Dirk Rohmann's book is a learned study arising from his 2004 Munich dissertation on violence and its representation in the first century a.d. R. focuses on the question of whether there is a causal nexus between the increasing amount of violence in first-century literature and the changing socio-political circumstances of the early Empire. His objective, as he writes at the end of the first chapter (17), is to combine philological with historical methods in his analyses of historiographic, philosophic, epic, dramatic and epigrammatic Roman literature (some Greek texts are also included). One should, however, not expect too many minute interpretations; R. rather tackles these texts from different genres and — a grand achievement — incorporates them into a vast discourse on violence and political power in the early Empire.
In ch. 3, which exemplifies this method, R. aims to show how violence has evolved into a topic that can be represented ‘aesthetically’. On the first eight pages of this chapter, he looks at topoi of moral constancy that can be found in various literary genres. He thus brings together a dazzling number of examples — scenes taken from three Seneca-plays (Agamemnon, Hercules furens, Phoenissae) and from Lucan's Pharsalia, several episodes taken from Tacitus' Historiae and Annales, as well as Silius' Punica, Seneca's Epistle 101, epistles by Pliny and Horace, and a bit of Suetonius' Life of Tiberius to mention only the most important of the passages (there are even more in the footnotes). It is impressive how R. arranges and paraphrases this rich material. The rest of the third chapter deals with different forms of capital punishment and their social implications, with revenge, and with compassion in a similar way — all material of high interest for the understanding of how violence was performed.
The book is well structured: after an introduction, R. presents in the second chapter a sound investigation of what has been considered to be ‘physical violence’ in the philosophical discourse led by Seneca, Pliny and the Stoics. This chapter contains fine readings of Seneca's De Ira (37–46) and lays out an elaborate system of terms that describe different aspects of violence in antiquity. Here R. also hints at what he calls the Publikumscharakter of violence — a point that is crucial for his analyses in the following chapters. The idea is that violence in the ancient world needs to be evaluated by audiences — whether the evaluation is affirmative or critical — to display its political capacity. This is explored further in ch. 3 (see above). In chs 4 and 5, R. comes to the very heart of his subject. He analyses the link between the spheres of violence and politics by discussing first some scholarly attempts to explain the emperors' death scenes, and by then examining how the emperors were presented as offenders of violence. On pp. 98–104, R. discusses the presentation of Poppaea's death in Tacitus, Annals 16.6.1–2 and its parallels. He demonstrates how Tacitus plays with certain elements and topoi of the historiographic tradition and concludes that the passage serves the purpose of drawing a general image of Nero's cruelty rather than being a reproduction of historical facts. This scepticism towards a naïve and merely historical reading of the historians is supported by an important digression on the heritage of Hellenistic historiographic poetics in the first century a.d. on pp. 130–8. Ch. 5 is dedicated to some of the socio-political phenomena that have been assumed to be the reason behind the frequent scenes of cruelty, such as punishment, crime, and gladiatorial games in first-century literature. Again, R. rejects simplistic historicist models by arguing that the texts do not provide realistic images of, say, crime, but express the contemporary attitude of the Roman élite and their need for security. A dense and reader-friendly summary (ch. 6) completes the study.
Some less helpful anachronistic comparisons and about a dozen linguistic, stylistic and typing errors are minor flaws of this well-researched book. There is a useful appendix with two rich indices and a long bibliography. No one who deals with first-century culture can ignore R.'s welcome contribution to ongoing research.
