In a time of increasing investment in digital research tools, this volume offers a more traditional, narrative view of a large-scale archaeological project. It aims to provide both the project results and their interpretation, and succeeds very well at the latter in particular. The accompanying online database, hosted by Brown University, is easier to navigate for stratigraphy, finds, plans and images. This two-fold approach raises an interesting debate about how we continue to communicate archaeological results, as E. Fentress discussed at the recent AIAC meeting in Bonn (2018). This dual approach has worked well for the Villa Magna project because it has such rich historical and archaeological documentation.
The organisation of the book text is straightforward. An overview and history of the project are presented in chs 1 and 2. This is followed by a review of the historical documentation relating to the site (ch. 3), and the site's setting and field survey results (ch. 4). Chs 5, 6 and 7 present the site phases in chronological order — the Imperial villa, the Byzantine era estate, and the medieval monastery and casale, respectively. General conclusions follow in ch. 8. Within each chapter, however, section organisation is often confusing. For example, the analyses of the sculpture at the Imperial villa (A. Kuttner) and of the building materials (S. Bernard, R. Veal and M. Andrews) come before the excavation details, with plans (ch. 5). Similarly, in ch. 7, the excavation details of each medieval phase come before a larger section on the cemetery (C. Fenwick), which groups all medieval phases together.
There are over forty contributing authors, and as such the quality of the writing and analysis is variable, with some repetition of results. Sections that stand out for high-quality analysis include, in ch. 5 (the villa), D. Booms on the architectural design of the winery, M. Andrews and S. Privitera on the estate-worker barracks, and S. Cox on the osteology of the infant burials; in ch. 6 (post-Roman), the ceramic analysis by D. M. Totten; and in ch. 7 (medieval), Fenwick on the cemetery and E. Nitsch on the isotope analysis of human remains.
The report highlights two key facets of rural estates. Firstly, the long chronology of the site demonstrates the investment by landowners, and how this reflected their social status and maintenance of cultural memory. The excavation of the monumental Imperial winery, with its almost theatrical cella vinaria and calcatorium, confirms the description of this feature in the letters of Marcus Aurelius. The winery and accompanying Imperial residence (only partially excavated) illustrate the significant building investment on this site, aimed at providing both dominance over wine-producing lands and a base for leisure. The investment in wine production continued to Late Antiquity, despite the abandonment of the Imperial winery c. a.d. 250. The doliarium was moved to the southern cryptoporticus of the Imperial residence, and Fenwick argues (193–5) that a newly built, but undecorated, apsidal hall facilitated the pressing of the grapes in this area. The apsidal hall is compared with one at Passolombardo, where a calcatorium was located in the apse and cella vinaria in the aisles. This is an intriguing interpretation and one that could dramatically shift our understanding of the function of apsidal halls, but without the excavation of the majority of this building at Villa Magna, and with its identification as a church securely in the sixth century, we ought to tread cautiously with an interpretation of this structure as a wine-processing facility.
In the late antique and medieval period, investment in agricultural production continued, but wine production was abandoned in favour of farming other crops and animals. The layout of the former Imperial structures serves to guide the subsequent occupations, which re-use large internal spaces. Of course, the apsidal hall, which becomes a church in the Byzantine period, stands out as the focal point of the site. There is much discussion of the potential links with the Byzantine court and papal Rome, something which the ceramic analysis, in particular, tries to tease out — were trade links closer with Roman or south Italian production? The answer seems to be both, which suggests that after it falls out of Imperial control, the site sits in the balance between the very high-status rural monasteries linked with bishops and small sites which have an elusive, if powerful, private owner. The Imperial legacy of the site must have been relevant, as was its positioning just outside of the suburbs of Rome. There was a desire to maintain control of these lands, as the historical documentation of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries makes clear, and the long occupation demonstrates the complex agricultural, political, trade and architectural importance of this site.
The second significant result of this project is that it highlights the variable quality of life of those who worked on the estate over its history. At the villa, the ‘barracks’ in Area D revealed the nature of some of the housing for Imperial estate workers, possibly slaves. The most fascinating element in the barracks is undoubtedly the five infant burials, overlaying each other in the same room. Four of the infants displayed the same markers of a genetic disease — thalassaemia — uncommon to inland populations. This indicates that the mother of these babies, slave or free, was probably a worker from a malarial, coastal region, who kept passing on a fatal genetic condition to her children.
The medieval cemetery also revealed much about the structure and health of the populations. The majority of the burials relate to the late medieval phase, and include both walled- and earth-cut tombs. There was very little evidence of hierarchy displayed in the burials of the early and central medieval phases, which S. Carocci interprets as indicating an absent or weak high social control over the population. He wonders whether this meant a higher quality of life than for those in neighbouring fortified settlements, and indeed whether this might also have fostered what he refers to as ‘female protagonism’ (408), as twelfth- and early thirteenth-century documents mention three women who were lay inhabitants of the villa. There is nothing in the archaeology to indicate this, however.
In the late medieval period, the cemetery excavations, and subsequent osteological and isotopic analysis, indicate that peasants living at Villa Magna were slightly worse off in terms of their diet and stature. The monastery was suppressed in the late thirteenth century, and the site became fortified, with evidence of an armed presence indicated by the small finds (T. Franconi). Two individuals (male and female) in the cemetery also had evidence of sword wounds to the head (F. Candilio), indicating some violence in the population.
There is no doubt that Villa Magna is an exceptional site. It is exceptional for its rich historical documentation, which connects to the archaeological record. It is also exceptional for its longevity as a rural settlement. And it is exceptional because this project has significantly contributed to our understanding of the function of agricultural estates throughout antiquity and the Middle Ages. There is a strong argument that this volume should have been divided into (at least) two smaller ones, but by amassing the results in a single volume, Fentress, Goodson and Maiuro enable us to appreciate the (very) longue durée of the site.
