This is an important work that deserves a wide readership. Firstly, it provides new insights into the freedom movement struggle in the United Provinces (UP), especially with respect to the press and public opinion and the role of Deobandi ulama. Secondly, leading on from his detailed case study approach, Venkat Dhulipala challenges a number of orthodoxies surrounding the Pakistan movement and post-independence state construction. These include the lack of popular awareness of the Pakistan demand and its implications, Jinnah's “bargaining card” intentions and his liberal democratic vision for Pakistan, and finally the conflict between the Muslim League leadership and the ulama during the freedom struggle. In the book's powerful conclusion, Dhulipala provocatively argues that Pakistan's contemporary crises are historically rooted more in the failures to fulfill a nationalist ideology suffused with Islamic expectations and values, summed up in the expectation of creating a new Medina, than in the betrayal of what was in effect a secular nationalist struggle (p. 501).
Since Francis Robinson's pioneering study of Muslim separatism in the UP, attention has switched successively to the Muslim League breakthrough in the future Pakistan areas and to the human costs and torn identities of the subcontinent's division, which have been increasingly expressed in Manto's eponymous figure, Toba Tek Singh.Footnote 15 Dhulipala returns to the Muslim League's UP heartland to trace its political developments from the 1937 provincial elections to the “referendum” on Pakistan in 1946. He utilizes a range of sources in both English and Urdu to illustrate the fierce debates for and against the Pakistan demand in a province that would not be included in it. The material reveals that through the press and public meetings, these debates engaged large numbers of people. These nonelite responses are traced in letters to newspapers, locally circulated poetry, and published copies of speeches (pp. 244–54). They reveal a vibrant public sphere in which Pakistan was imagined and contested.
The Pakistan demand ultimately carried the day in UP, Dhulipala argues, because it fused Islamic ideals and visions with assurances of economic viability, protection of minority interests, and geostrategic arguments. He thus seeks to return ideas to a central place in the freedom struggle mobilization. This has been more recently understood in terms of interests. The volume highlights the powerful appeal of Pakistan for conceptions of both an Islamic state and pan-Islamic sentiment.
The increasing popularity of the Pakistan demand in UP is attributed to the campaigning of Deobandi ulama in the Jamiat-ul-Ulama-i-Islam (JUI) alongside students from Aligarh Muslim University and the Muslim League leadership. This is another revisionist move, as the Deobandis have been traditionally portrayed as either apolitical or hostile to the Pakistan demand. Their collaboration is revealed through the figure of Maulana Shabbir Ahmad Usmani. He is portrayed as not only linking Pakistan's creation with the establishment of a new Medina, which would further the global processes of Muslim self-purification and Islamic unity (pp. 360–61), but also marshaling statistics and census data to argue for Pakistan's economic viability (pp. 377–80). This sophisticated grasp of “relevant facts, figures and statistics” was not confined to Deobandi ulama who supported Pakistan, but was also present in the counter-arguments of those attached to the Jamiat-ul-Ulama-i-Hind.
The Muslim League's 1946 electoral triumph in UP was not as dramatic nor as vital to the achievement of Pakistan as in such provinces as Punjab and Bengal. Nevertheless, Dhulipala maintains that its characteristics challenge established views regarding the inception of Pakistan and its nation-building trajectory. The vigorous debates in the public sphere, he argues, question assumptions either that the Pakistan idea was vague, or that support was motivated by the desire for a liberal democratic state. Rather, he sees an overwhelming desire for the creation of an Islamic state, although there was no consensus about precisely how it would be implemented (p. 498). This analysis leaves no scope for the existing wisdom either that Jinnah intended Pakistan as a bargaining counter, or that it was only after Pakistan's birth that ulama who had opposed it sought to Islamicize a state created by a secular elite in liberal democratic terms. According to Dhulipala, local Muslim League functionaries in UP spoke about Pakistan's creation in terms of an Islamic state (p. 497). This ideal gave the Pakistan demand an appeal that transcended factional, sectarian, and class divisions. The message was reinforced by a powerful section of the Deobandi ulama as well as by Muslim modernists at Aligarh and even Jinnah on occasion. Here Dhulipala not only refers to ideological continuities spanning the late colonial and post-independence eras, but also hints at the ways in which Islam set limits on debates, with “political groups [being] compelled to define themselves in Islamic terms” (p. 499). Rather than there being a post-independence progressive narrowing of the public space for “secular” agendas, according to this interpretation, Islam was the language of politics from the outset.
Dhulipala's work suggests the need to revisit the Muslim League's breakthrough in the future Pakistan areas. With respect to Punjab, however, in addition to the well-established role of Sufi networks, biraderi politics seems to hold greater significance than Deobandi-influenced Islamic ideology in mass mobilization in the later stages of the Pakistan struggle. Indeed, even in Jullundur District, one of the key areas of Deobandi influence in the province, its impact was focused around the Arain community, as seen in the careers of Maulana Faqirullah Raipuri Jullundari and Maulana Khair Muhammad Jullunduri. Moreover, the most renowned Deobandi scholar in Ludhiana District, which boasted the influential madrasa Darul Ulum Naumania, Habib ur Rehman Ludhianvi, was a key opponent of the Muslim League and JUI. Further research is required to establish whether the UP pattern of mobilization detailed by Dhulipala was as universal and thus as challenging to established orthodoxies as this volume boldly claims.
