There is something sadly predictable about the public unfolding of the rape investigation and trial of Tariq Ramadan in France over the past three years. On the one hand, as multiple accusations of heinous acts and lurid evidence of his private desires emerged, his detractors delighted in painting Ramadan as a hypocritical sexual deviant in pious clothing, effectively recapitulating their long-standing indictment of his “double discourse” of religious extremism masked in a language of academic liberalism. On the other hand, as incriminatory testimonies unraveled under harsh scrutiny, his defenders mobilized his case (and particularly his lengthy pre-trial detention) in critique of institutional Islamophobia and double standards in the French judiciary system, sometimes relying on misogynistic portrayals of his accusers as publicity seekers with a secular feminist axe to grind who have profited from the global zeitgeist of the #MeToo movement. In both cases, the gendered and racialized figuration of Ramadan as an abject other—whether a lurking fundamentalist or a victim of discrimination—overshadows the banality of sexual violence in contemporary France and the very real lives it destroys.
Todd Shepard's magisterial Sex, France, and Arab Men, 1962–1979 provides a vital revisiting of this dynamic in an earlier moment, as he tracks the haunting presence of the “Arab man” within both official and popular French public discourse during what he calls the “post-decolonization” decades. If in the years following the Iranian Revolution, postcolonial anxieties in France would primarily come to coalesce around young veiled women as corporeal signs of a festering Islamic presence, in this earlier period it was the oversexed male bodies of primarily Algerian immigrant workers which animated both revolutionary fantasies and right-wing dystopias. In his first book, The Invention of Decolonization (2006), Shepard underlined the protracted legal and extra-legal work required to sunder Algeria from France after 132 years of colonial occupation, settlement, administrative integration, and human entanglements—a rendering which retracted French citizenship from those Muslim subjects who had struggled to acquire it, and “repatriated” to France those pied noirs (European settlers), harkis (Muslim Algerians who served as French army auxiliaries during the decolonization war), and Jews with no family histories in the metropole. In his new book, Shepard demonstrates just how incomplete and traumatic this separation proved to be. While there appeared to be a tacit agreement in the French media and political scene to turn the proverbial page on the conflict, it was certainly not forgotten—as Shepard reads French historians like Benjamin Stora as arguing (pp. 14, 20)—but rather came to underwrite broader social debates, particularly around gender and sexuality. As Shepard trenchantly proclaims in the first line of the book, “Algerian questions—and answers—made the sexual revolution French” (p. 1).
The book innovatively surveys a number of key entanglements of sex and decolonization, as they emerged chronologically from the early post-decolonization waves of Far Right anti-Arab racism and violence, through the May 1968 uprising and homosexual rights movements, to the antirape feminist activism of the late 1970s. In between, Shepard calls attention to how social debates around prostitution and sodomy likewise repeatedly referenced the Algerian conflict and projected Arab men as particularly (hyper-)sexualized subjects. Such references and projections were not ancillary, Shepard insists, but structured the ways in which the questions were framed and futures imagined. For a Far Right animated by revanchist pied noir nostalgia for a lost cause and homeland (termed “nostalgeria”), the obsession with masculine virility derived in part from an older critique of French bourgeois decadence, framed the Algerian defeat as a sexual humiliation, and summoned fears of an “Arab invasion” and reverse imperialism that continue to resound in France today. In contrast, the literal embrace of sex with “Arab” men by (white) homosexual revolutionaries like Guy Hocquenghem as a means to mitigate immigrant “sexual misery,” reverse colonial domination, and “open up space for utopian politics” (p. 92)—a movement Shepard challenges us to read as more than simply neo-Orientalism—was but a fleeting moment in the early 1970s which seems nearly impossible to imagine today given the current state of identity politics.
Throughout, Shepard, refuses to treat Maghrebi-French men and women as passive objects of discourse. Instead, he highlights their own crafted representations of sexuality in novels and films, as well as their thoughtful interventions in media debates. Shepard does not merely deconstruct racist and sexist stereotypes, but rigorously and empirically depicts the complex worlds in which representations and material realities converge and diverge, where archival evidence substantiates or contradicts sensationalist accounts. There were indeed North African pimps operating in particular neighborhoods, but police investigators actually regarded them as but marginal players in the sex trade. Sex trafficking definitely took place, including cases involving white women (la traite des blanches), but experts at the time concluded that such cases were extremely rare and almost always involved those who were already sex workers. Ultimately the book attempts to grapple with the complexity of individual lived experiences which always escape simplified images and aggregate statistics. Rape certainly served as a metaphor for imperialism, Shepard affirms, but it first and foremost was a destructive act perpetrated by men of all ethnic backgrounds, victimizing real people who struggled to tell their personal stories within the extant racial and sexual narrative frames and political sensibilities.
By putting Maghrebi-French men and women at the center of the story, the book casts new light on the 1962–79 period which has been relatively underappreciated by scholars of postcolonial France. The latter tend to jump quickly from the moment of decolonization to the early 1980s when French-born children of migrant background took political voice, achieved hesitant multicultural recognition, and began to demand a broader national reckoning with the colonial past. The immediate post-decolonization decades have long come off as a time when Algerian immigrant workers kept their heads low as part of the implicit social contract famously described by Algerian sociologist Abdelmalek Sayad (see The Suffering of the Immigrant [Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2004]). Shepard's book reminds us not only of the impossibilities of such a bargain given multiform public obsessions with “Arab men,” but also of the fact that many of this earlier generation had little choice but to violate it and make their voices heard.
But, more than a rejoinder to the accepted verities in French postcolonial history, the book also makes an original contribution to the historiography of the sexual revolution in France, and to the study of sex, gender, and sexuality more broadly. It provides important insight into the contentiously decolonizing world in which Michel Foucault, Gilles Deleuze, Félix Guattari, Roland Barthes, and others developed their theories of sexual politics. In showing how central the Algerian question and concerns over anti-Arab racism were to homosexual and feminist movements of the time, Shepard unfolds a complex case of de facto “intersectionality” long before the term had been coined and with different political valences than its contemporary usage. As a critical historian, Shepard calls into question present certainties by exploring past moments of struggle which at first blush resemble contemporary conflicts but end up unfolding in very different, sometimes unexpected ways. And he does so in unflinching, even irreverent terms, with frank discussions of sexual identities, politics, and acts that defy certain tendencies of academic puritanism. Likely teaching this book, at least in the United States, will require content warnings. But Shepard would no doubt encourage his readers to reflect on how vulnerability rather than assertion has come to define the contemporary politics of sex, and how that politics intimately intersects with new kinds of erotics around racial and ethnic difference. The simultaneous villainization and martyrization of Tariq Ramadan demands precisely such an inquiry.
