No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
Louis Jordan has put together an impressive volume detailing the historical, political, and economic circumstances surrounding the issue of coinage in Massachusetts. His work offers both a thorough examination of the primary sources and literature on the topic as well as new information and interpretations. Jordan is able to synthesize the vast materials on the topic into a well-written scholarly volume that I suspect will become a standard reference for those interested in monetary matters of the British North American colonies.
Jordan explains every element related to his subject, from account book date recording to the various methods for minting coins. Numerous figures also provide a wonderful complement to his vivid descriptions, allowing you to see the layout of a mint along with pictures of the coins produced. The two appendices provide invaluable tools for researchers: a transcription of the Hull Shop Account from 1671 to 1680 with comments and explanatory notes provided by Jordan as well as a listing of relevant documents and events related to the Massachusetts Mint, in chronological order.
The history of the Hull family and John Hull's principal partner, Robert Sanderson, is entertaining reading. While attempting to provide well-supported answers to questions such as the location of the mint, Jordan provides a rich backdrop on the development of Boston and the surrounding communities. He also includes relevant political details such as the requirements of the Puritan church and the relations between the colony and England in the turbulent eighteenth century. Jordan's work offers excellent examples of the process used by England to govern the colonies as we follow petitions and representatives to meetings of the Privy Council and the Lords of Trade and Plantations. Perhaps more impressive than the information provided was Jordan's ability to keep on point and not get drawn into discussions of the political tensions between England and Massachusetts that relate to his main point in a purely tangential way.
The book provides technical details about the rules and methods for determining the purity of silver and the operation of a mint. For the period covered by the available account records, Jordan attempts to estimate the productivity of the mint by such measures as turnaround time for orders and the optimal size of a silver melt. Although his analysis requires him to make assumptions, none seem implausible. Jordan arrives at good estimates for the time to produce coins in Massachusetts. The problem of coin weight (pp. 54–63) was well presented though there were some simple steps that would have made it more informative. The lack of a scientific approach to coinage made weight something of a problem, evidenced by the examples Jordan presents (pp. 59–61). He provides an average coin weight in grains of silver but does not give the standard deviation. As a result the reader does not gain a sense of the distribution of coin weight.
The later chapters (Part 5, pp. 148–78) introduce issues of international exchange such as the activities of Spanish mints and the eight reales coin. One again Jordan provides an exhaustive amount of detail as he discusses the different exchange values attached to coins throughout the British Empire at the time, the one based on the silver content and then the legislated exchange value. He does a good job explaining the attempts to legislate the value of a shilling in Massachusetts to keep the coinage in circulation in the colony. This section of Jordan's work combined with John McCusker's Money and Exchange in Europe and America, 1600–1775: A Handbook (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1978) gives students and scholars alike a detailed set of references to examine for exchange-rate movements and monetary history in colonial America.