Uriel Abulof's The Mortality and Morality of Nations is a highly innovative contribution to the study of nationalism, focusing on what the novelist Milan Kundera has called “small nations.” Defined independently of their size, such nations are haunted by a deep-seated fear of their own disappearance; their identities seem to be essentially questionable, “for their very existence is the question” (vii). While larger nations find a source of legitimacy in the meaning they can give to the mortality of their members, creating a link between the “question” of individual death and the “answer” given by an eternal nation (as famously suggested by the late Benedict Anderson), “small nations” fail to deliver such a sense of belonging. What happens if one's supposed source of self-assurance is marked by existential doubt? Through an unusual combination of existentialist philosophy with three empirical case-studies – French Canadians, Zionism, and white South African Afrikaners—Abulof has written a stimulating book, which moves the focus to the margins of nationalism and probes its most fragile expressions. He demonstrates the role of “existential threats” for the discursive self-legitimation of small nations, tracing the “existential threads” (15) their members weave against the abyss of disappearance. Their political languages could thereby function as a “‘magnifying glass’ onto the mortality and morality” of all nations (8) and point to their constitutive uncertainties.
Cross-pollinating comparative analyses with theoretical meditations, Abulof engages in Weberian understanding (Verstehen), immersing himself in the public debates of small nations. For Abulof, French Canadians, Zionist Jews, and Afrikaners are cases of ethnonationalism; they construct an “identity-polity complex” in which “ethnic identity and national polity are closely intertwined” (34). But while their identities might be conceptualized as “imagined kinship” (6), he brings to light the uncertainties of their self-understandings. Abulof's opening theoretical chapter explores the links between narratives on collective threats and the discursive construction of national moralities, that is, their “languages of legitimation” (18). According to Abulof, shifting “degrees of freedom” (3) affect the small nations’ strategies of self-legitimation, their national “causae-sui” (22–28). With great erudition and an unusual sense of literary style, he substantiates his claims by way of qualitative discourse-tracing and quantitative findings.
The second chapter follows the evolution of French colonists in North America to Canadiens, then to French Canadians, before arriving at today's Québécois. At each step of the way, Abulof pays keen attention to the existential framing within their discourse of survivance: the specter of collective disappearance, which motivated changes from an ethnic imaginary, to a Catholic “ethno-religionism” (88), and finally to a postethnic, linguistic patriotism at ease with multiple and overlapping group identities in a Canadian state. The third chapter on Zionism provides an overview of Zionism's history before and since the founding of Israel, making palpable the frontlines within Jewish identity as a multivocal narrative, articulated against the backdrop of an ever-looming threat of destruction. Abulof gives credence to his claims regarding the evolution of the Zionist causa-sui by integrating quantitative data. He effectively cites opinion polls and charts the frequency of words through corpus linguistics of Israeli news sources, analyzing their mediatic discourse framing. In the last and perhaps most provocative chapter, he turns to the Afrikaner case, similarly confronting a history of self-doubt and conflict within their allegedly stable sense of ethnic belonging. While the author rejects a direct comparison between South African apartheid and the Israeli treatment of Palestinians, the study nevertheless points to important similarities between the two cases—not so much on the level of practice (a subject on which the author remains cautiously silent), but within Afrikaner and Zionist discourses, both marked by an abysmal dimension of uncertainty.
Abulof owes an intellectual debt to the work of Ernest Becker, who in his treatise The Denial of Death (Free Press, 1973) theorized human meaning production (“causae-sui”) as a response to the terror of mortality. Yet Becker's psychological perspective hardly squares with the existentialism of Sartre and Camus which Abulof also endorses. Throughout the book, he makes an important distinction between what he calls “epistemic” and “ontological” insecurities. While epistemic insecurity refers to the “survival of a people and their polity,” ontological insecurity points to the past and the collective's sense of selfhood, answering to the question “Who am I?” (34). But if one distinguishes between the epistemic survival of people and polity on the one hand, and the ontological survival of an identity on the other, the price must be the essentialization of an ethnie as preexisting the construction of its own identity. The distinction between epistemic and ontological insecurities makes it seem as if small nations were transhistorically existing subjects: ready-made ethnies which experience threats and respond to them. This maneuver entails the naturalization of an ethnonationalist imaginary, turning discourses into willful choices; what is lost is precisely the political existentialism which Abulof hoped to defend. The problem extends to yet another level, as the distinction between “epistemic” and “ontological” selfhood gets transposed onto the collective “selves” of nations, by way of a charged body metaphor: “the body is the corporeal locus of individual identity, the polity that of the collective's identity. Here, the ‘I-We’ amalgam is embodied in the ‘body politics of the community’” (41). But is the survival of human bodies really the same as that of nation-states? Owing to an undertheorized merging of psychology (and even sociobiology) with existentialism, Abulof risks duplicating ethnonationalist assumptions on the conceptual level.
These slippages have far-reaching repercussions. What Abulof euphemistically calls a nation's “significant other” (31, 64) might more aptly be referred to as its constitutive outside: not only the British, on which he oddly focuses much of the argument, but the colonized natives, since all three of his “small nations” also happen to be cases of settler colonialism. While he explicitly argues that Palestine could also be a case of a “small nation” (39), pointing to a fruitful extension of his theory, Palestinian agency gets largely erased in his account. Similarly, the aboriginal peoples of Quebec hardly receive any mention at all, whereas the end of apartheid in South Africa is portrayed as a free choice on the part of Afrikaners (227), enabled by a moderate ANC who no longer posed a threat to their survival (303). With a focus on deliberation and narrative, Abulof glosses over power relations in the construction of hegemonic discourses, while subsuming the small nations’ “significant others” under the objectifying rubric of “epistemic threats,” be it to their sovereignty or physical survival. Yet is there not an important difference between a fragile group threatened by disappearance, and a colonial state which is haunted by the prospect of its overthrow? In the absence of such nuance, Abulof's account seems to resemble a disavowed Schmittianism, for which a sovereign people is posed against an existential enemy.
Perhaps these philosophical uncertainties are themselves part of Abulof's own, self-searching endeavor. With The Mortality and Morality of Nations, he manages to unsettle received truths on ethnonationalism, never shying away from comparisons that are as insightful as they are provocative. This is a timely book and an illuminating journey into the troubled world of ethnonationalists.
