Three tasks might be attempted in a comprehensive account of anthropology in/of Iran: (1) accounting for the growth of (and blockages to) anthropology as a field in Iran with respect to nationalist, modernization, comparative, or Islamist ideologies; (2) reconstructing the knowledge accumulated, by interviewing ethnographers and by interpretive readings of their texts and notes, especially where publication poorly reflects actual knowledge; and (3) including the work of diaspora and foreign-based anthropologists and cultural analysts working in Iran in a dialectical play of points of view.
Fazeli's fascinating and excellent book does primarily the first task. Written from Iran by a member of the (post)revolutionary generation, Fazeli provides some wonderful autobiographical context. He wrote his first ethnography about the village in which he grew up (home also of Grand Ayatullah Araki, p. 173), as did Al-e Ahmad and others in moments of “sympathy” for rural culture. A revolutionary Basiji in the Iran-Iraq war (p. 147), Fazeli's cohort believed their responsibility in university was “to combat their secular instructors” (p. 158), and he began his M.A. in 1988 as one of the five first postrevolution anthropology students (p. 170), before doing a PhD with Richard Tapper at the London School of Oriental and African Studies. His tools, to provide a balanced view of the various anthropological initiatives in Iran, are (1) an articulation of anthropology's own professional culture and (2) a cultural critique by reading anthropological initiatives against his schema of nationalist, modernization, socialist, or Islamicist ideologies. Chapters are chronologically organized, and I find it most revealing to read in reverse order (from current efforts to restart anthropological work back to the early 20th century) as a way of giving coherence and point of view to some of the oddities of judgment in the earlier chapters.
Thus, it is odd to read in the chapter on the 1970s that it was not until Mortaza Farhadi's book in 2000 that Ann Lambton's “notion of an individualistic and non-cooperative attitude as a feature of the Iranian peasantry” was overthrown (p. 98). However, Safinezhad's work in the 1970s on village cooperative labor organization (available in English by means of Eric Hooglund's 1982 book on land reform) made this point, as did work in the 1970s on agricultural share and water rights systems in Khuzistan (by Grace Goodell) and Yazd (myself). It is odd to read that it was not recognized until Safinezhad's 1989 work that all nomads do not have the same social structure (p. 98), especially from a student of Tapper whose work on the Shahsavand marketing to Tehran challenged Barth's work on the Basseri, as did Jacob Black-Michaud's on agropastoral combines among the Bakhtiari, and the dozen or so other studies of tribes in different ecologies and political economies. It is odd to read Naraqi's 1969 opinion that foreign anthropologists imputed unchanging stasis to Iranian social structures, on the eve of an explosion of studies of change among nomads—in the bazaar (Rotblatt in Qazvin, Dylan in Kerman, Fischer in Yazd), in religious institutions (Thaiss, Fischer, Akhavi), in health care and psychiatry (Good and Good), and elsewhere.
Similarly, it is fascinating to follow how Fazeli deals with such “proto-ethnographers” as Al-e Ahmad, Gholam-Hussein Saedi, and Samad Behrangi, all of whom were briefly part of the Institute for Social Studies and Research. Fazeli astutely observes a double dialectic between qualitative and quantitative social science. Al-e Ahmad et al. were ejected in part because they were too unsystematic and because they were critics of the modernization ideology of the state. In the 1960s French (and earlier German) training was replaced by American social science with its statistical methods that fit with a modernizing bureaucracy's demand for quantifiable indices. Ethnography had been championed precisely because of the unreliability of survey and census style research in Iran (and many other developing countries). Ethnography fit both earlier French training and Persian literary genres, and it is striking how important Saedi's ethnography of the zar cult (Al-e Hava) and his other ethnographies were for 1970s meaning-based, interpretive, linguistic, and symbolic anthropologies pursued by American ethnographers working in Iran, as well as for the new wave in Iranian cinema, beginning with Saedi's script for the 1969 film Gav.
Fazeli beautifully traces the importance of folklore studies and the importance of Hedayat, Shamlu, and others. He places Hedayat in his problematic ideological context, but a comparative perspective on the importance of folklore studies in many modernist movements, national as well as artistic, might be helpful here, as would attention to the 1970s performance studies of ethnomusicology, oral poetry, wedding, and comedic satire within Iran. Fazeli highlights the importance of Anjavi-Shirazi and the radio broadcasts that generated large folklore archives, but television and the film and book projects of the Institute for Intellectual Development of Children and Young Adults should also be included, as should the documentary films produced with Russian, American, and British help (about which Hamid Naficy is writing).
Perhaps the most fascinating of recent projects mentioned by Fazeli is the thirty-plus volumes of some twenty amateur ethnographers of The Culture of the War Front. Informed, interpretive readings might retrieve from them more than a missed opportunity. Fazeli interviews two of the authors and records the desire to create a mystical and symbolic crucible for Shiעite idealism. Also tantalizing is the mention of the effort to Islamicize anthropology by inviting the staff of the Anthropology Department of Teheran University to Qum to cooperatively Islamicize the field in 1983. (Mofid University in Qum still today views itself as engaged in research on the relations between humanism and Islam.)
In 2001 Fazeli says there were sixty-three students in graduate programs in anthropology in Iranian universities, a new Iranian Anthropological Association, and several new journals. Among the changes supporting these developments are (1) the shift of the state ideology from pure Islamism back to a nationalism that is both Iranian and Islamic, partly to control the upsurge of nationalism after the bombing of Shush and other cities of Khuzistan by Iraq; (2) the turn to participatory methods and local knowledge in response to the failures of top-down development and reconstruction (jahad sazandegi) campaigns; and (3) the failure of the Islamicization of academia. There is a new emphasis on cultural capital (sarmayeh-i farhang), worry about cultural amnesia (nesyan-i farhangi), and softening of the slogans about Western cultural invasion (tahajom-i farhangi). There is also, he should acknowledge, a new stream of work by diaspora Iranians returning to do fieldwork (Arlene Djalafar, Shahla Haeri, Rafique Keshavjee, Mazyar Lotfalian, Ramyar Rasoukh, Fereydun Safizadeh, Roxanne Varzi, Saeed Zeydabadi-Nejad, among others): how their work can contribute to the politics of culture in Iran remains to be seen.
Fazeli argues that, because the state attempted to instrumentalize anthropology both under the modernization and the Islamization regimes, anthropological work has been superficial, and has not contributed to wider methodological or theoretical debates. Still, as he describes, there is a rich history of work to build on, and much that lies under the surface could, with interpretive work, be made to flower. Above all, Fazeli's book is a starting point for recognizing the play of difference, and need for dialogue, in work done by those constrained by local institutional demands and those operating from the diaspora or abroad.
