Dale Torston Graden's book explores the different forces that led to the end of the slave trade to Brazil in 1850 and the gradual abolition of slavery between 1871 and 1888. It is a well-researched book, full of interesting stories about slave revolts, ship wrecks, British navy interceptions of slave traders, and the adventures and misadventures of abolitionists in Bahia.
The book first recognizes that there are three explanations for the abolition of slavery and the end of slave trade. First, religious and labor groups, mostly in England, “heightened awareness,” influenced the abolitionist movements in the Americas, and pressured the British Empire to end the slave trade. Second, the expansion of “industrial capitalism” brought with it “a free labor ideology” and, thus, a condemnation of “slavery as inefficient and inhumane.” Finally, the increasing slave resistance in the Americas played a major role in the demise of slavery.
For Graden, slave resistance was the most important domestic factor that led to ending slavery in Bahia. For him, the process of abolition is “far more complex than merely the handing down of laws by enlightened leaders and parliaments” (p. xviii). He focuses on the lives and activities of lesser-known participants. Using police and other archival records, the author reconstructs the actions of African slaves, African freedmen, and other activists who helped to mount a systematic and continuous resistance against the institution of slavery without entering politics directly. These actors manifested their resistance through revolts, street protests, and slave flights, and in many other ways.
The book is divided into three parts. The first part describes British pressure to halt the slave trade, some forms of protest against this trade on the coast of Africa, and the increasing resistance and rejection of the slave trade in Bahia after the 1835 Malês Revolt, the largest slave rebellion in the Americas. The argument of this first part of the book (chapters 1 and 2) is that opposition against the slave trade increased in Brazil out of the fear that continuing the slave trade would generate more social instability. The second part of the book, chapters 3 and 4, focuses on the domestic factors leading up the passing of the Law of the Free Womb in 1871. This law intended to emancipate slaves born after 1871 once they were eight years old. The government committed to pay slave owners a compensation for each freed slave, but in practice emancipation was not widely enforced (at least according to the author). According to Graden different forms of slave resistance and antislavery protests intensified in the period leading up to the legislation, especially after the war with Paraguay (1864–1870). For the author, the “often-brutal recruitment of soldiers for the war effort caused upheaval throughout the empire” (p. 228). Pressure related to these upheavals led, to a large extent, to the passing of the Law of the Free Womb.
Finally, in the third part of the book, the author explores the forms of resistance that led to the complete abolition of slavery in 1888. Between the 1870s and 1888 resistance against slavery increased in Bahia and throughout Brazil. On the one hand, during this period abolitionist societies increased their intellectual influence, either in newspapers, in literary works, or directly in politics. On the other hand, this period also witnessed an intense internal slave trade because the decline of the sugar economy in the northeast was followed by the boom of coffee plantations in the southeast. In the author's view, “slaves reacted with hostility when torn from families and environments to which they had adapted” (p. 157). The book ends with an additional chapter exploring life after the abolition of slavery. The main argument of this chapter is that exclusion and marginalization followed emancipation. This attitude against Brazilians of African origin continued until the twentieth century.
For those economic historians who like explicit hypothesis testing and clear counterfactuals, this might be the wrong book to read in order to understand the economics of abolition in Brazil. The book is not a horserace of the hypotheses that might have led to the abolition of the slave trade and slavery itself. On the contrary, it explicitly argues that it is hard to pick a winner among existing hypotheses and tries to call our attention to slave resistance as another plausible explanation. In the end, economic historians will be left wanting more. For instance, there seems to be a problem of causality (endogeneity). We do not know how much slave resistance actually caused any of the abolitionist legislation or if some forms of resistance were simply fueled by the abolitionist movement in Europe and Brazil. The merit of the book, however, will be as a fun and useful starter for undergraduate students interested in the abolition of slavery in Brazil.
