This edited collection revisits the subject matter of the 1991 volume The Sociology of the Health Service (Gabe, Calnan and Bury, Reference Gabe, Calnan and Bury1991). As with the 1991 work, the emphasis is on sociological analysis of health and health service policy, a focus that is perhaps not clear from the title but which makes this book of potential interest to readers of this journal.
In the years since the publication of the earlier volume, health/health service policy has changed considerably, with the emergence of new policy themes such as an emphasis on patient choice and user involvement in design of services, the coming to prominence of ‘evidence based’ approaches as the foundation for practice and policy, a focus on primary care-led provision and a returning policy interest in disease prevention through public health measures as a means to reduce health inequalities while containing expenditure on the NHS. In addition, there has been a significant shift in the way in which sociology as a discipline is regarded by policy makers. As the editors describe in their introduction, the earlier volume was produced during a period when British sociology was in a position of ‘retrenchment in adversity’; the majority of available funding was for policy-led research and there was limited opportunity for a rigorous, reflexive sociology ‘of’ rather than ‘in’ medicine. However, since the mid 1990s the political climate in which sociology operates has changed, becoming more receptive to the idea that sociological insights can inform the political agenda. This has allowed the discipline to enter a period that the editors characterise as one of consolidation, in which new theoretical developments in the discipline are being employed to analyse policy-relevant issues.
In this spirit, the aim of this volume is to encourage sociological engagement with health policy and the organisation of health care. The brief to contributors was to take a critical view of the changes in the social context of health service provision since the early 1990s, turning a sociological lens on the contemporary shape of interrelations between healthcare, state and society. The essays presented here are not simply updates of articles published in the 1991 volume. Rather, the book is a collection of original works addressing the contemporary configuration of the health service, and highlighting the changes in policy and practice that have taken place over the last two decades. In the majority of cases, the authors contributing to the current volume are not those who wrote for the original book, and, where authors reprise their role, they for the most part adopt a different approach rather than simply extending their analysis to new material from the intervening years. As such, this volume complements rather than replaces the earlier work.
Of course, many of the topics addressed in 1991 are still relevant today and are revisited in this book. Chapters on private sector involvement in NHS provision, the impact of New Public Management on the health service, the place of primary care in health service delivery and the nature and role of the medical profession appear in both volumes. In other cases, while the issues discussed are paralleled in the two books, the topic has been refocused. The chapter on ‘evaluation’ in the 1991 volume is replaced by one on ‘evidence based medicine’ in this book; the chapter on community care has been replaced by one on social care; the chapter on health promotion is replaced by one on public health policies and equalising health. In addition, there are chapters on topics that have emerged as new or become newly relevant to policy: consumerism in healthcare and the politics of identity; the role of the pharmaceutical industry; innovation and how new technologies become embedded in health service; and the place of ‘non-orthodox’ (complementary and alternative) medicine in an ‘orthodox’ health service.
The papers collected together offer something of a degustation menu of contemporary issues in health service policy, both in the range of substantive topics covered and in the manner in which their analysis is approached. Inevitably, there are issues that one might wish to see addressed that have not found space. Nevertheless, the breadth of topics addressed means that the book will have something of relevance to a wide audience of those researching in health/health service policy. However, the essays also take different approaches to their subject matter. As with the earlier volume, they are a mix of sociological analysis and health policy analysis employing insights from sociology. This mix reflects the editors’ belief that the future for the sociology of health care is one of ‘undertaking policy-led and theoretically informed policy-relevant work’ (p14), two approaches that do not necessarily sit easily together. The two approaches are likely to appeal to different groups of readers.
Overall, the book offers those coming new to the field a taste of the range of issues in the sociology of health and health service policy, while those who are already working in the field will find key chapters of interest, and are given the opportunity to drop in and sample other topics.
