Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:00:41.756Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Hydrogel sphere impact cratering, spreading and bouncing on granular media

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2021

Xiaoyan Ye*
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory of Mechanics on Disaster and Environment in Western China attached to the Ministry of Education of China, Department of Mechanics and Engineering Science, School of Civil Engineering and Mechanics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000 Gansu, PR ChinaPhysics of Fluids Group and Max Planck Center Twente for Complex Fluid Dynamics, Faculty of Science and Technology, MESA+ Institute and J. M. Burgers Centre for Fluid Dynamics, University of Twente, P.O. Box 217, 7500AE Enschede, The Netherlands
Devaraj van der Meer
Affiliation:
Physics of Fluids Group and Max Planck Center Twente for Complex Fluid Dynamics, Faculty of Science and Technology, MESA+ Institute and J. M. Burgers Centre for Fluid Dynamics, University of Twente, P.O. Box 217, 7500AE Enschede, The Netherlands
*
†Email address for correspondence: yexy@lzu.edu.cn

Abstract

The impact of a hydrogel sphere onto a granular target results in both the deformation of the sphere and the formation of a prominent topographic feature known as an impact crater on the granular surface. We investigate the crater formation and scaling, together with the spreading diameter and post-impact dynamics of spheres by performing a series of experiments, varying the Young's modulus $Y$ and impact speed $U_{0}$ of the hydrogel spheres, and the packing fraction and grain size of the granular target. We determine how the crater diameter and depth depend on $Y$ and show the data to be consistent with those from earlier experiments using droplets and hard spheres. Most specifically, we find that the crater diameter data are consistent with a power law, where the power exponent changes more sharply when $Y$ becomes less than 200 Pa. Next, we introduce an estimate for the portion of the impact kinetic energy that is stored as elastic energy during impact, and thus correct the energy that remains available for crater formation. Subsequently, we determine the deformation of the hydrogel spheres and find that the normalized spreading diameter data are well collapsed introducing an equivalent velocity from an energy balance of the initial kinetic energy against surface and elastic energy. Finally, we observe that under certain intermediate values for the Young's modulus and impact velocities, the particles rebound from the impact crater. We determine the phase diagram and explain our findings from a comparison of the elastocapillary spreading time and the impact duration.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Young's modulus $Y$ of hydrogel spheres obtained after polymerization of different acrylamide and bisacrylamide concentrations. Here, $\Delta Y$ represents the standard deviation in the target modulus $Y$, obtained from different batches of hydrogel spheres using the same solutions and preparation method. Note that the variation of the modulus within a batch of particles is significantly smaller than $\Delta Y$ and therefore more precise values may be found within this study. In general, the value of $Y$ can be obtained with an error $< 1\,\%$, except for $Y \approx 100$ Pa, where the measurement is difficult due to the large gravitational deformation of the sphere. Also note that not all batches listed in this table have been used for experiments reported in this study.

Figure 1

Figure 1.(a) Sketch of the homemade Young's modulus test set-up which is composed of a scale and a plate attached to a micrometer. The hydrogel spheres are placed between the scale and the plate. The vertical deformation $\delta$ and the corresponding force $F$ are measured while adjusting the micrometer. Springs connect the plate that moves downward due to the action of the micrometer to the plate above and put tension on the lower plate such that it stays horizontal while moving up and down. (b) Force $F$ and vertical deformation $\delta$ are plotted in a double-logarithmic plot. The dashed line represents the power-law scaling with exponent $3/2$ expected based on the Hertz theory.

Figure 2

Figure 2.(a) Sketch of the experimental set-up. Before impact, a granular target is prepared in a given packing fraction by fluidization with dry air and subsequent tapping. The impact of the hydrogel sphere and its deformation are subsequently imaged with one high-speed camera, while simultaneously, the deformation $z(x,y,t)$ of the granular bed is measured using two laser sheets imaged by a second high-speed camera. A two-dimensional scan of the surface is made before and after the experiment using the same laser sheets and a translation stage (not depicted) providing the three-dimensional crater profile. (b) An example of the three-dimensional crater profile resulting from the impact of a $Y = 100$ Pa hydrogel sphere at an impact speed $V = 2.88$ $\textrm {m}\,\textrm {s}^{-1}$ on a granular bed consisting of $200\,\mathrm {\mu }$m beads at a packing fraction $\phi = 0.592$. Note that for these impact parameters the hydrogel sphere remains visible in the centre of the crater profile. The grey colour indicates regions where height measurement data were not acquired due to partial obstruction of the laser sheet or poor reflectivity of the hydrogel sphere. The scale bar in the image has a length of $2.00$ mm.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Snapshots from the impact of hydrogel spheres onto a sand bed with an average grain diameter of $114$ $\mathrm {\mu }$m, for three different values of the Young's modulus of the sphere, namely (a) $100$ Pa, (b) $5000$ Pa and (c) $30\,000$ Pa, each for the same impact velocity $U_0 = 1.5$ $\textrm {m}\,\textrm {s}^{-1}$. Each row represents five consecutive snapshots of an impact, where the leftmost column illustrates the moment of initial contact between the hydrogel sphere and the granular target, $t=t^*$. The subsequent snapshots correspond to $t=t^*+10$ ms, $t=t^*+30$ ms, $t=t^*+70$ ms and $t=t^*+270$ ms.

Figure 4

Figure 4.(a) The dimensionless maximum crater diameter $D_{c}^\infty /D_0$ versus the non-dimensionalized kinetic energy $E_{k}/E_{g}$ of the impact of hydrogel spheres with different Young's moduli $Y$ onto a granular bed with average grain diameter of 200 $\mathrm {\mu }$m and a packing fraction in the range 0.585–0.62. The data are compared with those obtained in de Jong et al. (2021) for the impact of solid spheres (red open circles) and water droplets (blue open circles) of similar size on a granular bed of similar grain size and packing fraction (see legend). (b) The same data as in (a), but now plotted doubly logarithmically to verify behaviour that is consistent with a power law. Note that the data have been shifted in the vertical direction to avoid overlapping of the data for different values of $Y$. (c) Power-law exponents $\beta$ (filled symbols) obtained for the data presented in (b), as a function of the Young's modulus $Y$ of the hydrogel spheres. The open symbols are power-law-exponent data obtained from plotting $D_{c}^\infty /D_0$ against the corrected kinetic energy $E_s/E_g$, where Young's moduli have been slightly shifted for visualization purposes. (d) The dimensionless crater depth $Z_{c}^\ast /D_0$ versus the non-dimensionalized kinetic energy $E_{k}/E_{g}$ for the same data as presented in (a), under the same conditions and again compared with the solid sphere (red dots) and droplet (blue dots) data. Note that the legend of (a) is shared by the other panels.

Figure 5

Figure 5.The relevant average deceleration experienced by (a) a droplet impacting on a solid, (b) a hydrogel sphere impacting on a solid, (c) a droplet impacting on sand and (d) a hydrogel sphere impacting on sand. Here, $R_{0}$ is the radius of the droplet, which is approximately equal to the deformation of the droplet during impact onto a solid, $\delta _{m}$ is the maximum vertical deformation of the hydrogel sphere, such that $\delta _{m}/2$ is the displacement of its centre of mass, and $Z_{c}^\ast$ is the maximum crater depth reached during impact.

Figure 6

Figure 6.(a) Rescaled crater diameter $D_{c}^\infty /D_0$ and (b) rescaled crater depth $Z_{c}^\ast /D_0$ versus the rescaled portion of the impact kinetic energy going into sand deformation $E_{s}/E_{g}$. The data in these plots are the same as presented in figure 4, where the red and blue open circles respectively represent the solid-sphere and droplet impact data of de Jong et al. (2021) and the filled symbols represent the current hydrogel sphere data.

Figure 7

Figure 7.(a) Dimensionless maximum spreading diameter $d_{m}/D_{0}$ of the hydrogel spheres and (b) spreading time $\tau _{max}$ versus dimensionless impact kinetic energy $E_{k}/E_{g}$ for the impact of hydrogel spheres with different Young's moduli $Y$ onto a granular bed with average grain diameter of 200 $\mathrm {\mu }$m and a packing fraction in the range 0.585–0.62, i.e. for the same parameters as presented in figures 4 and 6.

Figure 8

Figure 8.The dimensionless maximum spreading diameter $d_{m}/D_{0}$ of the impacting hydrogel spheres is plotted against (a) the modified elastic Mach number $(\delta _{m}/(\delta _{m} + 2Z_{C}^\ast ))^{1/2}(U_0/U_e)$ and (b) the modified elastocapillary Mach number $(\delta _{m}/(\delta _{m} + 2Z_{C}^\ast ))^{1/2}(U_0/U_{ec})$ as explained in the text. Note that the dataset of figure 7 (i.e. for average grain diameter of $200$ $\mathrm {\mu }$m and a packing fraction in the range 0.585–0.62) has now been enlarged to also include smaller average grain diameter ($114$ $\mathrm {\mu }$m) and smaller packing fractions (in the range 0.55–0.585).

Figure 9

Figure 9.Phase diagrams for the bouncing of hydrogel spheres after impact on a granular bed, presented in the parameter space created by the Young's modulus $Y$ on the vertical axis and the impact velocity $U_0$ on the horizontal axis. Red symbols indicate a rebound, whereas blue symbols represent impacts where bouncing is absent. The difference between the panels is in the packing fraction of the granular substrate, which in (a) ranges from $0.55$ to $0.585$ and in (b) from $0.585$ to $0.62$. In both cases, the average grain diameter is $200$ $\mathrm {\mu }$m. The different symbols denote the Young's modulus and have the same meaning as in figure 7.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Measured spreading time $\tau _{max}$ scaled by one quarter of the theoretical oscillation time ($\tau _{osc}$) plotted versus the modified elastocapillary Mach number $(\delta _{m}/(\delta _{m} + 2Z_{C}^\ast ))^{1/2}(U_0/U_{ec})$. Note that the extended dataset from figure 8 has been used to create this plot, using the same symbols and colour coding.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Ratio of the spreading time $\tau _{max}$ and the inertial time $\tau _{i}=(\delta _{m}+2Z_{C}^\ast )/U_{0}$ versus the modified elastocapillary Mach number $(\delta _{m}/(\delta _{m} + 2Z_{C}^\ast ))^{1/2}(U_0/U_{ec})$. Note that the extended dataset from figure 8 has been used to create this plot, using the same symbols. This plot is a recast of the bouncing phase diagrams (figure 9) (for an extended dataset), where red symbols indicate a rebound and blue symbols represent impacts where bouncing is absent. The horizontal and vertical dashed black lines are located at $\tau _{max}/\tau _{i} = 1$ and $(\delta _{m}/(\delta _{m} + 2Z_{C}^\ast ))^{1/2}(U_0/U_{ec}) = 1$, respectively, and are indicative of the upper (or inertial) transition and the lower (or elastocapillary) transition between which bouncing is expected to occur, as explained in the text.