I read with no little degree of amazement Judith Tucker's celebration and partial reprint of Vahakn N. Dadrian's “ground-breaking” (p. 171) 1986 article about the Naim-Andonian documents supposedly proving the Armenian genocide. Tucker makes no mention that at the time Dadrian originally published his article, I immediately questioned the validity of the documents (IJMES 19 [1987]: 523–24). They are riddled with internal inconsistencies, and the originals have long since conveniently disappeared.
I am not alone in this position, and for the sake of its own scholarly reputation IJMES should at least recognize this. Although Dadrian had the audacity to argue incongruously that “the presence and easy detection of such defects in the material under review militate against that charge [of forgery]” (p. 176), common sense would seem to argue the opposite. The manifest inconsistencies in the Naim-Andonian documents indicate that they are likely forgeries. Indeed, in all fairness to the Armenian position in the hoary controversy over whether the Ottomans intended to commit genocide against them, one would think that the Armenians and their supporters could come up with a better smoking pistol.
IJMES certainly could reprint a more substantial piece of scholarship than Dadrian's partisan contentions attempting to validate highly questionable documents that do no credit to the Armenian cause.
