El Salvador's 1992 Peace Accords, terminating a costly 12-year armed conflict, gave rise to an electoral democracy. While the country has made undeniable strides, the causes of the war persist and crime, often committed by street gangs, has soared to unprecedented levels. Grappling with the paradox of a violent peace, Ellen Moodie's first book examines crime narratives circulating in early post-war San Salvador. The volume is based on extensive fieldwork, including archival research and dozens of interviews with urban Salvadoreans of diverse backgrounds and perspectives. Whilst drawing on cultural, critical and political theory, the text is enlivened with personal anecdotes that help the reader to visualise the local socio-political and human rights situation. The book's premise is that crime stories shaped the way that people experienced their encounters with violence and reoriented them to different ways of interacting in the post-revolutionary setting. The study recaps the historical background, analyses official and informal crime discourses, explores the assignation of criminality, and reflects on the possibilities for democracy in El Salvador. The volume provides a window onto three issues: perceptions of violence (and their management); responses to violence; and the meanings of democracy in a violent context.
People's crime stories – tales of muggings, kidnappings, robberies and fears of rape – reflect a shared anxiety about mounting violence and its seemingly novel manifestations. To elucidate the nature of these accounts Moodie introduces two concepts, ‘critical code-switching’ and ‘unknowing’, both of which aided the powerful in resignifying post-war delinquency.
‘Critical code-switching’ refers to a taxonomic transition whereby violent acts were depicted as random and divorced from structural factors. The 1993 murder of an ex-rebel leader exemplifies how the government argued that the era of state terror, and therefore of collective resistance, had ended and given way to common crime and private responsibility for risk management. This portrayal of violence as not political but pathological was essential to sustaining El Salvador's image of democratic success. Moodie suitably points out how public insecurity is augmented by morbid media coverage of the daily atrocities, although the implications of these spectacles of death are left unprobed. Instead, the focus rests on how people began to idealise the past, retrospectively imagining it to have been a time of more predictable danger and hence greater safety. By showing how the storytellers came to feel that they had been better off in an authoritarian society, the analysis reveals how memory can become a tool of the ruling class.
‘Unknowing’ denotes forgetting or converting something known into something circumstantially unknown. Specifically, awareness of the inequality–crime nexus is replaced by the idea that delinquency is rooted in individual deviance. Echoing the framing of violence by the government and the media, Salvadoreans' crime stories position criminal agency into the racialised bodies of marginalised young men, particularly the gang members they perceive as a distinctly post-war phenomenon. In examining the operation of unknowing, the author not only offers a fascinating account of the construction of the criminal, but also demonstrates that throughout El Salvador's history individuals who posed a challenge to the established order were unknown and repressed: if not in La Matanza, a violent reprisal for an indigenous uprising in 1932, then in the civil war or the more recent crackdown on gangs.
By Moodie's own admission, gangs play only a limited part in crime. Yet, contrary to her avowed reluctance to focus on these quasi-symbols of crime, she felt compelled to devote a whole chapter to the phenomenon. Comparatively little thought is given to non-gang offenders, especially police or influential politicians and businessmen. Moreover, the research could have underscored that delinquency affects mostly poorer Salvadoreans, and that Alianza Republicana Nacionalista (Nationalist Republican Alliance, ARENA) administrations therefore lacked an incentive to act on it. Similarly, it might have been illuminating to know how residents in rural areas or drug-trafficking hotspots make sense of violence. More generally, while people's perceptions are worthy of study, it is also vital to establish why El Salvador suffers so much violence and who commits it. Although Moodie alludes to the crime spike's coincidence with democratisation and structural adjustment, the analysis glosses over the factors for violence.
The worsening of violence has occurred in the context of neoliberal economic programmes that were faithfully implemented by successive ARENA governments. According to Moodie, these policies also manufacture neoliberal citizens tasked with managing their risk of crime, for example by living in securitised enclaves or when mingling in pseudo-public spaces such as shopping centres. Unsurprisingly, widespread insecurity has fed public demand for punitive measures, typically tougher laws and militarised policing. However, a conservative interest in chronic insecurity and hence calls for authoritarian solutions are insufficiently explored. To be sure, Moodie notes that media and government anti-crime discourses shape citizens' perceptions and that these discourses, as well as the hard-line measures they invite, threaten a fledgling democracy. Yet she does not delve into the reasons for such manoeuvring, especially the fact that certain sectors of society benefit politically and economically from insecurity.
Salvadoreans' crime narratives also relay their encounters with democracy. Whereas the elite had favoured electoral freedom and investment opportunities, the stories indicate that ordinary people had three aspirations: the rule of law and responsive institutions; a sense of community; and socio-economic development. Given ongoing violence and limited opportunities, the initial euphoria soon gave way to disillusionment. The gulf between these expectations remains significant for understanding the limitations of El Salvador's democracy. Strikingly, the crime narratives contain no references to ARENA. It is puzzling that the interviewees would have critiqued the state for its failure to ensure citizens' well-being, but not the party that governed the country for two decades and is thus responsible for many of its current ills. Finally, the research inevitably touches on the impact of high levels of crime on democracy. The author cites a 1995 survey revealing a widespread perception that human rights favour offenders and therefore impede crime control. More recent polls, which were not included in the study, would have mirrored this finding. But while nostalgia for authoritarianism is unsurprising in a country with no democratic legacy, the question of how much violence and exclusion a democracy can endure is not pursued here. Moodie seems to think that El Salvador is firmly planted on the path of democratic consolidation, because the place exudes hope. Rather than optimism, however, we may be seeing a desire for survival in which democracy may eventually be cast overboard unless it affords people more security, education and jobs.
Overall, El Salvador in the Aftermath of Peace is a fascinating and engagingly written work that wrestles with one of the key issues affecting this Central American nation. While the book is not for those who hope to find out more about the contemporary configuration of crime in El Salvador, it will appeal to readers with an interest in the lived experiences, dreams and fears of ordinary people in uncertain times. Veteran Central America watchers and students of post-conflict settings elsewhere in the world will surely find much food for thought in this volume. The political dimension of crime, not necessarily an anthropologist's chief concern, could have been tackled more decisively, particularly the question of why delinquency was left to fester when El Salvador initiated its experiment with democracy. Moodie's study returns the spotlight to a place that the international community had learned to ignore. Above all, it shows that small countries matter not only at times of crisis and can provide important lessons for other places.
