Susan Strange has left an indelible mark on the field of global political economy (GPE), and the 2008 financial crisis provides fertile ground to revisit her contributions. Randall Germain's new edited volume, Susan Strange and the Future of Global Political Economy: Power, Control and Transformation, takes up this challenge. The collection features pieces that constitute a great breadth and depth of knowledge of the field, ranging from the complexity of the problems facing the world post-2008, to the resilience of the United States' structural power in managing those problems, to the theoretical intricacies of integrating Strange's work with other theorists, most notably, Michel Foucault, Antonio Gramsci and E.H. Carr. The contributors harness Strange's theory and praxis, each in their unique way, to build off and sharpen their analyses.
As is to be expected with a contrarian scholar such as Strange—one who clearly delighted in being difficult to categorize and who vehemently argued for the integration of a diverse range of scholarly fields—the contributors come to a wide range of conclusions as to what Strange's legacy means and how best to leverage her work to understand present circumstances. Germain's edited volume is an important contribution to better understanding both Strange's legacy and the future of the field of GPE.
The 2008 financial crisis with all its complex intersecting aspects is the central focus of inquiry that animates the volume. The crisis represents a fundamental point in the history of the global political economy, one which was predicted by Strange herself in her final published piece, “The Westfailure System” (Review of International Studies 25, 1999: 345–54.). The volume locates Strange's legacy within this context, taking the crisis as an opportunity to engage with her body of work and demonstrate her continuing importance to the field. The volume does this by harnessing Strange's theories in specific ways and grouping the contributions in a manner to achieve this task. Despite the contributors' different approaches, the common thread tracing its way throughout the work is power and specifically Strange's concept of structural power. This commonality unifies the volume and helps provide an overarching narrative that a diverse range of readers will find both fascinating and useful, acting as a touchstone to return to with each new chapter.
While the theme of structural power is an overt focus of the volume, a subtler and arguably more interesting contribution is the diversity of methodological insights offered by the contributors. This focus on methodology goes beyond simple questions of the praxis of GPE to provide an accessible and important commentary on the methodology favoured by Strange: counterfactual analysis that places emphasis on key decision points. Her methodology brings the underlying structures that facilitate decision making, and the decision makers themselves, into relief. Emphasis is placed throughout the volume on the key choices of both state and non-state actors who exercise agency within the structure of the post-2008 global political economy. The contributors place these decisions in context and illustrate their importance to the production of structural power itself. This focus on methodology makes the volume useful for scholars beyond the field of GPE, an attribute fitting for a book evaluating the legacy of Susan Strange.
As Louis W. Pauly notes in his concluding chapter of the volume, “the authors took up a challenge that their shared mentor might have expressed as ‘Listen to what I say but, more importantly, watch what I do—and do it better’” (185). However, Pauly's comment also points to what can be considered the greatest weakness of the volume: Strange's methodology can be opaque and at times difficult to parse causally. Many of the individual contributors do not problematize this aspect of her method, choosing instead to adopt it largely without question. Benjamin J. Cohen's chapter provides a much needed counterpoint in this regard, helping the volume better contextualize Strange's methodology and its shortcomings within the larger GPE and social scientific canon.
Overall, the volume is an important and essential contribution that successfully demonstrates why students and scholars of GPE and the current state of the global political economy more broadly should continue to reference and leverage Strange's body of work and methodology. It is also successful in illustrating why and how the field must move beyond Strange, by building upon the foundation that she laid while remaining cognizant of the areas where that groundwork must be shored up.
