As seems entirely appropriate for a Festschrift presented to Peter Brown, this volume takes as its purview a very broad conception of Late Antiquity, offering to the reader essays spanning late Roman, early medieval, Byzantine and early Islamic societies. The editors have gathered together seventeen illustrious contributors within these fields and, while asking them to reflect on Brown's many areas of interest, have also allowed them to explore their own without thematic constraint. Robert Markus’ piece, which opens the volume, considers the influence of both Brown and Henri-Irénée Marrou on the development of late antique studies. It is not merely a retrospective of their contributions to scholarship, but also a personal memoir of Markus’ own intellectual journey through the transformation of Christianity in the post-Constantinian age, concluding by re-iterating Brown's recognition of the variety of late antique ‘Christianities’ (13). The papers by Averil Cameron and Glen Bowersock both thoughtfully consider the relationship between ‘Old’ and ‘New’ Rome: the former details evidence for knowledge of Latin in Justinianic Constantinople, concluding that there is no simple account of its fate. In doing so, Cameron not only re-evaluates John Lydus’ claims concerning the decline of Latin, but addresses broader issues by questioning the existence of a ‘crisis of culture under Justinian’ (36). Bowersock offers a survey of the new capital's developing nomenclature, first as ‘New’ or ‘Second’ Rome and then, across an impressive range of late antique material, including Syriac and Arabic texts, simply as ‘Rome’. The core of Sebastian Brock's chapter is a translation of a ninth-century Syriac document detailing the regulations of an association of Christian craftsmen and intended as a model for others. In dating the origins of this work to the late Sassanian period, Brock offers a tantalizing glimpse of continuity in such institutions between the classical and the early Islamic periods. Sidney Griffith then offers an example of cultural interchange from eighth- and ninth-century Syria-Palestine, arguing forcefully from the works of John of Damascus and Theodore Abū Qurrah that the iconophobic behaviour of many Christians owed much more to their Muslim and Jewish neighbours than to contemporary Byzantine concerns.
With Rita Lizzi Testa, the reader is taken back to the fourth century to re-evaluate the administrative reforms of Constantine and the ‘senatorial reaction’ to them. Through a detailed discussion of the relevant passages of Ammianus and Zosimus, Lizzi Testa concludes that the emperor Julian sent two separate letters to the Roman Senate in the period just after his acclamation as Augustus and that it is his writings, together with later political upheavals, that constructed Constantine as an unpopular innovator. John Matthews, Claude Lepelley and Philip Rousseau then lead us into the age of Jerome and Augustine. Matthews’ lively and entertaining piece examines Christian and pagan attitudes to death in late fourth-century Rome. Lepelley illuminates Augustine's criticisms of ‘unreliable’ hagiographies and martyr acts that lack proper documentation, revealing (with apologies for anachronism) ‘un aspect positiviste’ (147). Rousseau's insightful exploration of Augustine's reading of Varro is a nuanced examination of the latter's religious and political thought and the approaches of both men to the role of consuetudo in Roman religion. This triptych of essays not only questions whether Jerome and Augustine were representative of their Zeitgeist but, perhaps more significantly, invites the reader to reflect on whether an identifiable Zeitgeist existed.
Charlotte Roueché's brief piece starts from a theatre graffito at Ephesus that may depict a scene from the Book of Tobit in order to ask whether late antique theatrical performances were often the purveyors of wholesome Christian narratives and not just the debauchery that so troubled John Chrysostom. Claudia Rapp then presents a wide-ranging survey of writing and sinfulness in early Byzantine Christianity, focusing on the cheirographon, both physical and metaphorical. Rapp's fascinating account examines a number of stories in which the intercession of living or dead holy men led to the miraculous erasure of lists of an individual's sins, touching on their relationship with classical attitudes, both legal and magical, towards the power of the written word. The symbolic power of writing and its destruction is then explored further in Judith Herrin's paper on book burning, which starts in the Roman Empire before making a broad sweep through Late Antiquity, with particular emphasis on the Quinisext Synod of a.d. 692, to argue that this practice was more concerned with purification than censorship. Lellia Cracco Ruggini and Giorgio Cracco then narrow the focus onto the towering figure of Gregory the Great. Their detailed account of his Expositio in Librum I Regum not only seeks to settle the matter of the text's authenticity, but also to explain the political context of its composition, as well as its lack of citation until the twelfth century, in the work's image of ‘una Chiesa di predicatori-profeti’ (255).
Starting from a passage in Gregory's Dialogues, Peregrine Horden speculates on ‘the late antique origins of the lunatic asylum’ by assembling the material on the accommodation of the mentally ill in hospitals during this period. His essay is particularly notable for its discussion of the development of shrines as institutions for the care of the sick. Susanna Elm and Julia Smith then provide a pair of illuminating papers on gender and literary construction in very different historical contexts. Elm challenges a number of views on the redefinition of masculinity in Late Antiquity to provide a fascinating account of Gregory of Nazianzus’ self-promotion as a ‘Christian philosopher’, simultaneously maternal and paternal towards his followers, which is then compared to the emperor Julian's conception of his own role. Smith considers the life and afterlives of the sixth-century saint Radegund of Poitiers, exploring her transformation from hostage bride into virginal holy woman and on to model for ascetic behaviour and ecclesiastical organization. Peter Garnsey completes the volume by taking the reader to the very end of the Byzantine Empire and the political philosophy of George Gemistus Plethon, who sought to apply Platonic theories in the reinvigoration of the faded superpower. In particular, Garnsey explores the ways in which Plethon interpreted and adapted the model set out in Plato's Republic, as well as highlighting the misrepresentations of this text by Aristotle, Proclus and Thomas More. The chronological and thematic breadth of the volume, like the lengthy ‘select bibliography’ of Peter Brown that introduces it, stands as testament to his exceptional and wide-ranging influence.
