In June of 2020, Louis DeJoy, a businessman and prominent Republican donor, became the seventy-fifth Postmaster General of the United States. DeJoy quickly instituted cost-cutting measures that, critics charged, were aimed at causing mail delays that would cripple Democrats’ vote-by-mail campaigns. Looming over all of the partisan wrangling was an ongoing fiscal crisis for the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) and a fundamental question about whether the organization should operate as a public service or a business enterprise. Philip F. Rubio's Undelivered: From the Great Postal Strike of 1970 to the Manufactured Crisis of the U.S. Postal Service offers important historical insights into how we arrived at this point while issuing a full-throated defense of the USPS as a vital public service.
Undelivered is a labor and institutional history of the USPS spanning the twentieth century through the 2010s, pivoting around a strike by some 200,000 postal workers in March of 1970. For eight days, the nation held its breath as postal employees across the country walked off the job demanding better wages and greater collective-bargaining power. It remains the largest illegal “wildcat” strike in U.S. history, one that revitalized postal unions and helped spur the 1970 Postal Reorganization Act.
Rubio begins by tracing the fractured history of postal labor unions in the wake of the Civil War through the 1960s, as collective organizing often split over racial segregation, job specialization, and degrees of militancy. Despite this, postal workers on the whole were highly unionized by the 1960s. As a longtime source of African American employment, the US Post Office Department's increasingly diverse workforce also began to embrace the wave of protest and labor militancy of the 1960s. Years of meager pay increases left many postal workers needing to work a second job to support their families, while rank-and-file members grew frustrated by a lack of action by leaders of the nation's nine major postal unions.
On March 18, 1970, thousands of workers in New York City set up a picket line and the strike spread to dozens of cities across the country. A professor of history, Rubio also draws on some two decades of experience working as a mail carrier to narrate the strike. Participant interviews provide compelling anecdotes, such as of one young letter carrier who joined the picket line in Minneapolis only to have to discard his official uniform and borrow a pair of oversized pants from his father without a belt: “try holding onto a strike sign and your pants at the same time” (p. 82). Rubio uses these oral histories, union records, newspaper coverage, and government publications to argue that the strike was overwhelmingly driven by the militancy of rank-and-file union members rather than their more conservative leadership.
Rubio moves on to discuss the aftermath of the strike and the passage of the 1970 Postal Reorganization Act that dissolved the US Post Office Department as a cabinet-level entity and established the USPS as a self-supporting corporation owned by the federal government. In the wake of the strike, this legislation also extended collective bargaining rights to four major postal unions—a major victory for postal workers. At the same time, the 1970 Postal Reorganization Act ushered in an era of reforms tilted toward cost-cutting business principles rather than service-oriented management. Perhaps most importantly, the nation's postal system was cut off from taxpayer funding for the first time in its history, even as it was still required to maintain universal service regardless of profitability.
The remainder of Undelivered traces the course of postal labor unions and the USPS through the end of the twentieth century and into the 2010s, detailing how the organization staved off campaigns for privatization while continuing to serve as a source of stable public-sector employment for African Americans and, increasingly, women. Rubio ends with what he convincingly terms the “manufactured crisis” of the twenty-first century. Here, he joins other scholars in lambasting the 2006 Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act, a bipartisan piece of legislation passed during a lame duck session of Congress that, among other measures, mandated the USPS to aggressively pre-fund future retiree benefits. The USPS ended up having to set aside roughly $5.6 billion a year for the next decade, kneecapping an institutional balance sheet already hard-hit by the rise of electronic communications and a decline in mail volume.
Undelivered can occasionally lapse into a style of writing common to institutional histories, burying the reader in a blizzard of acronyms, policies, and organizational details. Although some of this comes with the territory of narrating such a large organization across a long time period, it can also obscure the bigger picture. In narrating the strike, for instance, Rubio details union meetings, votes, and walkouts in dozens of cities across the country. But participation was highly uneven; some cities had widespread activity and others none at all. This pattern would seemingly speak to the larger geography of labor activism during this period, but Rubio declines to offer an explanation, instead declaring it “a mystery absent more research” (p. 117). Fair enough, but this kind of analysis would have helped Undelivered speak to an even wider audience.
Like the best historical scholarship, Rubio's book speaks urgently to the present day. Private carriers such as FedEx and UPS have expanded, but they still cover only 20 million homes and businesses compared with 157 million served by the USPS. Some half a million postal employees help move more mail than any other postal system in the world. Yet the organization faces profound challenges and an uncertain future. As politicians and policymakers debate the USPS, they would do well to turn to Rubio's Undelivered to help decide its future.
