Eric Morser's boldly conceived and tightly argued history of La Crosse, Wisconsin in the nineteenth century is predicated on two distinct but closely intertwined theses. The first is that governmental institutions and policies at all levels played at least as great a role in the development of midwestern cities as did geographical location and the actions of pioneering entrepreneurs. The second is that La Crosse and other smaller cities had as great an impact on the economic development of the region as did Chicago, Milwaukee, or St. Louis. Although acknowledging that previous historians have painted a “compelling picture” of midwestern urban development, the author nevertheless contends that they have paid insufficient attention to the broader political context in which that evolution occurred.
In Morser's paradigm, the role of the federal government in the evolution of the city's political economy dates from the 1820s when the first Americans began arriving at Prairie La Crosse. As the lead miners and fur traders steadily encroached on the territory of the native Ho-Chunk peoples, the latter united behind Red Bird, who soon became “one of the most notorious inhabitants of the Old Northwest” (3). In June 1827, Red Bird and two of his followers murdered a fur trader and scalped his infant daughter. The federal government quickly mustered a contingent of soldiers, made alliances of convenience with rival Indian nations, and forced Ho-Chunk leaders to surrender Red Bird. Within a remarkably short period of time, the American military built forts for the protection of white settlers, granted favors to merchants who catered to their needs, and put down several minor Indian uprisings. Their efforts soon rendered the native peoples almost completely dependent on the trading posts for sustenance, forced them to sign treaties that would eventually deprive them of their lands, and spearheaded their ultimate removal west of the Mississippi River.
At the same time, the federal government sponsored a series of high-profile military and scientific expeditions headed by such celebrated explorers as Zebulon Pike, Stephen H. Long, Henry Schoolcraft, and David Dale Owens. Their widely circulated reports extolled the region's natural resources and limned a compelling portrait of its commercial possibilities that energized thousands of potential settlers in the eastern states and western Europe. The cross-country treks to southwestern Wisconsin were greatly facilitated by prodigious improvements in transportation largely designed and financed by federal and state governments. By the same token, policy choices by national and state lawmakers, chiefly involving land sales and preemption acts, enabled local sawyers and millers to build the lumber industry that became the primary engine of the city's prosperity.
Meanwhile, local boosters used their political clout in Madison to persuade the territorial and state governments to vest residents with the power to finance and police private businesses, while lawmakers and judges steadily enhanced the regulatory authority of the common council to build and maintain the public infrastructure. As the city grew and prospered, municipal leaders increasingly embraced state-sanctioned authority to sponsor the provision of such crucial public services as gas and electric lighting, streetcars, telephone lines, water, and sanitation. Although acknowledging that both state and local government were primarily responsive to the demands of business during most of the century, Morser contends that legislators and judges gradually began to provide opportunities for new voices, chiefly those of organized workers and women, to help define the city's future. In short, federal, state, and local officials were dynamic agents that helped La Crosse and similar midwestern cities forge their cities' commercial history from within.
To buttress his interpretation, Morser relates the stories of prominent La Crosse pioneers and demonstrates how their tales can be made even more instructive by embedding them within the context of the city's developing political economy. Chief among them were Nathan Myrick, an ambitious migrant from upstate New York who helped transform an undistinguished trading post into a burgeoning town site; Charles Colman, an early lumberman whose leadership helped La Crosse gain hegemony over its Black River competitors; Thomas Benton Stoddard, a tireless booster who spearheaded the completion of the city's first railroad; John A. Renggly, a civic-minded physician who advocated for the establishment of critical public works; David Frank Powell, whose campaigns for mayor during the 1880s mobilized working-class voters for the first time; and Fredericka Levy, the city's first successful businesswoman, whose accomplishments inspired legions of women to enter public life. Without disparaging the abilities and achievements of these movers and shakers, Morser demonstrates that much of their success was owed to their use of institutions and policies of state and local government.
Unfortunately, the author provides no such in-depth analysis of his contention that La Crosse and similar “small” cities played a major role in the economic development of the Midwest. He is on solid ground when he asserts that their inhabitants forged river and overland cities connected to nearby communities, were magnets for diverse settlers and industries, and grew into regional entrepôts that linked rural midwesterners to a much wider world. However, he verges on hyperbole when he proclaims that such activities had “an unforeseen and lasting impact upon the thousands of people who lived in the community's metaphorical shadow,” or that such cities “emerged as economic polestars at the center of their own hinterlands” (xii–xiii). Such claims beg the obvious question of the dimensions of La Crosse's hinterlands and “metaphorical shadow” compared to those of Milwaukee or St. Louis, as well as the more basic question of defining the “small” city. That such issues are clearly outside the author's purview, however, in no way diminishes his groundbreaking achievement in restoring politics and government to their rightful place in the saga of city building in the Midwest.
