common roots in the person and the teachings of the Imams of the family of the Prophet.Footnote 78 It then provides a long list of great Shiʿi ʿulama sympathetic to Sufism, as well as defending their attachment to kashf and esoteric knowledge as an inheritance from the Imams. The text staunchly defends, in rather ad hominem terms, the doctrine of wahdat al-wujud and questions Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's scholarly credentials.Footnote 79 It is clear from the text that its author considers al-Shihab and its arguments to be derivative, based on the Safavid works of Mulla Tahir Qummi – and since the elder Muhammad Taqi Majlisi had responded to him, he feels that a proper refutation is unnecessary.Footnote 80 He finishes with the issue of music and dance, strongly supporting the practices.Footnote 81 The popularity of Sufi practice and devotion in North India remained even among the Shiʿa.
The kalam works similarly did not go unchallenged. Although the dominance of the “family of ijtihad” was clear, some independent-minded authors did write critically. One such figure was Sayyid Murtaza Nawnehravi (d. 1336/1918) who, in his Miʿraj al-ʿuqul fi sharh duʿaʾ al-mashlul in the early twentieth century, continued the project of criticising Razi, but also condemned many of Sayyid Dildar ʿAli's positions but defended the philosophical theology of the school of Mulla Sadra.Footnote 82
However, despite these responses, the theology that Sayyid Dildar ʿAli formulated and promoted with its anti-Sunnism, anti-Akhbarism, and anti-Sufism, coupled with a critique of philosophy, remains a formidable force in modern South Asia. Any serious consideration of the modern intellectual history of Shiʿi Islam in the subcontinent must engage in a serious re-evaluation of not just the nature of theology at the cusp of the new Awadh dispensation but also what changed in the Awadh state. Consistent with the project of understanding the intellectual history of South Asia as a way of deciding what changed in the period of colonialism, any understanding of Shiʿism under British rule and in the post-colonial period needs to engage more rigorously with what came before, what changed and what established the parameters and issues of debate that continue to affect intellectual and cultural trends today.
