In Mexico, as population growth rapidly expanded during the last half of the twentieth century, pollution-intensive industrialisation and the expansion of agricultural land increasingly strained the country's rich natural resources. Several critical environmental problems affect today's Mexico: dense urban smog, atrocious water conditions, improper handling of toxic and domestic waste, extensive soil erosion and illicit logging count among the most conspicuous examples. Government policies have long favoured agricultural production and colonisation into so-called ‘marginal’ areas for decades, triggering extensive biodiversity and watershed value losses.Yet surprisingly few authors have examined the historical context and changes of Mexican environmental policy, making Jordi Díez's book Political Change and Environmental Policymaking in Mexico a welcome addition.
Díez has put extensive effort into reformatting his doctoral dissertation into a well-organised and insightful book on environmental politics in Mexico. The novelty of Díez's work lies in its analysis of Mexican environmental policymaking through the overlapping lenses of political science, political ecology, environmental protection and forest management. In seven well-ordered chapters, Díez takes the reader from a brief historical background on political change and the burgeoning environmental movement in Mexico to more specific environmental policy along with their drivers and consequences, especially institutional responses (or lack thereof) to deforestation.
After briefly discussing how Mexico's political landscape unfolded during the twentieth century, dominated by the Partido Revolucionario Institucional (PRI) party, Díez spends considerable space on Mexico's environmental movement, the environmental agenda during the Ernesto Zedillo (1994–2000) administration and environmental policy making, including the role of Mexico's Congress. Together, these initial chapters provide an appealing look at several environmental ‘movers and shakers’ and their key policy decisions made at the national level. It is shown that the mainstream environmental movement, with the exception of the ineffectual Green Party, had an influential role to play in the focus and setting of environmental policy. Environmental reforms championed by the first Minister of Environment, Julia Carabias (and later by Victor Lichtinger), led to increased participation and pluralism by a broad sector of civil society. Díez also illustrates how, even though they were constrained by deficient financial and technical resources and excluded from drafting specific environmental laws, Mexico's environmental policy legislators experienced increased power and influence during the Zedillo years.
The final two chapters are dedicated to deforestation and forestry policy in Mexico's largest rain forest, the Selva Lacandona of the state of Chiapas. Díez does an excellent job here of describing how powerful social actors – big business, the military and the landed élite – have worked to influence or even sabotage environmental policy, increasing deforestation along the way. His astute analogy of the principle of la ley se acata pero no se cumple (the law must be obeyed but not complied with) overrides these two chapters. Socio-economic exclusion, corruption and caciquismo, lawlessness, ineffectual forest monitoring, inadequate institutional capacity, and many other pressures or limitations have all contributed to continued deforestation in Chiapas, a state in which the positive policy implications that occurred at the national level have mostly bypassed. Lastly, Díez provides a very revealing Epilogue and Conclusion, providing the reader with an update of the ‘current’ situation up to near the end of Vicente Fox's presidency (2000–06).
A few criticisms must be noted. While Díez does a good job of discussing the forestry law reforms of the Zedillo administration (1994–2000), he ignores other significant reforms. For example, the forestry laws of 1926, 1943, 1948 and 1960 were all quite ambitious, requiring permits and documentation for logging, transporting forest products, or any change in forest land use. The greatest omission, however, has to be the 1986 forest law reform that ended private concessions and parastatals, returning control of most of Mexico's forests to indigenous communities and ejidos. This groundbreaking reform recognised the right of communities to form their own logging businesses and introduced more systematic environmental regulation for the forestry sector, sowing the seeds for (arguably) democratic forest management. Díez should have provided at least a few sentences on the 1986 forestry law reform on pp. 41–2, as well as acknowledged the implications for this important shift in forest management control.
Some would also argue that the integrity of rural communities and the preservation of local environments in Mexico would be facilitated by active local participation in economic and environmental policymaking and planning. At times, Díez seems to be headed toward this conclusion but never quite gets there, nor does he provide practical recommendations in the Conclusion for needed improvements. Perhaps an additional chapter on the positive effects of community-based forestry policy in Mexico, especially in neighbouring Oaxaca and Guerrero, would have provided some lessons learned for forestry and environmental legislators against the more negative example of Chiapas. More could have been written too on the issue of social justice around environmental decision-making. Finally, the interesting final chapters could have been expanded on and more interview data incorporated into the analysis. Díez also weakens his own argument that environmental policy is weak in the state by admitting that Chiapas could be an ‘outlier’ or extreme case (p. 146).
The book is well-referenced, although a few additional key works could have been cited or referenced in the text. Given the relevance of this book to the subfield of political ecology, I found it peculiar that the views of certain renowned Mexican scholars on this and related themes were notably absent: to name a few, Enrique Leff, Héctor Díaz Polanco and Víctor Toledo. Additional works could have been cited on how forest-specific policy has made some significant positive changes in other parts of Mexico. While Díez reports that five per cent of Mexicans belonged to an environmental nongovernmental organisation by the mid-1990s (p. 33), it would have been useful to know how this compares to Canada or the United States. In addition, several sloppy spelling and grammatical errors detract from important points. For instance, the government forestry firm COFOLASA is called ‘CFOLASA’ on p. 122 and ‘environmentalist’ should be pluralised on pp. 32 and 37. The environmental non-governmental organisation, (ENGO) Mexican Ecologist Movement, should have been added to the examples provided in Table 2.1 on p. 35, particularly since the author admits it plays a different role than Greenpeace in Mexico.
These deficiencies aside, Díez's book certainly adds significantly to the analysis of environmental policy in Mexico. It is worthy reading for serious researchers on this theme, and would be useful for mid- and upper-level university courses dealing with Latin American environmental policy.
