In his introduction to Reading Modern Drama, editor Alan Ackerman quotes a 1966 TDR article in which Richard Schechner remarked, “The literary model is passing away and it is being replaced by a performance model”; in reply, Ackerman suggests, “It is not clear that to have imagined such a vanquishing has been either correct or intellectually productive” (5). Ackerman also quotes Joseph Roach (one of the contributors to this volume), who in a 2010 issue of PMLA lamented that the “widening gap between performance studies and literary studies is the source of a number of missed opportunities” (4). Reading Modern Drama seeks to restore some of these missed opportunities and, in fact, to bring the two disciplines closer together, if not actually to unite them; each of the three words of its title—reading, modern, and drama—is closely interrogated.
Ackerman is not only the editor of Reading Modern Drama; he is also the editor of the academic journal Modern Drama, where all the essays in this volume were originally published under his editorship between 2005 and 2010. The title of the volume therefore takes on additional meaning: What does it mean to read the journal Modern Drama? If the chapters of Reading Modern Drama are allowed to answer that question, then the answer is: a great deal. The essays are eclectic in approach and methodology and uniformly superb. They are, as Ackerman notes, “loosely organized around a common theme: the relationship of dramatic language to its theatrical aspects” (3–4). The topics explored range from gossip as the invisible hand that shaped modernity and gave rise to an essentially new dramatic genre in the eighteenth century (where the author believes modern drama really has its beginnings) in Joseph Roach's fascinating “Gossip Girls: Lady Teazle, Nora Helmer, and Invisible-Hand Drama,” to Jane Harrison's pioneering role in the fashioning of attitudes that led ultimately to the rise of performance studies as an independent discipline in Julie Stone Peters's compelling “Jane Harrison and the Savage Dionysus: Archeological Voyages, Ritual Origins, Anthropology, and the Modern Theatre.” These essays are wide-ranging, intellectually stimulating, and never boring or pedantic.
In fact, it is rare to find in one volume so many essays that stimulate new ways of thinking about a number of modernist plays in relation to performance. While a prodigal amount of ink has been spent on playwrights such as Brecht and Beckett, two of the essays in Reading Modern Drama are among the best I've ever read on the two masters. R. Darren Gobert's chapter, “Cognitive Catharsis in The Caucasian Chalk Circle,” concentrates on Brecht's evolving, complex relationship to Aristotle, particularly Aristotle's notion of catharsis. With his intimate knowledge of Brecht's theoretical writing and intentions as a playwright and director—as well as with cognitive theorists and classicists like Martha Nussbaum—Gobert provides a rich elucidation of Brecht's evolving attitude toward emotion and the role it plays in the spectator. In “How to Do Nothing with Words, or Waiting for Godot as Performativity,” Richard Begam situates Beckett's canonical play within the “post-Nietzschean tradition according to which language is a series of metaphors designed to help us manage and control reality, as opposed to a series of descriptors designed to represent the essential nature or structure of reality” (111). While it might be true that “nothing” happens in Waiting for Godot, as Begam persuasively argues, the play is “obsessively concerned with the rhetoric of performativity” (120).
Beckett is the subject of another chapter in the book, “Reinventing Beckett.” But rather than concentrate on one play, as Begam does, S. E. Gontarski explores the difficulty of reinventing Beckett amid the Beckett estate's “untheatrical ideology of invariant texts” (137). He chronicles Beckett's own transition from writer to director, and persuasively argues that “Beckett's plays do not exist in a uniform, static state”; he also notes that, paradoxically, due to the intransigence of the Beckett estate, “a director can follow any of these various published texts and still conflict with Beckett's recorded intentions” (144–5). Gontarski further discusses a number of fascinating Beckett productions that were cleverly incorporated into museum exhibitions, including his own production of Breath, where the audience did not even realize it was viewing a theatrical production.
It is not only canonical authors and plays that find room in Ackerman's collection. In “The Space Stage and the Circus: E. E. Cummings's Him and Frederick Kiesler's Raumbühne,” Allison Carruth presents a fascinating account of how Frederick Kiesler's avant-garde stage architecture, as well as the circus and burlesque, influenced Cummings's theatre aesthetic, and in particular his play Him, especially in Jim Light and Robert Edmund Jones's brilliant, although misunderstood, production at the Provincetown Playhouse in 1927.
Other essays in the volume include Myka Tucker-Abramson's “The Money Shot: Economies of Sex, Guns, and Language in Topdog/Underdog,” a scintillating analysis of how Suzan-Lori Parks's The America Play was revised as Topdog/Underdog; Bilha Blum's “‘¡Silencio, he dicho!’: Space, Language, and Characterization as Agents of Social Protest in Lorca's Rural Tragedies,” an excellent account of how Lorca used the binaries of onstage–offstage space, prose–poetry, and life–death to stimulate his audience's thinking on social reality; Nick Salvato's “Uncloseting Drama: Gertrude Stein and the Wooster Group,” a brilliant analysis of the Wooster Group's production House/Lights, an adaptation of Stein's Doctor Faustus Lights the Lights, that Salvato argues did more to uncover what that play is really about than whole shelves full of scholarly works; Nicholas Crawford's “Synge's Playboy and the Eugenics of Language,” which is quite simply the best thing I've read on Synge's masterpiece; and Hana Worthen and W. B. Worthen's “The Pillowman and the Ethics of Allegory,” an exploration of McDonagh's play as allegory, but more specifically of allegory as “the trope for art's engagement with time, experience, and history,” which makes it “always potentially political in its implications” (203). The only essay I have not yet mentioned is Tanya Thresher's “‘Vinløv i håret’: The Relationship between Women, Language, and Power in Ibsen's Hedda Gabler,” an incisive exploration of one of modern drama's most enigmatic characters, and like all the other essays in this volume, first rate.
If you have not been keeping up with your reading of Modern Drama—and even if you have—this is a collection of essays not to be missed.
