In his latest book, William Schniedewind attempts to determine when the Bible was written, why it was written and how the Bible became a book by investigating the phenomena of orality and textuality in ancient Israel. Schniedewind frames his arguments for a lay audience, perhaps the only way to handle these vexing issues in a 257-page volume. He readily admits that scholars may be frustrated by this approach (p. viii), but hopes that the guild will engage his ideas nonetheless. Measuring by the early and vigorous response to this book, his hope has been realised (cf. Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 5 (2005), article 18; www.jhsonline.org). Indeed, How the Bible Became a Book is another formidable salvo in the ongoing debate on the origin of the biblical texts, with Schniedewind claiming that much of the Hebrew Bible was written during the late Judean monarchy, rather than the Persian period or later.
Schniedewind begins by describing the social location of writing in the ancient Near East as a tool of royal and religious administration. In the late eighth century BCE, favourable conditions for the flourishing of writing first emerged in Jerusalem. Its bureaucracy burgeoned because of a massive population influx from the Northern Kingdom and the Judean hill country in the wake of Neo-Assyrian military campaigns. During this ‘golden age of biblical literature’, Hezekian scribes first wrote down the Mosaic and priestly oral traditions, composing and arranging the Tetrateuch. They also laid the framework for Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings, enshrining the reigns of David and Solomon as ‘the golden age of Israel’. Hezekiah's political vision motivated this literary activity for, as a Davidic heir, Hezekiah saw himself ushering in a new United Kingdom. The biblical literature thus served the important political function of integrating Northern refugees by validating their traditions and combining them with Southern ones.
On the basis of inscriptional evidence (especially ostraca), Schniedewind argues that the process of textualisation – the movement of writing from the temple and court into the general populace – progressed rapidly in the seventh-century reign of Josiah. As literacy spread throughout the society, the written text became a tool for Josiah's political, social and religious revolution. Demonstrating a strikingly different ideology from that of Hezekiah, Josianic literature castigated the North and embraced the cause of ‘the people of the land’ – rural southern tribal leaders who advocated a return to Judah's loose democratic confederation. Reflecting this Josianic vision are Deuteronomy, the Josianic redaction of DtrH and certain Deuteronomic additions to the Tetrateuch (particularly in Exod 24).
To determine the levels of redaction, Schniedewind eschews traditional source- and redaction-critical methods and analyses texts based upon a new criterion: how the texts relate to their own textuality (p. 118). For example, since pre-Josianic traditions reflect an oral understanding of torah and post-Josianic and post-exilic texts presume a written Torah, Schniedewind determines that the description of Moses’ writing down the words of Yahweh in Exod 24:2–4 marks this text as a Deuteronomic (i.e., Josianic) addition. This particular text bears witness to a conflict that arose in the Josianic period between written and oral instruction – between the authority of the book and that of the teacher – which resurfaces throughout the later biblical literature, in formative Judaism and in early Christianity.
The Babylonian exile radically interrupted the process of textualisation. Schniedewind claims that undeniably Babylonian texts such as Psalms 79 and 137 and the Book of Lamentations were sung, not written in the exilic period, so they do not provide evidence of literary activity among most exiled Jews. In Babylon, writing continued only among Jehoiachin's scribes, who undertook another redaction of DtrH to substantiate the legitimacy of this exiled king.
In chapter 9, ‘Scripture in the Shadow of the Temple’, Schniedewind refutes Phillip Davies' notion that the Hebrew Bible is the ‘fiction of Jewish nationalists writing in the fourth century BCE’ (p. 18). Schniedewind also takes aim at Giovanni Garbini's contention that ‘under the domination of the Achaemenids, Hebraism knew its magical moment and Hebrew literature its golden age’ (p. 166). In contrast to these scholars, Schniedewind argues that the Persian period was ‘a dark age for biblical literature’ (p. 193). In a time marked by retrenchment rather than literary flourishing, priests and scribes laboured to preserve the biblical literature by editing and shaping it into books. The Persian period saw the composition of Chronicles (‘a poor excuse for literature’ (p. 184)), Ezra-Nehemiah, Esther and Ecclesiastes, the organisation of the Minor Prophets and the final editing of the Pentateuch. According to Schniedewind, Persian-period priests shaped the identity of the Jewish people by freezing oral tradition and ensconcing the prophetic ‘word of God’ as text. On this point, as in many other places throughout the work, Schniedewind shows a distinct preference for orality over textuality, making such broad claims as: ‘oral torah was egalitarian, whereas Scripture was elitist’ (p. 15). He asserts elsewhere that writing supplants the ‘living teacher’, undermines community and hinders true wisdom (p. 114). However, he posits that formative Judaism and Christianity restore the role of oral tradition and teaching. For example, he writes, ‘Paul advocated for the living voice . . . called to preach, not to write’ (p. 211); and ‘despite Jesus’ use of the text to critique the religious establishment, he claims a higher authority that is not textually based’ (p. 211).
One of the strongest aspects of the book is Schniedewind's analysis of the social and economic conditions in the eighth and seventh centuries. Largely on the basis of archaeological and epigraphic evidence, Schniedewind argues persuasively that literacy flourished during this period. He goes on to claim that since ‘textualisation’ was taking place at this time, biblical literature was indeed being written then. While not an unreasonable conclusion, this is by no means a necessary one. One may well argue that if literacy did develop in this period, it does not mean ipso facto that the biblical texts were then taking shape.
In addition to archaeological evidence, Schniedewind turns to the biblical text itself to argue for its origin in the eighth and seventh centuries. Unfortunately, the reader remains largely unaware of Schniedewind's reasons for accepting the historical accuracy of certain biblical accounts. For example, without explanation, he takes the description of King Solomon's court (which included scribes) to be thoroughly historical (1 Kgs 4:3). However, in the account of the discovery of the scroll of the law in 2 Kgs 22, Schniedewind argues that the ostensibly old scroll of the law was in fact a work created by Josianic scribes, quite against the biblical text's claims. Yet in the same pericope, Schniedewind accepts the narrative of Josiah's installation by the ‘people of the land’ (2 Kgs 21:24) as historically accurate. Schniedewind may have decided that engaging the questions of the historical accuracy of these texts would have alienated his target audience: lay readers. However, the lack of a forthright and consistent approach to the Bible's historical claims, and particularly the claims of 2 Kgs 22, is likely to confound scholarly and lay readers alike. Moreover, the arguments of the minimalists have become so popular that even non-specialists now expect extensive justification for taking any biblical text at face value. Without such justification, many readers will remain unconvinced of Schniedewind's provocative claims, regardless of the merits of his approach.
