In this article we highlight the main points of the development of bioethics and ethics committees in France. We argue that the French cultural context of medicine and its current political transformations favor new models of hospital ethics committee and we provide an example of such a model developed at Paris's Institut Curie, the oldest French cancer treatment and research centre.
Emergence of French Ethics Committees Dominated by Research Regulations
The growth of bioethics and ethics committees in France is very different from that in the United States and elsewhere.Footnote 1 In our country, ethics committees emerged in the 1980s as the result of two movements, a political movement with the creation of a permanent Comité Consultatif National d'Ethique (CCNE) (National Ethics Committee) and a professional movement, with the development of local ethics committees. The CCNE, created in 1983 by the French President, was given the mission “to express its opinion on moral issues raised by research in the fields of biology, medicine and health, whether these issues concerned individuals, social groups or society as a whole.” Between 1983 and 1993, one third of CCNE opinions concerned medically assisted procreation and the embryo, one third concerned research on human beings, and one third concerned genetics.Footnote 2
At the same time, ethics committees were formed in teaching hospitals in response to the requirements of international scientific journals for better control of research protocols. After several years of debate on the role of these committees, the French Parliament voted the so-called Huriet-Sérusclat law in 1988, which defined the framework of research. It created Comités Consultatifs pour la Protection des Personnes dans la Recherche Biomédicale (Institutional Review Boards), CCPPRB now called CPP. Following the application of this law at the beginning of the 1990s, almost all of the old local committees disappeared and were replaced by the new CCPPRB.
It is important to stress several characteristics of bioethics and ethics committees development in France. First is the prominent place in the birth of French bioethics devoted to problems of research and biology, particularly medically assisted procreation and genetics. Although the creation of the CCNE can be interpreted as a denial of the role of the official representative body of the French Medical Association (Conseil de l'Ordre des Médecins), it was not, strictly speaking, asked to comment on daily medical care. After its creation, the CCNE essentially dealt with applications of biology. The predominant position of the CCNE in French bioethics tended to focus the debate on research whereas the creation of hospital ethics committees was designed to regulate clinical study protocols.
The second point concerns the absence of criticism of medicine by the French bioethics movement. The CCNE and local committees are predominantly composed of clinicians and scientists. The legitimacy of their members is essentially based on their knowledge of the field and their professional status. It is not their role to question science or medicine, as happened in the United States in the 1970s when many people outside of the scientific and medical fields (philosophers, theologians, jurists) were responsible for the development of bioethics. The movement in France was dominated by medical doctors and humanistic scientists, represented by such prominent leaders as Professors Jean Bernard and Jean Pierre Changeux, former chairmen of the CCNE. Hospital ethics committees too were essentially composed of physicians and scientists.
The third important point is that the French version of bioethics was therefore developed based on legal regulations governing biomedical research.Footnote 3 The bioethics movement led also to the establishment of “bioethical” laws enacted in 1994, with the support of medical doctors and researchers, especially the members of the CCNE. In France, bioethics is characterized by a rapid passage “de l'éthique au droit” (from ethics to law), which is the title of the first Conseil d'Etat report, known as the Braibant report.Footnote 4 These laws are based on the principle of respect for the dignity of human beings. French “bioethical” laws were not designed to protect an individual's “autonomy.” In contrast with the United States, jurists or philosophers never publicly denounced the “paternalism” of physicians. Similarly, French law courts did not allow patients and their families to take actions against medical decisions. There was never a French equivalent of a Karen Quinlan case that prompted hospitals to create ethics committees to make decisions when there was a difference of opinion between healthcare professionals and laymen about life or death issues.
Development of Ethics Discussion Groups Focused on Hospital Care
The fourth point is the importance of professional independence in France, a country where the history of the profession is impregnated with the principles of “liberal” medicine.Footnote 5 This independence is not only a right but also a duty for practitioners: “The doctor cannot abrogate his/her professional independence in any way” (Article 5 of the Medical Ethics Code). Consequently, personal responsibility is a central component of French medical ethics, even in the public hospital sector. Moreover, this responsibility is guaranteed by law: “The practice of medicine is personal; each doctor is responsible for his or her decisions and actions” (Article 69 of the Medical Ethics Code). Because the doctor must assume individual responsibility in dealing with the complexity of the patient's situation, his or her independent decisionmaking extends also to include an ethical independence. Traditionally, ethical skills also constitute part of medical skills.
In the United States, medical decisionmaking can be discussed, on request, by an ethics committee or an ethicist in the clinical environment. In this context, the doctor no longer has the monopoly to define and decide alone on the patient's well-being. The ethical dimension of medical practice can be the subject of an external review, beyond the auspices of the physician, deemed useful in helping to resolve problems identified as “ethical.”Footnote 6 Central to this approach is the professional “ethicist,” an occupation that does not exist in France.Footnote 7 Clinical ethicists provide ethical consultations at the request of patients, families, or healthcare professionals, although the nature of their expertise remains a subject of debate. In particular, the American medical context attributes skills to the ethicist that, in France, remain firmly in the domain of physicians.
The fifth, and final, point is that the importance attributed to medical responsibility resulted, in the mid-1990s, in the appearance of a new form of local ethical structure, devoted to discussion rather than decision. In France, the first phase of development of local ethics committee ended with their disappearance and replacement in the late 1980s by CCPPRB, created by the state, and that were no longer called “ethics committees.” Soon after, a new page was turned in the history of French bioethics with the spontaneous emergence in certain hospitals of “ethics discussion groups.” In a way, these groups have a role opposite to that of the previous committees: They deal with everyday care but not research, and they do not issue an opinion. They simply constitute a forum for discussion among hospital professionals.Footnote 8 Most of these groups comprise a large number of nurses, especially charge nurses, and some doctors. An important milestone of this growing movement was the creation, in 1996, of Espace éthique (ethical space) in Paris APHP hospitals (Assistance Publique Hôpitaux de Paris), the largest hospitals' trust in Europe.
These new structures express a different, more flexible, more open vision of bioethics, based on a multidisciplinary approach, although still mainly professional. In a way, experts have been replaced by everyday practitioners. Similarly, healthcare ethics is tending to replace biomedical research ethics. These new structures are not designed to reach normative decisions, but to provide a place for professionals to consider the ethical implications of hospital care. However, the number of these groups remains small. Unlike most American ethics committees, they also do not deal with actual cases, and their discussions often do not have any immediate consequences. The objective of these groups is not to make decisions or offer opinions but to discuss issues concerning changes in the hospital and in medicine.
This type of committee is therefore a professional discussion group, but one that does not have any direct link with the daily practice of medicine and clinical decisions. This raises the question of the practical value of such groups and what type of committee models would need to be developed in order to deal with clinical situations, keeping in mind the necessity of reflecting the French cultural context of medicine and bioethics. In other words, what types of different structures could we create in this country to preserve professional independence while, at the same time, facilitating decisions concerning patients or difficult institutional problems? We have tried to answer this double challenge with the creation of one model of ethics committee at Institut Curie, the oldest French cancer treatment and research center, created in Paris by Marie Curie.
A New Committee Model: Its Principles and Mission
Rather than being called an “ethics committee” the committee is referred to as the “Ethics Project” (“Projet Ethique”), to more accurately describes its structure, organization, and mode of functioning. The Ethics Project is designed to stimulate and encourage self-reflection for healthcare professionals (nurses, doctors, or institutional decisionmakers) regarding clinical problems and institutional decisions. The Project is therefore based on two principles. First, in the French setting, it places particular emphasis on the professional responsibility that each doctor or nurse must rightfully exercise as part of a multidisciplinary team. There is no need for a special committee to define a set of moral guidelines for other professionals or to issue ethical decisions, even if they are only advisory. We therefore consider that the ethical dimension of healthcare cannot be determined by such a committee representing the “moral conscience of the institution,”Footnote 9 offering wisdom or acting as a guarantor for healthcare professionals.
However, in the course of carrying out their professional duties, healthcare practitioners do face ethical dilemmas concerning the appropriateness of their decisions and actions. Keeping in mind that the French perspective precludes depending on an institutional committee or an expert opinion for answers regarding the ethical dimension of clinical care, what is the appropriate response to such questions? The second principle of the Project is that exercise of professional responsibility requires self-reflection and a review of clinical care. This is the case when an individual, a department, or an administrative team feels unsure about the best management or may be the subject of a complaint. It is essential, in such situations, to have a structure in which professionals can discuss these issues, review their actions, discuss care and organization, and exchange ideas about the correctness of decisions and policies. Although moral responsibility lies with each individual, there is an institutional responsibility not to leave individuals isolated or unsupported in their efforts to make the best decisions.
The Institut Curie Ethics Project is derived from the dual belief that (a) an ethics structure should not act as a substitute for the reasoning of healthcare professionals, but (b) it is equally important to provide tools to help them evaluate their actions. Although it may be difficult to clearly determine whether an action is “right” or “wrong,” ways of approaching problems can be articulated and shared. The Ethics Project is therefore designed to propose resources and procedures so that each member of the Institut Curie will be able to evaluate the moral aspects of his or her practices and decisions. This is not, strictly speaking, a guide to the decisionmaking process, but rather an aid to reflection concerning good clinical care. This type of “committee” will therefore initiate a process and encourage an exchange of ideas rather than proscribing a particular option. The nonjudgmental environment in which different arguments are aired aims to facilitate moving thinking forward so that healthcare professionals can analyze alternatives and formalize their own ideas. This process is achieved in three main ways: work seminars, discussions of institutional decisions, and support to the personnel involved in medical departments in which a difficult clinical situation is encountered.
Work Seminars
The first line of action, work seminars (called “clinical ethics seminars”) are organized every 6 months by a psychiatrist from outside of the institution who specializes in medical ethics issues. These seminars are open to all members of the institution, professional staff, administrative staff, and voluntary workers. Each seminar analyzes a difficult clinical case. The situation is initially described by the people directly involved in the case and the participants are asked to answer a number of practical questions. The participants then break up into several subgroups to discuss the problems and propose and justify their own solutions. At the final session, the various groups present and discuss their results. The team directly involved then describes the actual outcome of their difficult case.
Institutional Plenary Group
The second activity of the Ethics Project involves the discussion of institutional decisions by a “plenary group” composed of 20 members that meets every 3 months. This group, appointed by the administrative board of directors for a tenure of 2 years, is composed of people representing different occupations and institutions. Members include doctors, scientists, nurses, a psychologist, a social worker, an attorney, association and patient representatives, a philosopher, a sociologist, a theologian, and a representative of the board of directors. About half of the members do not belong to the Institut. The role of this group is to deal with institutional, medical, or administrative problems at the request of any member of the Institut Curie or a patient association or a volunteer worker. The questions to be discussed are described in a problem-based presentation text distributed before the meeting. For example, the various issues discussed to date include the institution's communication policy, the patients' access to their medical files, and organization of breast cancer screening.
The plenary group discussion is chaired by a moderator who oversees the discussion. The person (or representatives of the group) who formulated the request presents his or her questions. Then, depending on the topic, an expert (geneticist, epidemiologist, economist, etc.) may be called upon to define the technical framework of the problem. This is followed by a discussion during which each person is able to freely express his or her views. The objective is not to reach a consensus or a majority decision, but to open the discussion to the broadest possible range of opinions and arguments. The purpose of these meetings is to encourage a deeper reflection by asking the applicant questions, by providing justified opinions, and by expressing various points of view on the problem. The moderator closes the discussion by summarizing the main elements of the debate. The group does not make a decision, does not issue an opinion, and leaves the applicant free to make his or her own decision. Debates are recorded and then transcribed and published on the Institute's Intranet site.
Intervention Team
The third line of action proposed by the Ethics Project allows staff members to submit a difficult clinical situation, either current or retrospective, to a small group called the “intervention team.” The team is composed of six members of the plenary group, appointed for 4 years: two doctors, a nurse, a psychologist, a jurist, and a social worker. All team members attend regular meetings to follow a clinical ethics training program and to become familiar with accepted practices.
These professionals, working at Institut Curie, work in groups of three: a physician and two nonphysicians. Regulations require that members not be involved in the patient's direct care, must be external to the department, and are bound by professional confidentiality. When called to intervene, the team begins by defining the problem with the person concerned, determining the level of urgency, and assessing the time required. Interventions take place the same day if necessary, or as soon as possible on following days. The team can decline to intervene if it considers the problems raised beyond its field of competence or if conditions set for intervention are not met, for example, the participation of the attending physician. Such a decision requires unanimous approval by all members of the team.
Like the plenary group discussions, the intervention procedure is precisely defined. The three members of the intervention team decide whom they will interview: the person requesting intervention, the attending physician, members of the paramedical team in charge of the patient, the patient and family, and other actors as appropriate. Members of the intervention team conduct all interviews together, thus facilitating their shared perceptions and observations. The next step is to organize a meeting in which the team brings together pertinent people involved in the situation, including the attending physician. Its role is to facilitate discussion and allow exchanges of viewpoints. One of the members of the intervention team moderates the debate. The intervention team members do not express any opinion on the management, nor do they offer any advice. No notes are recorded in the patient's file, except to indicate that the intervention team was contacted and the names of those who participated in the meeting. It is left to the health professionals themselves to decide, according to their professional responsibilities, the proper course of action in managing the patient's care.
Support to Political and Cultural Transformations of French Medicine
Like other French ethics committee models (as the “Espace Ethique” model or the “Centre d'Ethique Clinique” model), our Ethics Project model promotes a type of committee corresponding to the French cultural context of bioethics. Our committee was not designed to provide a particular expertise or reflect a version of a “medical model,” including “diagnosis” of an actual situation and “prescription” of recommendations. This group is also not designed to defend the patient's point of view, although his or her perspective is taken into account, and priority given to ensuring that the patient's wishes are enacted in compliance with legislation. This Ethics Project is a structure that tries to set up a “reflective and pluralist model” intended to provide healthcare professionals with the means to develop their own capacities for rational decisionmaking. Consequently, members of the Project, either the plenary group or the intervention team, are characterized by a capacity to listen without judging and demonstrable skills in analyzing, communicating, and mediating. Their role is not to reach a consensus or even give an advisory recommendation. Instead, the Ethics Project seeks to multiply the various points of view and arguments in order to encourage a broader discussion. For this reason, it is essential to ensure a multidisciplinary balance between Institut Curie staff members and outside members and between physicians and nonphysicians, as this pluralism allows the system to be open to various types of approaches, values, and disciplines and protects against institutional rigidity or “group think.”
The Ethics Project established at the Institut Curie reflects the traditional French context in which physicians still retain their decisional authority. However, in France, as elsewhere, this medical independence is currently under review. As indicated above, although the power of the medical profession was not undermined by French bioethics, legislative texts over the last decade have begun to introduce a change of practices. For example, France has recently “imported” medical regulations from the United States that shift more decisionmaking to the patient with respect to full and informed consent, as well as the patient's right to refuse treatment, even when this refusal may be life threatening. France is evolving toward increased self-determination for patients regarding medical treatment decisions, and the debates that used to be conducted without patients or advocacy groups are now open to their participation. It is anticipated that this increased participation will reinforce the current trend to greater patient autonomy.
This evaluation questions the doctor's authority to act on behalf of the patient's interests. What is currently developing is a French form of the principle of patient autonomy; this in a country with a juridical public order (ordre public) of the human body and where respect of personal dignity is written into the constitution. It must be kept in mind that, in France, autonomy does not belong exclusively to the individual. Nevertheless, the growth of autonomy is real and the current transformations of French law could be described as a move toward emancipating the patient from medical guardianship.Footnote 10 This represents a major upheaval for the medical profession, which is faced with a profound transformation of its relationships with society, as, historically, medicine was designed to make patients comply with therapeutic norms in order to fight disease.Footnote 11 Practitioners achieved this compliance by means of their professional authority, derived from the immense power granted to them by society and their conviction of being right based on science. This authority was accompanied by a strong, almost paternal feeling of responsibility in relation to the health of “their” patients. This type of model is now receeding into the past.
Imbued with the idea that, by principle, they were professionally charged with acting for the patient's good and in the patient's best interests, as rooted in their decisional independence, physicians (and other healthcare professionals) are now finding that some of their practices are being questioned in the name of other values such as respect for personal dignity and individual autonomy. In these changing times, a structure based on the Institut Curie Ethics Project model appears to be useful in assisting health professionals to facilitate adaptation of practices while preserving professional responsibility. Our structure does not opt for offering normative positions, but instead emphasizes analysis and discussion, thus placing the various norms involved in healthcare into perspective.Footnote 12 We believe that the mission of an ethical institutional structure is not to relieve healthcare professionals of their personal responsibilities by deciding in their place (even insofar as offering an option that they will usually follow), but rather to help them evaluate the challenges and practical questions resulting from these political changes. Although this task may not be easier, it nevertheless appears to us to be more just, that is, intellectually more relevant and morally more honest.
