The author puts the first forty years of ballooning into the context of the Enlightenment, society, politics, economics and culture. In six chapters he gives a thorough inventory of all the flights of any importance and a number of unimportant ones. The first deals with ideas of flight, going back to the Greeks and featuring Cyrano de Bergerac, prior to the invention of balloons. The importance of the actual invention of the first balloons by Joseph and Etienne Montgolfier is downplayed in favour of their choice of a public demonstration at home in Annonay. Thereafter we have a brief mention of the development of a hydrogen balloon by Charles and no account of the first flights in Paris. Instead, Lynn emphasizes the rapid spread of balloon flights across France and Europe. He gives a census of flights in Lyon, Dijon, Marseille and ‘countless other cities in France’ (p. 15) with one or two sentences devoted to each, and touches on launches in Piedmont, Spain, Italy, Britain, the Austrian Netherlands (he says Spanish), Holland and Russia. There follows a section on deaths and disasters, and on how the invention of parachuting recaptured the flagging imagination of the public.
The chapter on the Enlightenment features the pre-eminence of the issue of the utility of balloons. A few uses were found or suggested. Tethered balloons might be valuable for artillery observation. They might also permit scientific experiments and observations of the properties of the atmosphere at various altitudes. But these uses of tethered balloons were limited. Free balloons might have commercial value by taking advantage of prevailing wind direction. But the question of utility boiled down to finding a method of directing and steering them. All sorts of devices were imagined, among them paddle wheels, oars, and a sort of jellyfish effect to be achieved by alternately deflating and inflating slightly. Nothing worked, and balloonists resigned themselves to providing mere entertainment.
The next chapter considers the social composition of balloonists and their audience. The number of women involved both as balloonists and as members of the audience offers insight into ‘the gendered side of scientific practice’ (p. 60). The Infante Dom Gabriel (he says ‘infant’ (p. 61)) sponsored the first attempted flight in Spain. Unfortunately the balloon caught fire immediately after take-off. No matter what their origins, balloonists were ‘the pop stars of their day’ (p. 64). The behaviour of the audience varied greatly. Peasants were terrified and attacked the balloon when it came down. Monarchs and aristocrats viewed the flights at the outset in Paris. Often the crowds outside the fenced-off area for ticket-holders were unruly. Failed launches met with great hostility from would-be viewers.
All of the above problems led national and local governments to attempt some control over the flights that occurred over their territories. Occasionally balloons took part in a festival. The crowning of Napoleon featured a highly decorated balloon soaring overhead. The Congress of Vienna was celebrated with a balloon. On the other hand, balloons sometimes carried satirical messages. Their effectiveness for the military was problematic, but Napoleon took along a balloon company to Egypt – where, however, the chief value was overawing the population of Cairo. The danger of riots led some local authorities to ban flights altogether and others to require licenses. Nevertheless, the great majority of flights, major or lesser, escaped control altogether.
The economics of ballooning consisted of the sale of tickets to watch the flights and of the sale of decorative paraphernalia of all sorts. Over time, thousands of people bought admission to the launches, but that may have been dwarfed by the market for balloons themselves, small or large, of prints, of clothing, even of furniture. The popularity went beyond that, and inspired poems and literary conceits. The young Shelley wrote a sonnet to a balloon, and Erasmus Darwin mourned the death of Pilâtre de Rozière in a fiery embrace.
This book consists of a very large number of factual sentences. Brief summaries appear at the end of each chapter. The generalizations are postponed to a conclusion. They are largely wide of the mark, however. For example, Lynn states that a ‘full understanding of the importance of science during the age of Enlightenment and Atlantic revolutions requires an explanation of how and why ballooning entered and stayed in the public consciousness’ (p. 3). Ballooning, the publisher's synopsis on the back cover asserts, was ‘at the birth of large-scale mass consumption of science’. As a historian of science, I have to say that ballooning had precious little to do with science, and I do not know what ‘mass consumption of science’ means. All in all, the multiplication of instances, which is what the book consists of, does not establish that ballooning entered deeply into the culture of the forty years covered by Lynn. I think it remained an entertainment overhead, as indeed does his account.
