No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
This monumental book addresses the questions “of who the pre–Islamic Arabs were and of their relationship to other groups in Arabia and adjacent regions.” It is meant to provide “a legible introduction to the subject which can be understood by a reader with some general knowledge about the ancient history of the Mediterranean and the Middle East” (p. xi). The task is daunting, but the author proves more than equal to it.
At the outset, the question regarding the identity of the Arabs is posed linguistically and rather literally. After considering some of the modern meanings of the word

arab, Jan Retsö moves back to the early Islamic period. There

arab appears in contrasted pairs together with terms such as

ajam, musta

riba, mawlā, and so on. The discussion of each of these is subtle and sometimes surprising. Most intriguing is the relationship of the

arab to the qurrā

or ahl al-qurā, “people of the villages” (pp. 48–51). It emerges that

arab did not, at the time of the rise of Islam, commonly designate “the members of the tribes that at some point became Muslims.” After all, the earliest Islamic fighters were known as muhājirūn, not

arab (p. 70). The tribal system familiar to us for early Islamic history, as well as the designation of its members as

arab, are thus products of the Umayyad period (661–750). Outside observers likewise did not—at least, at first—refer to these people as “Arabs.” This means that before Islam there was no concept of a nation of

arab, composed of a number of tribes all descending from an eponymous patariarch, similar to the nation of Israel familiar to us from the Bible. All this is not surprising, but it is presented convincingly and documented thoroughly. More controversial is the idea that the a

rāb, whom we think of as “nomads,” were not identified that way in the earliest Islamic texts, including the Qur

an. This term referred to a juridical status rather than a way of life: the a

rāb were the opposite of those who “emigrated,” performed muhājara (pp. 86–87). Later, Retsö claims that this status had southern Arabian roots.
The argument here is subtle, and the source material is rich. However, we may ask whether this focus on the meaning of a word is the most desirable procedure. There is some danger, after all, in viewing the early Islamic community as composed of distinct groups, such as muhājirūn, ahl al-qurā, mawālī, a

rāb, and, for all that,

arab, when these were—as Retsö himself shows—shifting and at times overlapping terms. One answer is that those historians of early Islam who are not interested primarily in the origins and development of words must nonetheless avoid constructing social groups entirely out of such terms as these. This book will give them a sense of the complexity of the terminological and other issues involved.
Thus far, I have accounted for only a fraction of the book, which then goes back to discuss the earliest Arabs known from cuneiform sources; Arabs in the Old Testament; the ages of the Achaemenids and of Alexander and his heirs; the “Nabataean problem”; the Arabs and the Roman Empire; and the Arabs as they appear in Talmudic and southern Arabian sources. The author shows a remarkable command of texts and modern scholarship in an enormous array of languages. He does not, however, make much use of the pre–Islamic (jāhilī) poetry in Arabic, probably because of the methodological problems it poses. Similarly, Retsö expresses discomfort with ancient Greek geography and other works imbued with classical learning, such as Pliny and Ammianus, although he certainly makes good use of these authors. In general, he is more comfortable with documentary sources and with literary sources that reflect official points of view.
But, of course, this subject matter is notoriously tricky, as Retsö shows again and again. Beginning with that same ancient Greek geography, “Arabia” could refer to the entire peninsula, but it more commonly designated a smaller region directly facing whoever was doing the naming. The designation “Arabs” similarly referred to a variety of groups. Beginning around A.D. 300, however, in the northern borderlands other names (Saracens/Tayyaye), that had previously appeared together with “Arabs” took the place of this older designation, although southern Arabian sources continued to mention “Arabs.” Retsö connects this change in terminology with a major social change: the “beduinization of Arabia,” which Dostal and Henninger identified earlier. The matter is more complicated than this, however. In particular, a tension between ethnic designation (Arabs as a people) and functional designations (Arabs as warriors or priests associated with sanctuaries) is never fully resolved.
Until recently, we did not have an up-to-date, one-volume survey of pre–Islamic Arabia in English. That situation changed with Robert G. Hoyland's Arabia and the Arabs from the Bronze Age to the Coming of Islam (London: Routledge, 2001). Hoyland's work is easier to handle than Retsö's and provides a first stop for those who want to enter this extensive and varied terrain. For those who want to venture farther, Retsö's book will be indispensable, even if some readers may in the end prefer to use it as a kind of reference work. The reviewer must point out that despite the author's desire to provide a “legible introduction” to the Arabs before Islam, the book's print is crowded and small, and a thorough reading can cause some eye strain. The effort, however, will be amply rewarded.