Since the rediscovery of Islam as a significant factor in contemporary Middle Eastern politics—a rediscovery that dates to the Iranian revolution—Islamist movements have attracted the attention of Middle East scholars. In fact, one subset of such movements, those most inclined to use political violence, has drawn the most interest from the academy as well as the media, though scholars have more recently begun to examine another larger subset of movements that conceive of their roles as educational, social, moral, and political. This book focuses on a portion of these nonviolent groups: organizations in a selection of predominantly Muslim countries, all of them Arab and none generally regarded as democratic, dedicated in significant measure to participation in legislative bodies.
The subject of investigation is a set of Islamist movements, one from each of the selected countries, all of which have won elections to legislative bodies and seek to influence political outcomes, even though the legislatures themselves exercise little authority. Not surprisingly, these Islamists experience more frustration than satisfaction and fear loss of public support as a result of their engaging in futile behavior. The authors conclude that frustration and fear are likely to diminish the willingness of such groups to stand for election and serve in legislatures in the future.
The success of the book lies in the modesty of its ambitions. Because it treats one aspect of Islamist activity in a limited number of countries over several decades, it manages to engage in genuine comparison even as it articulates the particularities of each situation. The authors argue, for example, that Islamist participation in the legislative process is probably best established and most fruitful in Kuwait (Hadas) and Morocco (Party for Justice and Development). Palestine (Hamas) and Yemen (Islah) seem the most problematic, probably as a result of the semi-chaotic contexts in which the Islamist parties must function. Egypt (Muslim Brotherhood) and Jordan (Islamic Action Front) fall somewhere in between, because the status of the legislatures and that of the Islamist groups remain variable and uncertain. The authors maintain a laudable degree of parallelism among the case studies while managing to paint distinctive portraits of the individual movements. The book consists of an introduction, case studies on one Islamist movement in each of these six countries, and a concluding chapter.
Perhaps the most striking conclusion that the author makes in regard to these movements is that they do not seek majority control of the legislatures. Hamas is the exception, though it probably did not expect the electoral success that it achieved. In most instances, winning elections outright would jeopardize the very existence of these groups, which function in authoritarian settings. The groups aim to capture enough seats to achieve a presence in the legislature and a bit of influence over policy but not so many as to constitute a serious threat to the regime. Through elections, they gain visibility that helps them to advance an agenda of religious and moral reform, as well as the opportunity to claim general support, to assert that they produce concrete benefits for constituents, and to develop a new set of political skills (pp. 185–86). The authors conclude that these movements have been somewhat successful in at least three of these four ways:
Islamist leaders have the least to show for their efforts in meeting the third goal, serving constituents. The movements have entered politics, developed platforms and drafted laws, questioned ministers, and aired scandals—and had little concrete to show for all these efforts. Sometimes the foot soldiers of the movements have found themselves harassed, arrested, or detained. On most occasions, Islamist parliamentarians find themselves outvoted (p. 187).
It does not seem that the Islamist movements studied here have themselves succeeded in nudging regimes toward democracy. Quite the contrary, the threat of Islamist success provides these governments with a rationale for subverting elections and keeping legislatures weak. The explanation for the modesty of Islamist accomplishment lies not with the movements themselves but with the contexts in which they are forced to operate. The differences in success seem to reflect local circumstances, and for that reason I would like to have seen a more thorough description of the political context in each of the six countries. Individual chapters develop the setting in only a page or two (a bit more for Kuwait and Morocco), which might not be sufficient for someone using this text in an undergraduate course. Obviously a book of such specific focus cannot offer an extensive introduction to every aspect of politics in any one case, but the authors might have provided a more thorough analysis of the role of legislatures. What can they do and what can they not do? Developing two or three scales for evaluation of that variable—total meeting time in a year, number of bills passed, number of amendments to regime proposals, and media attention to the legislature, if such information is available—might have further illuminated the relative success (or failure) of Islamist movements.
This book is nonetheless successful precisely because its scope is narrow. The authors have chosen to make it accessible to undergraduates by avoiding references to authorities in the text (endnotes serve that purpose) and by writing straightforward, jargon-free prose. They inform the reader as to which author wrote each chapter, but good editorial work has minimized stylistic differences. The authors collaborated on the introduction and conclusion. All chapters draw on Arabic sources, written and oral, as well as secondary literature. The research is solid. I recommend the book to students of comparative politics for the rigor of its comparisons and for the light it sheds both on an important subset of Islamist movements and on the authoritarian systems in which they function.
