While the political and sociological aspects of Israel's history have been the subjects of numerous studies, its economic development has not received the attention it deserves. Paul Rivlin's book helps to fill this void. Of its ten post introductory chapters, the first four cover the development of the Israeli economy from the beginning of the Zionist endeavour in the late nineteenth century through the first decade of the present one. The following five are devoted each to the economics of the specific issues of defense, Israeli-Palestinian relationships, the Ultra-Orthodox and Arab minorities, and the social distribution of resources and income. Each chapter carries a “conclusions” section, summing up its main highlights. Finally, the book's overall concluding chapter lists the economic challenges bound to confront Israel in the future, and points out the policies that have to be taken to deal with them, as well as the political obstacles to their adoption.
Rivlin's description of the evolution of the Israeli economy over time follows mainstream economic tracks. It is well-written and although perforce painted with a wide brush, it succeeds in bringing up this economy's salient characteristics. This is no mean feat given the need to provide also some general historical background in view of the country's turbulent political and quickly changing social, scenes. Critical of the interventionist government policies of Israel's early days and the persistence of some of them until today, he is also aware that the “shift from collectivism to individualism, favored by conventional economics, comes…with a [social] cost” (p. 95). Idealizing somewhat the past, he also seems to decry the fading over time of the “sense of unity and purpose” (p. 48) and the rise of consumerism. To globalization, and the influence of the media and of travel abroad in particular, with which Rivlin associates these changes, one should probably also add the growth of population and of incomes: a society of more than seven million cannot be as cohesive as its seven-hundred thousand's predecessor of sixty years ago; and the higher the income, the greater the variation in consumption patterns and, hence, also the scope for advertising and other consumerism bound phenomena.
Readers familiar with Israeli history will be able to spot occasional factual inaccuracies, mostly relating to non-economic issues. To illustrate: Rather than having been created in 1948 (p. 33), the Hagana ceased to exist that year, having morphed into the Israeli Defence Forces; the existing religious modus vivendi is not the result of a compromise reached during the British Mandate (p. 167), but of the latter inheriting the Ottoman Millet system's subjugation of personal status matters to the jurisdiction of denominational courts; the number of Palestinian workers in Israel in the pre-Oslo period did not peak in 1987 (p. 157), but in 1992, (Statistical Abstract of Israel No. 45, Jerusalem: C.B.S., 1994, table 27.22), and the figures cited include not just the legally but also the illegally employed.
Such glitches might lessen the value of the book as a reference for fact quarriers. But they do not materially detract from Rivlin's analysis of the various economic processes that the Israeli economy underwent over time. He shows how balance of payments crises, that plagued Israel for many years, dictated domestic consumption and incomes policies. He also provides a well guided tour of Israel's all-pervasive indexation system that prevented inflation in the 1980s from burning itself out by eroding the real value of the public's money balances, and explains the heterodox stabilization program of the mid-eighties that brought it to an end. He also shows how the conservative policies of the Israeli banks, and what would have been regarded at the time as financial backwardness, protected Israel from being dragged into the financial crisis of recent years.
By the author's own declaration, “the central theme in this book is the clash between efficiency and growth on the one hand and equity on the other” (p. xv). Paradoxically enough, in at least four of the special issues discussed in it, the clashes are between vested interests on the one hand and both equity and growth on the other one. Rivlin's rough estimates of the costs of conscription, of the hurdles on the entry of young Ultra-Orthodox males into the labor market, of the Israeli settlements in the West Bank and of the failure to fully integrate the Arab minority in the Israeli economy are at the same time estimates of the extra growth to be gained by removing or lessening the inequities stemming from them.
For a product of a prestigious university press, Rivlin's book suffers from what can only be called sloppy copyediting. Repetitions abound—in one extreme case a passage of nine lines is repeated virtually verbatim twice within the span of six pages (pp. 178, 184). In calculating the costs of the Israeli settlements in the Occupied Territories, the products of sums of NIS 1,100 or less per settler multiplied by the less than 300,000 settler population are presented as NIS billions, rather than as hundreds of millions (pp. 150–51). The share of the Arab sector in the economy is calculated by nonsensically multiplying its share in the labor force by what is claimed to be its labour participation rate (p. 195), although the source from which this calculation is taken makes it clear that it is the ratio of average Arab earnings to the all-Israeli ones (Ezra Sadan, The Arab Sector's Share in the Economy, The Abraham Fund Initiatives, 2006, p. 4).
Rivlin's book is well-written and makes a good read. It avoids technical jargon, argues its positions clearly, and manages to convey the flavor of the Israeli economy and of its specifics. The attitudes of its author are those of a humanistic, secular, liberal Israeli, which are not much in evidence these days. The earlier caveats apart, it can be wholeheartedly recommended to both economists and laymen interested in gaining a bird's view of its subject.
