Eric Drustler's Renegade Women is a masterfully composed collection of microhistories that focus on Ottoman and Venetian women who transgressed imperial, geographical, and confessional borders during a period of political stability between the Ottoman and Venetian empires, from the late 16th century until the outbreak of the Candian war in 1645. In early modern Mediterranean vocabulary, the signifier “renegade” denoted a Christian (man or woman) who “rebelled against the faith” and abandoned Christianity to embrace Islam. In Renegade Women, however, Dursteler redefines and expands the semantic field of the term “renegade” to include not only Christian women who converted to Islam but also all women who transgressed gender, social, political, and religious boundaries, and “in any geographical, ideological, or theological direction” (p. ix).
Dursteler makes the Mediterranean a prominent character in each of the collection's tales. In conceptualizing the Mediterranean as “a channel of division, a corridor of an escape, and a means of connection” (p. x), Dursteler provides his female protagonists with a topos that is conducive to interconnectivity and delineation, stability and transformation. Dursteler's casting of the Mediterranean as “an arena of interactions, of encounters and exchanges” (p. 108), creates the necessary backdrop to the tales of reconfiguration of the boundaries of religious identities and territorial belongings, which, as Dursteler convincingly argues, were fragmented, fuzzy, and open to contextual recreation and reimagination.
The tales of Renegade Women are presented across three chapters, followed by a conclusion in which the author recapitulates and further substantiates some of the book's arguments. In the first chapter, Dursteler tells the story of Beatrice Michiel of Venice who was living in an unhappy marriage with her second husband, a merchant without citizenship named Zuane Zaghis. With little possibility to obtain a divorce in Venice, Beatrice left her husband and three children to relocate to Istanbul. There, she joined her renegade brother who had forged a successful career in the inner service of the imperial palace as Head of the Privy Chamber (has oda başı) and Chief of the White Eunuchs (kapı ağası). Shortly after her arrival to Istanbul, Beatrice embraced Islam and adopted the name of the Prophet's daughter, Fatima. Due to her brother's high-ranking status in the imperial palace, Beatrice/Fatima was able to secure an official divorce from her non-Muslim husband and to ensure exclusive control over the property in Venice. She married an Ottoman official and gained remarkable power and influence in the imperial palace, where she was able to emerge as one of the most important supporters of the interests of her patria, Venice.
Dursteler's meticulous account of Beatrice/Fatima's complicated history offers an important insight into the ways in which transgressions of imperial and religious boundaries in the early modern Mediterranean could provide women of high social status with opportunities to rearrange their gender and social identities and to thereby acquire new forms of female agency and power. Perhaps even more significant is the author's ability to use Beatrice/Fatima's life history as a telling example of complex and multidirectional processes of identity-formation in the early modern Mediterranean. In providing ample evidence of Beatrice/Fatima's fractured religious, social, and cultural identities, Dursteler presents a convincing argument that some converts did not experience “a clear, new religious identity,” but rather “ambivalence and tension” (p. 115), as they contextually renegotiated the boundaries between their new faith and the old one, and between self and other.
The second chapter of Renegade Women focuses on two tales set in the Ottoman-Venetian contact zone of Dalmatia, where “the Ottoman and Venetian empires adjoined most directly” (p. 36). The tales center on Elena Cavalelli, a Christian girl from the Venetian coastal town of Zara (Zadar), and Mihale Šatorović, a Muslim girl from the Ottoman-controlled town of Clissa (Klis), whose lives took a dramatic turn after they rejected the marriage plans concocted by their fathers. Elena resisted conversion to Islam, the religion of her renegade parents, instead choosing to spend her life in a convent. Mihale, for her part, defied her father's authority by abandoning her family home, fleeing into Venetian lands, and converting to Christianity. With the help of Venetian officials, both Elena and Mihale were placed in the Casa delle Zitelle, “Venice's preferred refuge for endangered girls from the Venetian-Ottoman frontier” (p. 70). From there, the girls navigated through webs of familial, institutional, and imperial relations until they shaped their lives according to their wishes. Elena took her vows and adopted the name of Suor Deodata, while the renegade Mihale took the Christian name of Catterina and remained in Venice where she eventually married a Venetian man of her choosing.
In revealing Elena/Suor Deodata and Mihale/Catterina Šatorović's complex histories, Dursteler presents compelling evidence that young, unmarried Muslim and Christian women from the Ottoman-Venetian frontier zones could use existing institutional and imperial structures in order to recast their gender, social, and religious identities. Significantly, while Elena and Mihale's female agency was circumvented by cultural attitudes of the patriarchal Venetian society that allowed “endangered girls” limited choices of action, they were nonetheless able to manipulate those options and take control over the destiny of their bodies, their faith, and ultimately, the course of their lives.
Renegade Women's last tale presents another excellent example of how imperial geography, religion, and female agency converged in the early modern Mediterranean. Set on the Ottoman-controlled Aegean island of Milos, the story focuses on Maria Gozzadini, an Orthodox widow of Hassan Ağa (a Muslim), and her three daughters Aissè, Eminè, and Catigè, who, in March of 1637, fled Milos and set on a journey through the “liquid landscape” of the Greek islands, and into Venetian territory. There, the four women forged new political, ideological, and religious allegiances and rearranged their lives under more favourable circumstances. The passage from Ottoman Milos to the Venetian island of Corfu allowed Maria to reinterpret her life on Milos as that of dissimulation, a secret adherence to Christian faith which she claimed to have also instilled in her daughters. Due to the paternalistic stance of the Venetian male-dominated political and religious institutions that considered women as weak and prone to conversion, Maria and her daughters succeeded in securing the official, institutional protection of their faith and female honor, in spite of the diplomatic scandal that ensued shortly after their flight from Milos. After closing the door to the possibility of a forced return to Milos, Maria and her daughters used their female agency to refashion their lives. Maria's daughter Aissè married a Christian man from Corfu, thereby renouncing her previous marriage to the Muslim judge of Milos, Mustafa Efendi. Her sister Eminè followed suit and married into one of the most prominent Corfiot families, while Maria and her daughter Catigè embraced the life of prayer and entered the island's monastery.
Eric Dursteler's Renegade Women makes a significant contribution to the burgeoning field of historical and cultural studies that emphasizes the instability and hybridity of the social, legal, and religious identities of the subjects who inhabited the Ottoman–Venetian frontier zones in the early modern eastern Mediterranean. In addition, the book's skillfully narrated histories of women who denounced and/or embraced conversion as a means of asserting their female agency and power make an important contribution to the history of Mediterranean women's lived experiences. By using a narrow body of archival sources as a lens through which to examine intersections between gender, agency, and socioreligious identity, Dursteler has produced an engaging study that will have a lasting impact upon students and scholars of the Mediterranean who use gender as an analytical category in their lines of inquiry.
