The rôle of rivers in the ancient world has attracted attention at least since L. Mechnikoff's La Civilisation et les grands fleuves historiques (1889), but as far as the Roman world is concerned, at least outside Egypt, it has not been much discussed in a systematic way until recently (though note N. Purcell, JRS 80 (1990), 179 for indications of some problems now central to the study under review). Campbell's impressive volume, however, is the second book in as many years providing an in-depth treatment of the rôle of rivers, and of ‘riverine’ (to use a term favoured by him) societies in the Roman period, following Peter Thonemann's seminal The Maeander Valley (2011), which appeared just in time to be taken into account by C.
This is a wide-ranging book, beginning by way of introduction with both hydrology and the rôle of rivers in the legendary early Rome, and then, after a brief discussion of methodology, covering in chs 2–4 perceptions of rivers in geographical writing, in Roman law, and in literature and art, and in chs 5–9 the use of rivers for military purposes, their economic and transportation functions (at 130 pages the single longest part of the book), and finally, healing waters. Ch. 10 forms a conclusion. It does not attempt an histoire totalisante approach to environmental history of river regions, though it recommends studies that follow this approach and cover ‘a very long expanse of time’ (such as Thonemann's work on the Maeander referred to above) as a way forward on a regional level (36). Rather, this is a book ‘based on what the ancients themselves wrote and thought about rivers’ (37), aiming to take the Romans on their own terms. Within its field, it continues in a very successful way the tradition of Claude Nicolet's L'inventaire du monde, rather than that of Braudel.
C.'s approach is informed by the sense of rivers’ history in the longue durée (from pre-Roman times to the Convention of Strasbourg in 1963) and by an exceptionally wide knowledge both of relevant written sources, particularly on law and economy, and of modern archaeological research, built up in a lifetime of scholarship. It is not, on the other hand, a book conveying to us a sense of the landscape. Descriptions of rivers are based more on ancient and modern geographical writing than on personal impressions, and photographs taken by C. illustrate only the Rhine in its mid-course and the Thames near the Port Meadow. It is illuminating to contrast his approach with J. N. L. Myres's programme ‘to penetrate Britain by boat up all the main water-ways on the east and south coasts’ (The English Settlements (19852), xxvi–xxvii), applied to the study of a period for which written sources are meagre.
For this reviewer, the two highlights of the volume were an excellent presentation of Roman law on waterways to a ‘general’ historian in ch. 3, the first of its kind, and a detailed discussion of rivers as transport arteries in chs 6–8, which is now easily the best in any language and will serve as a necessary background to any in-depth regional studies. It seems more doubtful whether the treatment of religious, literary and artistic perceptions in ch. 4 (a mine of useful information, like the rest of the book) is ultimately successful; one is inevitably left wishing for more, and genre or chronological developments sometimes become imperceptible.
One theme that is surprisingly rather marginal for C., and which would seem to me to repay further treatment along the same lines, is the rôle of the river fisheries in the economy. Note, for example, I.Histria 67–9 for a city whose ‘sole revenue’ was derived from Danubian fisheries. However, in a book covering the whole of the Roman world, and at times reaching beyond it, each reader is bound to have a share of minor disagreements, and these should not obscure C.'s achievement in connecting environmental history of Roman rivers to wider historical themes. Anyone interested in Roman historical geography, environmental or economic history, or in the ways in which the Roman age perceived the natural world will need to engage with his work.
Few minor addenda pro domo mea: Mela on the navigability of Borysthenes (298) is clearly taken over from Herodotus 4.53, cf. A. V. Podosinov and M. V. Skrzhinskaya, Rimskie geograficheskie istochniki (2011), 115 n. 200; on ‘riverine identities’ (e.g. 325–6), add now D. Dana and M. Dana, Ancient West & East 8 (2009), 235–41 (on the ‘potamophoric’ name Istrodoros); for the thermal waters of Hierapolis in Phrygia (402), note rather Dig. 43.20.1.13 and Vitr. 8.3.10, with further discussion in T. Ritti, Hierapolis: Scavi e ricerche I (1985), 16–22; for Dionysius Periegetes, K. Brodersen's 1994 edition should have been used.
The book is accompanied by two useful appendices: a checklist of thermal/curative waters in the Roman world (391–404), and a list of navigable rivers, from Spain to India, according to ancient geographers and the Digest (405–9). One wonders, however, whether their evidence should have been treated in isolation from both documentary and narrative sources, amply discussed by C. in relevant chapters (note, e.g., Tacitus, Ann. 11.20 and 13.53). Illustrations are not particularly numerous, but there are nineteen exceptionally clear and useful maps. Misprints are very few, though the date of Cicero's de lege agraria should read 63 b.c. (96), for Sánchez-Osty read Sánchez-Ostiz (550), and the spelling of some Turkish river-names is unsystematic (408).
