Stroboscopy is a key component of examination in the voice clinic. It can be a difficult skill to master, and is best learned by repeated practice under the guidance of an experienced teacher. Thus, a book on stroboscopy might seem at first glance to be an odd concept, but there is clearly much to be gained from a text that outlines the principles of stroboscopy and presents images of pathology.
The preface sets out the intended audience: the book is not intended for all members of the voice clinic, as there is little on offer for singing teachers. Muscle tension dysphonias, for example, are only mentioned in passing. Equally, neurological and malignant conditions are mentioned very little. This seems entirely appropriate for a book whose main focus is on gaining and interpreting images of benign mucosal processes.
As with all publications from Plural, the quality of the printed product is exceptional. The images are crisp, and the book is produced in (almost entirely) full colour throughout. This is obviously mandatory for a text that relies so heavily on colour photographs.
The book is divided into two broad sections. In the first half, comprising 12 chapters, the history and basic science of stroboscopy are outlined, along with a (relatively brief) discussion of vocal fold anatomy and physiology. In the second half (15 chapters), laryngeal disorders are systematically discussed: inflammatory conditions, vocal fold scarring, benign lesions, etc.
In the first half of the book, covering the basics of stroboscopy, a comprehensive and easy-to-understand explanation of stroboscopy is presented. This does not, readers will be pleased to hear, explore in detail the mathematical principles of how stroboscopy light sources work, but provides enough information for the clinician to be able to understand the basic principles of the equipment.
The first half of the book also explains the optimal set-up for a clinic room, and how to perform the examination. One of the problems with this section of the book is a lack of diagrams or photographs: the section on examination technique, for example, is very ‘wordy’, with several pages of continuous text. This does not lend itself to easy reading. I would personally have preferred to have the text broken up with some tables of ‘top tips’ or photographs explaining how to avoid common pitfalls.
In the chapter on ‘Interpretation of videostroboscopy’, Dr Woo systematically covers all the points that it is important to note when interpreting video footage of an examination. This chapter is clearly laid out and comprehensive.
Interestingly, the second half of the book (on specific pathologies of the larynx) intersperses stroboscopic images with photographs taken in the operating theatre. These latter photographs are of equivalent quality to the photos taken in the clinic room – a testament to the exceptional equipment that is now available in voice clinics. With hundreds of clinical photographs, this second half of the book almost serves as an atlas of laryngeal examination. It is certainly very useful to be able to refer to the photographs when looking for images of unusual conditions.
For a book that is purportedly solely concerned with the diagnostic process of examination in the clinic room, the second half of the book strays occasionally into the realm of investigation and treatment. For example, in the section on laryngopharyngeal reflux, there is a discussion of the investigation and management of the condition.
The book continues with sections on granulomatous diseases, granulation, laryngeal trauma, vocal fold scars, benign mucosal lesions, pre-malignant conditions, the ageing voice, benign tumours, vocal fold paralysis, neurogenic dysphonia (a very short chapter, as already mentioned) and functional dysphonia.
This is a beautifully presented book and serves as an excellent atlas of benign laryngeal lesions. However, one major shortcoming lies in the book's printed format. Interpretation of stroboscopic images requires the clinician to watch video footage, both in real time and in slow motion. Unable to present video footage in the book, Dr Woo instead offers sequential frames as montages, i.e. several successive frames presented side-by-side. Although this is the best way of presenting these images in a book, it is not a very easy way of viewing video material. It would have been very useful to include a DVD with video footage demonstrating these conditions. Production of such DVDs is time-consuming and expensive, but would have lifted this book from ‘very useful’ to ‘must-have’.
Even without video footage, however, this book is a welcome addition to the laryngeal literature. For clinicians who need a text with high quality photographs of benign laryngeal pathology, it will be very helpful.
