Composed of an introduction, six chapters, and a conclusion (followed by notes, bibliography, and index), Ryan Thomas Skinner's book Bamako Sounds: The Afropolitan Ethics of Malian Music enacts the multiple and ubiquitous musical voices that shape the urban soundscape of Bamako, Mali's capital city. With a sharp sense of ethnographical narration, Skinner unveils an understanding of Bamako's music scene in the light of a complex theoretical framework describing the ‘Afropolitan ethics’ shared by the Malian artists and performed through their music. Thanks to the insightful descriptions of performance scenes and atmospheres, the reader is literally immersed in vibrant and musical Bamako and the connoisseur immediately recognizes the aural features of the city. Yet it is not enough to hear the urban polyphony, one has to listen to it. It is this close listening that which the reader is invited to undertake by the author who, throughout the book, demonstrates his acuity as an observer and listener as well as a critical thinker.
By spanning a wide scope of popular Malian music genres, from hip-hop to jeliya, and using various media as research materials, from lyrics to music videos via movie and urban writings, the author excavates his concerns about how music embodies and reflects the multiple layers of moralities that a Malian musician uses for asserting his self-expression into the world, what he conceives of as ‘Afropolitan ethics’.
The introduction of the book clearly exposes the theoretical framework of Afropolitanism as the main paradigm, according to the author, able to unpack the complex being-in-the-world ethics of the Malian musicians. Although Skinner acknowledges the criticisms against the notion of Afropolitanism and announces his further critique of ‘cosmopolitanism’ in the conclusion, the author nevertheless uses it faithfully: Bamako is seen as an ‘Afropolis’, the music scene as part of an ‘Afropolitan art world’, Mande popular music as an ‘Afropolitan music idiom’, and the musicians as ‘Afropolitans’. This theoretical stance is then patiently elaborated throughout the six chapters that successively address the urban, professional, aesthetic, religious, economic, and political layers that underline the ethics of musicians in postcolonial Mali.
In the first chapter, dedicated to ‘Representing Bamako’, Skinner gives an impressive insight into the complex ethics of Malian, if not African, musicians as ‘postcolonial subjects’ in their representation of urban social life as a source of anomie and inspiration at once. The second chapter, ‘Artistiya’, addresses the issues related to the ‘performative production of artistic personhood’ and the social positioning it implies in terms of status, agency and identity, informed by an historical account of the disjuncture of Malian cultural policies and state economic and political crisis. ‘Ethics and Aesthetics’ are at the core of the third chapter, in which Skinner expounds on how some aesthetic parameters of Mande music reflect the ethics therein embedded and therefore share in a balance between collective heritage and individual creativity and agency.
The fourth chapter, ‘A Pious Poetics of Place’, deems ‘Afropolitan ethics as a religiously motivated project’ by addressing different ways of asserting an ‘Islamic subjectivity’ in Malian popular music that challenges the theoretical secularity of the nation-state. In the fifth chapter, ‘Money Trouble’, Skinner offers a historical account of copyright policies in Mali, torn between global prescriptions, economic neoliberalization, and the informal rules that challenge state authority. The sixth and last chapter, ‘Afropolitan Patriotism’, goes beyond Bamako itself by analyzing musical productions by artists from the diaspora and music videos encountered online, successively released for the fiftieth anniversary of Mali's independence in 2010 and then after the 2012 crisis. Here the values and ethics of ‘the idea of “Malian music”’ serve a critical enquiry about a potential Afropolitan sense of national patriotism.
The conclusion offers a criticism of the paradigm of cosmopolitanism to further assert the use of Afropolitanism as the main theoretical framework of the book. However, although the demonstration convinces the reader in many ways through the various case studies, the suspicious might remain doubtful towards the relevance of particularizing and stressing an ‘African ethos’, albeit criticized by the author, whereas the pervasive ‘local Mande morality’ has been so thoroughly described. One might be tempted to tentatively suggest a local shift to Afropolitanism – while remaining aware of the embedded essentialism conveyed therein – in terms of a potential Mandopolitanism perhaps? This is an open question.
Thanks to a well-defined theoretical agenda complemented by a well-balanced book structure, an undeniable skill for ethnographic descriptions, a catchy narrative structure of the chapters, and a careful analysis of the song lyrics mainly in Bambara, Skinner not only offers a clear framework to listen to and interpret the multilayered Malian musicians’ discourses in a postcolonial ‘Afropolitan’ world, but also simply reasserts and brilliantly demonstrates how music is a privileged site for addressing collective and individual as well as political, social, and economic issues that are at stake in postcolonial Africa.
