Heather Harris, Kimberly Moffitt, and Catherine Squires devoted their first volume, The Obama Effect: Multidisciplinary Renderings of the 2008 Campaign (SUNY Press, 2010), to making sense of the historical significance of Barack Obama's unprecedented candidacy and what would ultimately be his two-term presidency. I was thrilled to learn that Harris and Moffitt curated Michelle Obama and the FLOTUS Effect. Not only is an edited collection on the former First Lady's legacy long overdue, but I cannot think of a more talented team of editors and contributors to undertake this project.
Below, I consider how this book might contribute to a syllabus on “Michelle Obama effects.” While the volume is divided into two major parts, I re-orient the chapters based on a framework that sorts material according to (1) how scholars define the effects, (2) what the consequences of these effects are, (3) why the effects exist, and (4) which segments of the electorate are (or perhaps should be) most heavily influenced by them.
Defining Michelle Obama Effects
The underlying logic behind Michelle Obama effects is that her political prominence has important societal implications. “Prominence” takes on many forms. For example, some authors celebrate the significance of Michelle Obama's very presence in the public eye. Others are fascinated not only with the fact that Mrs. Obama occupies these spaces as an “outsider within” but also with the skillful way she navigates contested spaces to forge coalitions, advocate for change, and influence media narratives. In short, the effects to which the authors refer include those associated with physical presence, policy platforms, and/or political agency. Harris and Moffitt introduce this presence/platform/agency typology in their introduction, and I would teach this outline of what FLOTUS effects are (and can be) as a complement to the ones offered by Watson and Esterowicz (Reference Watson and Esterowicz2003), Caroli (Reference Caroli2010), and Borelli (Reference Borelli2011).
The Impact of Michelle Obama
Michelle Obama's influence on policy initiatives is a major focus of the book. Chapters 5, 8, 9, and 10 explore the degree to which politicians and voters support several of her signature projects: mainly the Let's Move! campaign against childhood obesity, the Let Girls Learn effort to empower young women by increasing access to quality education, the Reach Higher program, which ensured that people were both informed about the importance of getting a post-high-school education and encouraged to pursue such an education, and the Joining Forces program for military families that she co-founded with Jill Biden. There is also a heavy emphasis on the media—particularly how it interprets the former FLOTUS through the lenses of Black-women stereotypes. Given the proliferation of Twitter, Facebook, etc., it was fitting that Chapters 10 and 11 offer discussions of Michelle Obama's accessibility through social media. Rather than shy away from the hypervisibility afforded to her by her elevated political status, she embraced the “media gaze,” showing the world not only what Black femininity looks like, but also that Black femininity “belongs” in the White House (see Chapter 1).
Explaining Michelle Obama Effects
Earlier chapters make a compelling case for the role that race and gender play as “mediating concepts” that help to explain the relationship between Michelle Obama's presence/platform/agency and factors such as policy advocacy and media depictions. Chapter 3 explores not only how racism and sexism constrict our understanding of the Office of the First Lady but also how Michelle Obama operated within these constraints to transcend depictions rooted in our racist and sexist history. In Chapter 2, we learn about the former FLOTUS’ commitment to making both her own story and those of other African American women more intelligible to the nation.
Chapter 4 chronicles Michelle Obama's efforts to define herself—rather than react to others' characterizations of her. This self-definition process involves the former FLOTUS confronting negative stereotypes. In some cases, this image management process required First Lady Obama to harness and channel America's preoccupation with her Black femininity. More importantly, this volume makes evident the potential of Black femininity as a mobilizing force. Chapter 7 demonstrates that, despite Trump's Electoral College Victory, the Clinton Campaign in general (and Michelle Obama's efforts in particular) shaped the ongoing narrative about the inexcusable crime of sexual assault and the resulting unacceptableness of those in power who participate in, condone, or fail to stand up against it. Chapter 8 shows that Obama's success depended on her ability to appeal to voters' emotions—particularly those that elicit compassion and pity—and, in so doing, the chapter demonstrates how emotions and rationality can play mutually-reinforcing roles in political decision-making.
Who is Influenced by these Effects?
Rather than assume that Michelle Obama mattered similarly to everyone, this edited volume is unique because it showcases the diversity of the intended “targets” of FLOTUS effects. Sometimes, Michelle Obama appealed directly to Black women via the “intentional, and persistent, placement of her body in the public sphere” (p. 5) to both reflect and shape how Black women view themselves. Other times, Michelle Obama's messages were more inclusive, like when she stressed the unifying and widely-cherished values of hard work and love of family.
By engaging the literature on “Obama Effects,” this book adds to a rich body of research on how the first African American presidency ushered in socio-political change while also inspiring scholarly attention. I give Michelle Obama and the FLOTUS Effect my highest recommendation, and it will be a required text in every course of mine that examines the challenges facing Black women who navigate predominantly-White spaces.
