With his Roman Seas, Justin Leidwanger proposes a challenging ‘multiscalar’ analysis of the Roman Mediterranean. The multiscalar approach, which has been increasingly popular in the last two decades, puts the emphasis on the study of social phenomena at various levels. The goal is to examine the various degrees of interaction that develop at each level, without necessarily implying a hierarchy between them. Four levels of analysis frame L.'s study: the Mediterranean basin as a whole; the Eastern Mediterranean basin; the regions of Southern western Asia Minor and Cilicia/Cyprus; and, finally, the two micro-regions of the Knidian peninsula and south-central southern Cyprus.
Ch. 1 sets the debate. In line with both Braudel and Horden and Purcell, L. starts from the obvious: trade was the linchpin of the Roman economy. It was vital to feed the huge cities of Rome and Constantinople, and no less the huge armies that protected the frontiers. But for L. this does not mean that all ancient Roman trade should fall into the category of macro-directional trade. Judging that it is impossible to develop a unified view of the world of Roman trade, L. wants to analyse the various ‘economies’ that composed it.
Ch. 2 is devoted to the conditions of navigation in the Eastern Mediterranean, with the opposition between the summer regime of the Etesian northerly winds and the winter regime of southerly winds. It also provides an overview of the progress and limits of the improvements of naval technology in the longue durée (L. does not believe that the lateen sail represented a fundamental progress). It also puts to good use the data relating to the travels of the modern replica of the ancient ship of the (pre-Roman) Kyrenia wreck: its speed fits with the estimates of journey times provided by ancient sources.
In ch. 3, the emphasis is put on ‘maritime cultural landscape’, that is on maritime life in a broad sense from shipbuilding to fishing and port life. This allows L. to capture the flexibility of this life and, for instance, to blur the distinction between fishing and trade (fishermen could indeed be occasional traders and could certainly transform themselves into sailors on board merchantmen—which nevertheless does not mean that the two activities of professional fisherman and sailor should be confused).
Ch. 4 is dedicated to a double analysis of shipwreck data. At a macro-level, it presents an updated comparative study of the shipwrecks of the whole Mediterranean and of the eastern Mediterranean only. Interestingly, it shows in both cases a clear decline in the number of wrecks as early as the first part of the second century c.e. But a crucial difference is that while in a pan-Mediterranean perspective the number of wrecks continues to decline in the Late Antique period, by contrast in the eastern Mediterranean the number of wrecks spikes again after 500 c.e. At a regional level, this eastern Mediterranean pattern is reflected also in the analysis of a subset of sixty-seven wrecks off south-western Turkey and Cyprus. An inspiring network analysis of this subset shows, however, a sharp difference between the Early Roman period, with the Aegean in a central position, and the Late Antique period, when the Cyprus/Cilicia region played that role.
Ch. 5 focuses on the ports and maritime activities of the micro-regions of the Knidian peninsula and of the south-central region of the island of Cyprus. It reveals the density of local ports, and the intensity of the short-haul traffic they suppose. In a Braudelian and multiscalar perspective, L. might have introduced the longue durée into his analysis. The Kitab-ı Bahriye (Book of Navigation, of 1521) by the Ottoman admiral and geographer Piri Reis provides a detailed description of the Knidia. Together with ancient data and modern navigation reports, it contributes to revealing the sharp dissymmetry between the two coasts of the peninsula, the northern one being battered by the Etesian winds in the summer (the season of navigation), while the southern one is well protected from them (see A. Bresson, Anatolia Antiqua 19 (2011), 395–409).
Ch. 6 connects the threads of previous analyses and interrogates the roles of the market, of the cities and of the state in determining the main features of maritime trade in the Roman period. L. is ready to accept Chris Wickham's view that through massive fiscal transfers of bulk everyday goods the state was the essential driving factor of the Roman ‘world system’. But he adds that these transfers were themselves dependent on ‘a larger world of diverse commercial exchanges that moved the bulk of goods both within and among regions’ (221).
L.'s innovative research represents a most welcome contribution to the analysis of the ancient Roman economy, which will certainly spark a rich debate. Without further ado, one may start from a question suggested by the book. L. emphasises the third-century crisis (207), well marked by a sharp drop in his regional shipwreck graphs. But his pan-Mediterranean and even eastern-Mediterranean graphs show that, overall, the decline in traffic began as early as the first half of the second century. If so, should not we move beyond the ‘usual suspects’, ‘drought, disease, political instability, inflation, …’ (207) to account for the crisis of the Empire?
