“Stories of peoplehood” are dangerous, especially for democratic politics. When one considers the global popularity of sectarian and nativist parties or the proliferation of policies that aim to preserve the economic and political welfare of democratic citizens by demonizing, detaining, and walling out people who do not belong, it is hard not to reach such a conclusion. Thinking historically, it is only too easy to point to the part that stories of peoplehood have played in inciting and sustaining political violence. Rogers M. Smith does not disagree. Yet this book insists that antidemocratic narratives must be met with counternarratives and, building on his earlier work, Smith mounts a powerful case for the importance of recognizing and cultivating the kinds of political-identity stories that can animate democratic policies and institutions.
In many ways, Political Peoplehood is deliberately out of step with the times. Eschewing the temptation to speak only to like-minded scholars, Smith addresses his argument to readers who need convincing through a rhetorical style that is itself flexible, moderate, and democratic. Where political theorists often dismiss our empirically oriented colleagues as representatives of a hostile camp, Smith essays to persuade behavioral social scientists that doing their work rigorously and carefully requires attending to normative questions. Where critics of American racism and imperialism contend that its political traditions are hopelessly tainted, Smith mines the best and worst moments in US history for resources that will challenge exceptionalism and providentialism and counteract global inequalities.
Smith divides Political Peoplehood into three sections, the first of which advances a general theory of the role of narratives, personal and collective, in political life. At the core of this theory is a heuristic device that he calls “the spiral of politics.” “Rather extravagantly,” Smith declares, “it purports to depict elements of how politics works, everywhere in the world and all through human history” (19). The spiral provides a way of visualizing how ideas, values, and interests both emerge from and fundamentally reshape the contexts in which political action takes place. It offers points of entry for different research methods and encourages a collaborative, cumulative understanding of political inquiry. Approaching political identity in this way, Smith argues, enables students of politics to discern alternatives to the “strong and wide conception of peoplehood” associated with the nation-state and to reckon with the broader range of associations that claim the right to exercise some form of governing authority over their members, often in opposition to the authority of the nation or other political communities.
The second section examines the history of American peoplehood from the revolutionary period to the age of Obama to lay bare the vexed relationship between the commitment to individual rights for all and restrictive conceptions of membership. Although the story's contours are familiar, Smith's focus on the rhetorical force of natural rights claims illuminates how and why universal rights have been championed at specific historical moments by groups as differently situated as the revolutionary generation (which downplayed these rights upon becoming the constitutional generation), white workers, abolitionists, women's suffrage advocates, and property-owning elites. “Rights stories have not been potent enough to determine the course of human events,” Smith concludes, “but in their different forms they have helped political leaders and government officials to forge coalitions and movements in support of their policies” (144). Acknowledging that the popular success of these stories has had both democratic and undemocratic implications, Smith seeks a middle way between celebratory accounts of American democratic accomplishments and the wholesale rejection of a national project that has been fundamentally defined by white supremacy and imperial ambitions.
The radical potential of Smith's middle way emerges in the third section, “Moderating Peoplehood.” At the core of this argument is a critique of the distinction between special obligations that states owe their citizens and the general obligations they have to all human beings. As Smith rightly notes, this misdescribes both the legacies of imperial power and the disproportionate effect that nations like the United States have on the well-being of peoples around the world. Smith departs from many theorists of constitutional democracy by taking global inequalities as a starting point for reflection. One of the most provocative implications is that the United States and its state governments have a responsibility to acknowledge and remedy the effects of “coercively constituted identities” by extending special opportunities for membership to Mexicans and other peoples who have been subject to US colonialism or conquest. Smith's focus on narratives and identities thus supplements political and economic analyses of immigration; he asks how histories already intertwined through violence and imposition might provide argumentative grounds for widening the pathways to jobs and possibly dual citizenship for immigrants from Mexico, the Philippines, and Haiti. Smith also observes that the broader history of American intervention could recast US responsibilities to immigrants from nations such as the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, Cuba, Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan. And the argument extends beyond the United States to any democratic nation whose present wealth was (and is) built on the backs of colonial subjects.
It would be difficult to name a scholar who has done more to expand political scientists’ understanding of the meanings of democratic citizenship as a matter of history, constitutional law, policy analysis, and normative political theory. At every turn, Smith anticipates critiques and carefully reinforces his claims. Even as he suggests that narrations of peoplehood might best be interpreted as “adventure stories,” he cautions against any retelling that forgets the brutality and loss constitutive of collective life (Stories of Peoplehood: The Politics and Morals of Political Membership [Cambridge University Press, 2003], 212). When Smith contends that his account is faithful to the way that politics actually works and “realistic” in its prescriptions, it is hard to assail his evidence. Yet Political Peoplehood does not fully address a deep tension between its attentiveness to the ugly dimensions of political peoplehood and its call for moderation. The book has surprisingly little to say about the affective work of narratives or the role of the imagination. Can moderate stories of peoplehood, told with an openness to other stories and a recognition that many individuals have multiple attachments, actually produce moderate peoples? Or do the ends Smith endorses require political languages that exceed the boundaries of such narratives and that directly contest the exclusionary vernaculars of politics?
Political Peoplehood appears to offer two answers. On the one hand, it enjoins the formation of coalitions and development of deliberative practices that might produce more moderate peoples by curbing rhetorical excess, such as appeals to prophetic authority. On the other hand, it overstates its own moderation, advancing imaginative proposals that cut against the grain of contemporary public discourse more boldly than Smith admits. Advocating “special obligations to poor noncitizens who can claim to have been coercively constituted by specific wealthy states” (259) demands a profound readjustment in the way Americans understand themselves relative to the rest of the world. It also depends on a reorientation of public thinking and feeling about how past injustices bear on the present. Smith's argument for historically conscious immigration policies may thus align him with radically antiimperial and antiracist narratives or with forms of reparations politics that he resists. Readers can appreciate how the unrealistic, immoderate dimensions of Smith's vision make its realization both unlikely and worth the fight.
