The history of mathematics in the ancient Mesopotamian civilizations is a young field. Aside from the numerical methods of Babylonian astronomy in the late first millennium BC, known since the 1880s through the work of Joseph Epping and Franz Kugler, very few ostensibly mathematical texts had been published from cuneiform tablets before the 1920s and 1930s, when the productive scholarly rivalry of the mathematician Otto Neugebauer and the assyriologist François Thureau-Dangin yielded a corpus of Babylonian mathematical texts, mostly from the so-called Old Babylonian (OB) period (early second millennium). The initial excitement and intense activity of these decades, characterized primarily by text editions accompanied by commentaries, did not sustain itself after Neugebauer and Abraham Sachs's Mathematical Cuneiform Texts (1945). By this time Neugebauer himself was interested primarily in mathematical astronomy, and no one else who had the expertise to work closely with the original documents seems to have seen ways to open up new areas for research and interpretation. The prevailing picture of Mesopotamian mathematics was episodic and descriptive, emphasizing the sexagesimal numerical system and the more advanced ‘problem texts’ which lent themselves to algebraic interpretation by means of linear and quadratic equations. This mathematics was seen as springing into view rather abruptly in the OB period, with obscure antecedents, and then disappearing again from the textual records until, more than a millennium later, it resurfaced in more or less the same form in Seleucid and Parthian Babylonia. Hardly anything was known about the intellectual contexts in which the mathematical texts were produced, or even where they came from, since most of the texts that were known and considered interesting in the 1920s and 1930s entered modern European and American collections by way of the antiquities trade.
Eleanor Robson's Mathematics in Ancient Iraq testifies to the remarkable resuscitation and, indeed, transformation of the field that has taken place since the 1980s. One stimulus has come from the identification of mathematical texts from hitherto poorly documented periods, especially the centuries preceding the OB period, and the study of metrology and accounting practices. Our understanding of OB mathematics itself has greatly deepened, in part through analysis of the more elementary ‘school texts’ for which we often have good evidence both for provenance and for their place in the broader scribal curriculum, and in part through Jens Høyrup's persuasive reinterpretation of the language of the ‘problem texts’ as being grounded in geometrical rather than algebraic imagination. In short, not one page of this book could have been written a generation ago, when the very idea of a chronologically structured history of mathematics in the ancient Near East from the fourth through the first millennium BC would have seemed an absurd project. That this is no longer true is due especially to some half-dozen scholars, all currently active and all possessing knowledge in varying degrees of both assyriology and the history of mathematics. Among these Robson, as a professional assyriologist, is pre-eminently well positioned to write a history that situates Mesopotamian mathematics in its ancient social and intellectual context; and whether or not one always agrees with her interpretations of the mathematics, her competence in these aspects is nowhere in doubt.
Pre-OB mathematics is a challenging topic to present to a general reader. The texts are none-too-numerous and frequently obscure, and to make sense of them at even a preliminary level demands a broader knowledge of contemporary economic and social history than the OB texts; one is dealing here with the coming-into-being of mathematics. Robson's two chapters dealing with the third millennium are in fact her most successful in their clarity and balance. On controversial questions such as the degree and character of central government control of Babylonian society in the UR III period (roughly the last century of the third millennium) – a period crucial for the development of the sexagesimal place-value notation but apparently barren of activity in the ‘advanced’ domain of problem texts – she gives the reader a sufficient idea of the arguments on both sides without concealing her own opinions or delving into polemics. Her treatment of OB mathematics tends more to present a coherent picture with fewer indications of where a present consensus exists – among that half-dozen or so scholars! – or of where (as in the case of the notorious ‘Pythagorean triplets’ tablet Plimpton 322) the reader is being offered the author's stance on a disputed subject. Generally this chapter, though one of the longer ones, at forty pages, is still too short to convey the richness of the source material and the diversity of scholarly approaches, while conversely the three chapters (eighty-nine pages) devoted to Assyria and to Babylonia during the more than a millennium between the OB and Seleucid periods appear largely as placeholders covering tangential topics, since the archaeological record has yielded scarcely any mathematics from these times. Robson's chapter on the late first millennium BC, the longest, is deeply interesting for its discussion of the prospects and problems of understanding the place of mathematics in the scribal milieus that produced the tablets of mathematical and observational astronomy known from archives at Babylon and Uruk – though one gets the impression that progress in this area has barely begun. Perhaps, for that matter, it is time that the numerical methods embedded in Babylonian astronomy should themselves be studied as a part of Babylonian mathematics rather than as a related but distinct activity.
Robson provides two useful appendices: a summary of the systems of metrology employed in Babylonian mathematical texts, and a bibliographical catalogue of published texts. That this last was not able to include references to important editions of tablets by Jöran Friberg and Christine Proust that have appeared since 2007 is an indication of how lively the study of Mesopotamian mathematics is.
