A persisting common assumption about colonial and postcolonial cities is that they are essentially an elaboration of the disseminated European urban principles, models, and techniques imposed by foreign experts and ideas on silent, oppressed, indigenous population. More recently, scholars have begun to challenge the narrowness of this vision and probe issues of resistance, responses, adaptations, modifications, hybridization, or domestications of these foreign city-building concepts. Urbanism Imported or Exported? falls into this intellectual trajectory. Like other books on this discourse—and I have in mind a long haul that runs from Robert Ross and Gerard Telkamp's edited volume Colonial Cities (1984) to Vikramaditya Prakash's Chandigarah's Le Corbusier (2002)—the wider critical purchase of this volume lies in its intended focus on the local, individual narratives and personal stories of how urban patterns, spaces, functions, and strategies are generated through local agents interacting with foreign experts. By focusing on the microlevel, the book avoids the pitfall of essentializing and generalizing monolithic categories, including the category of the local. However, what distinguishes this volume and gives it its strength is the way it places the colonial urban experience among several other noncolonial experiences that bear some parallels. In broadening the scope of urban colonialism to include cases from the First World, the book shifts conventional framings of colonial and postcolonial urban transformations and puts new light on the complex web of interactions through which the diffusion of modern urban ideas has occurred. Owing much to a growing field concerned with the cross-influences and international diffusion of ideas, and I here think of Stephen Ward's Planning the Twentieth Century City (2002), this new perspective allows readers to delineate refractions, echoes, and parallels among the various stories it narrates.
Edited by two talented researchers, and composed of an introductory chapter by Anthony King, an established authority on the subject, and twelve essays by an international cast of contributors from various backgrounds, the book raises important questions and sheds light on a variety of methodological and theoretical issues. For example, Nasr and Volait ponder in their introduction the methodological challenges facing researchers seeking local voices. They ask questions such as what constitutes the local? Where is evidence of local contributions to be uncovered? These questions and more continue in Anthony King's introductory chapter, in which he comments incisively on the importance of recognizing the positionalities of the researchers and expresses his indignation with the limitations of macrotheories in understanding what he calls “transnational spaces.” The editors are to be commended for organizing the variegated themes tackled by the book's essayists into four fairly coherent sections on “the latest models,” “city-building, state-building, and nation-building,” “powerful subjects,” and “foreign experts, local professionals.” With the exception of the chapter by Ray Bromley, which somewhat loosely fits with the common threads of this book, most contributors illustrate, with varying degrees of success, how urban transformations involve very dynamic processes, subject to constant changes and adaptations, dependent on power relationships specific to every case. Unlike most of the other chapters, however, Stephen Ward's essay on the influence the United States has exerted on Western urban planning, although an interesting read and coalescing with the dominant theme of the volume, examines the subject without the benefit of a particular case study.
The diverse themes and problematics covered in this volume include the following:
- selective borrowing was a common utility resorted to by local actors in introducing foreign urban planning ideas, such as the appropriation of the Garden City principles in Egypt and Japan;
- imported Western concepts of urbanism were used politically either as a way to consolidate power or as a method to achieve political independence;
- there are limitations to the potentials of imported ideas, particularly when they encounter local economic conditions, driven, for example, by the profit of purely speculative attitudes, such as in the city of planning Thessaloniki and the Etoile project in Beirut;
- foreign involvement may intriguingly impose local and not foreign architectural and urban solutions, as in the case of socialist realism movement in East Berlin;
- the local elites' internalization of foreign culture, image of locals, and urban sensibilities may continue after foreign experts are gone;
- the importation of a model had more chances of successful realization when the new concepts were superimposed on an existing network of local power configurations;
- the role of foreign experts and their capacity of intervention change over time due to a gradual knowledge development of local professionals; and
- personal, educational, and professional ties acted as determinant channels in the process of diffusing urban planning ideas. Perhaps the book could have benefited from slightly more scope had it expanded the ways in which the experience of foreign experts influenced their later works and theories.
Contributors to this volume rely mainly on original sources and demonstrate sound scholarship. Collectively, they make a positive contribution on the various modes of diffusing modern urban-planning ideas by opening up a vibrant intellectual space in which other researchers may start to explore more intricate stories. I warmly recommend this book to students of colonial and postcolonial studies, geographers, and historians concerned with the manners in which ideas are diffused and disseminated. Indeed, those interested in urbanism and the history of urban planning during the past two centuries will definitely find this scholarly collection of great interest.
