This compendium on ‘the paradigmatic “Roman” character-value’ (3) fides as it is deployed in Flavian literature unites papers from a conference at Radboud University (2015) and an eponymous SCS panel (2016). The volume contains a joint introduction by the three editors, twelve chapters by established Flavian scholars that contain generous quotations of the primary literature and are divided into four main sections on important contexts for Flavian fides (chs 2–4 on politics, chs 5–8 on myth, chs 9–12 on history and ch. 13 on literary reception), a comprehensive bibliography, an index locorum and a selective general index.
The introduction offers a helpful survey of the wide semantic range of interpretations of fides (including notions such as good faith, loyalty, trust and fidelity) and its evolution from the Republic to the Flavian Dynasty with its various re-conceptualisations in literary and material sources (chs 3–9), as well as a detailed summary of the chapters that follow (chs 9–14). It does not provide a systematic literature review, only briefly citing the most influential studies on fides and pietas without assessing the different theories and definitions, nor does it establish a common theoretical framework and terminology for the volume as a whole.
Although the majority of contributions concentrate on the representation of fides in Flavian epic, a few essays deviate from this focus. Claire Stocks presents an ambitious diachronic study of both the personified Fides and clasped-right-hands motifs on Julio-Claudian coinage and the ‘cry of perfidy’, a case study in the violation of ‘a bond that would have been sworn by the right hand’ (23), in Augustan and Flavian poetry. She concludes that ‘in an attempt to unite the people (Fides Publica) and the army (Fides Exercituum) […] the Flavians made fides an imperial virtue for the first time’ (8) to consolidate their power after a.d. 69 ‘by anchoring it to an Augustan past’ (22), but discontinued the representations of Fides on coins in a.d. 89 because ‘the imperial image machine no longer needed to display clasped hands as a response to civil strife’ (36). S. identifies a similar transition of the epic-elegiac accusation of perfidy from the domestic sphere under Augustus to the public sphere under the Flavians with a near absence of the personified Fides in Flavian poetry, except Silius’ Punica. The use of elegiac motifs and the tension between public and private fides are also at the core of Neil Bernstein's analysis of domestic loyalty in Statius’ Silvae. Lauren Donovan Ginsberg and Emma Buckley discuss the Ps.-Senecan historical drama Octavia, which, as they both cogently show, adopts strategies that are typical for the Flavian discourse of fides. While Buckley analyses the critical depiction of Nero's destructive perfidia towards his family and citizens through the lens of Seneca's De Clementia, Ginsberg examines the elegiac stock characters and themes employed in the characterisation of imperial women as stereotypical embodiments of faithlessness. Steve Mason explicitly addresses and emphatically justifies the inclusion of Flavius Josephus’ Bellum Judaicum, the only Greek and one of two prose works, in this collection. Neither Ginsberg nor Mason focus on the terminology of fides or its Greek equivalent πίστις; they take a much broader and unfortunately at times also terminologically ambiguous approach to the concept of imperial (dis)loyalty. In the sole contribution in the final section on literary reception, Salvador Bartera offers a qualitative and quantitative linguistic analysis of Tacitus’ deployment of fides, esp. fides militaris, its cognates and antonyms in his account of the rise of the Flavians and the civil conflict of a.d. 69 in Histories 1–3. He juxtaposes Tacitus’ circumspect portrayal of the Flavians as restorers of the traditional fides with his critical description of fides’ gradual deterioration from Galba to Otho until it is eventually replaced by perfidia under Vitellius.
Many shared loci, motifs and narrative patterns create important contingencies between individual chapters across the four-part division. Several essays discuss the impossibility of dissociating private from public loyalty and highlight the dangerous potential of imperial women and the replacement of fides publica with personal loyalty. Bernstein persuasively shows that fides in Statius’ Silvae is idealised as ‘a bureaucratic virtue that reinforces the structures of imperial domination’ (70) and is not associated with equal partners, but is predominantly described as obedience and servitude by a loyal subordinate. Alison Keith analogously determines that a strict differentiation between public fides outside family bonds and private pietas between family members cannot be sustained for the Thebaid. Her comparison of the sisters-in-law Antigone and Argia as embodiments of exemplary familial and spousal fidelity and Eriphyle as ‘the lone faithless wife’ (130) forcefully demonstrates that, irrespective of the women's intentions towards their male counterparts, the outcome of their actions is equally catastrophic in the cynical world of Statius’ Thebaid. Both Ginsberg and B. on the Octavia likewise conclude that spousal perfidy can have severe public repercussions and are a reflection of a ‘broader breakdown in the political structure of Julio-Claudian Rome’ (209).
Dániel Kozák, Raymond Marks and Marco Fucecchi all stress the natural interconnectedness of pietas and fides in their convincing examinations of the divergent interpretations as well as the permutation or dissolution of these virtues in (civil) war contexts. They examine different portrayals of ethnic stereotypes of perfidy and identify a ‘problematization’ of this biased ‘polarization’ (187) in Flavian epic which acknowledges that just as an opponent's faithlessness can inspire greater loyalty in one's own ranks, exemplary fides can be defined in different ways and can quickly turn into the epitome of perfidiousness with a change of perspective, e.g. from the Roman to the ‘Barcid interpretation’ (189).
Helen Lovatt, Antony Augoustakis and Dániel Kozák examine the manipulation of fides, especially in its deployment as a rhetorical tool in interpersonal relationships of Valerius’ Argonautica, Statius’ Thebaid, and the Achilleid respectively. They conclude that fides gradually loses its traditional meaning and that mortal characters in particular tend to (ab)use promises and requests of faith as a rhetorical strategy to influence their interlocutors and achieve their aims. Lovatt moreover argues that Valerius’ pervasive use of the nec-vana-fides motif and metaliterary play on fides are intended to draw attention to ‘the treacherous uncertainty of both gods and storytelling’ (89) and ‘reflect on his own adaptation and manipulation of the Argonautic myth, and particularly his relationship with Virgil and Apollonius’ (103). Mason, in his argument for a more differentiated assessment of the Bellum Judaicum, similarly attributes Flavius Josephus’ strategic characterisation of Vespasian's and Titus’ (dis)loyalty as well as his digression from the Flavians’ preferred chronology and themes to the author's intention to showcase his own achievements as the adversary and protagonist of the Judaean War.
The volume benefits from the flexible structure and diverse approaches of its contributions. An unusual feature is the tendency to introduce new ideas, especially about the political implications of the essay's findings for Flavian Rome, at the very end of several essays. This sometimes seems forced, but does produce some stimulating discussions, notably Bernstein's comparison of the portrayal of fides in Statius’ Silvae with Claudian's panegyrics and Kozák's proposal to read the end of Statius’ Achilleid as a correction of Achilles’ declaration in Iliad 1 that he joined the Greek expedition out of loyalty. The editing of the volume is not entirely consistent: several typos and inconsistencies remain. Overall, however, the volume, constitutes another welcome addition to the continued resurgence of new companions on Flavian literature.
