In the United States, African American children with total kidney failure, termed end-stage renal disease (ESRD), spend more time on dialysis, receive fewer transplanted kidneys, and are more likely to die than white children. Are these differences unfortunate but unavoidable, or are they unjust? Are they the tragic result of differences in immutable biological factors or the result of autonomous choices of parents and guardians, or are they the unjust product of a social environment that creates and perpetuates inequity? Understanding this persistent health disparity requires an understanding of contributing factors that both underlie and extend beyond issues of organ availability and adherence. Although availability and adherence are obvious proximate causes, we argue that the primary cause is a social environment that limits the availability of suitable organs and makes adherence more difficult for African American parents of children with ESRD than for white parents and their children.
In this article we demonstrate how multigenerational injustices have perpetuated social inequities, creating a social milieu that in turn explains why African American children with total kidney failure are more likely to experience prolonged dialysis and an earlier death than white children. We define the term “health disparities” and describe the process that starts with a diagnosis of ESRD and ends with kidney transplantation, indicating treatment and outcome differences between African American and white children. We argue that bioethicists have a moral obligation rooted in justice to assist in the remediation or elimination of health disparities in transplantation and elsewhere, with a discussion of what remedial justice may require. We believe our detailed analysis of these injustices and their sad outcomes could be a useful model for comparable bioethical assessments internationally.
Health Disparities, Inequalities, and Inequities
Health disparity researchers differ in their use of terms. Some refer to “disparities,” whereas others prefer “inequity” or “inequality.”Footnote 1 Regardless of the choice of term, scholars use it to describe avoidable differences in health status or health outcomes between groups who differ in social and/or demographic characteristics (e.g., race, income, or education), rather than physiology.
Health disparities are created when the resources to pursue a healthy lifestyle are inequitably distributed, creating “unequal opportunities to be healthy, making disadvantaged groups even more disadvantaged with respect to their health.”Footnote 2 Social structures—beliefs, attitudes, and policies directed toward groups of people identified by characteristics such as race, ethnicity, gender, and socioeconomic status—influence how power, wealth, and other resources necessary to pursue a healthy lifestyle are distributed. In this article, we will use the term “disparity” to refer to those aforementioned avoidable differences in health, specifically disparities in the receipt of healthcare for children with ESRD.
The Social Determinants of Health
Invisible social structures have been and continue to be created by institutional and governmental policies and social norms. These invisible structures can constrain one’s choices regarding, for example, neighborhood and employment opportunities. According to the World Health Organization, what at first glance appear to be autonomous choices relating to residence, education, and income “are shaped by the distribution of money, power, and resources . . . which are themselves influenced by policy choices.”Footnote 3 Because differences in education, income, and neighborhood mediate opportunities to engage in health-promoting activities and may increase exposure to unhealthy environments, they are termed social rather than physical determinants of health.Footnote 4 Race, ethnicity, and gender are social determinants of health, despite reflecting physical traits, because resources and wealth are often distributed disparately with regard to these characteristics.
Public health researchers have clearly demonstrated that the social and physical environment can affect the health of individuals and populations as much or even more than an individual’s biological traits. The social and physical environment strongly influences one’s likelihood of contracting disease and sustaining injury.Footnote 5 We now briefly examine the origins of the social structures that particularly affect African Americans in the United States, and the manner in which they continue to influence treatment and outcomes for African American children with ESRD.
African Americans in the United States: The Creation of Unjust Social Structures
Both before and after the abolition of slavery, discrimination and racism were codified in laws and policies systematically disadvantaging African Americans during and long after their 246-year enslavement. The disadvantage continues to the present day, as we shall illustrate. Although overt racism and discrimination are now infrequent occurrences, the effects of the discriminatory social structures created long ago remain, affecting African Americans in nearly every aspect of their daily lives.
Slavery was abolished in 1865, but no broadly based social program provided the necessary economic and educational assistance required to bring the skills and knowledge of the former slaves to the level of the average white person. No “truth and reconciliation” commission was organized to address the human rights abuse that was slavery. No antiracism education was established to change the negative and harmful opinions of African Americans held by whites and African Americans.
As a result, whites continued to regard their former slaves as intellectually, morally, and physically inferior.Footnote 6, Footnote 7 African Americans were quickly disenfranchised, because their new rights of citizenship were essentially unenforceable.Footnote 8 As African Americans were stripped of the right to own property and freely choose an employer, de facto slavery persisted for the thousands of African Americans who sharecropped on farms or worked in mines in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. These laws began to be repealed only in the early years of the twentieth century.Footnote 9 In 1964, the Civil Rights Act reaffirmed rights originally promised in 1868 with the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution. As of 2012, whites and African Americans have lived in the United States together for nearly 400 years, although the basic citizenship rights of African Americans have been effectively enforced for less than 50 of those years.Footnote 10, Footnote 11
The combined effects of de jure and de facto slavery kept generations of African Americans locked in poverty. Barred from property ownership and educational opportunities (including entry into the health professions), generations of African Americans have been unable to reap the fruits of their own labor, making the accumulation and intergenerational transfer of wealth nearly impossible.Footnote 12, Footnote 13 As a consequence, even the highest-income African American families have only a fraction of the wealth of similarly compensated white families.Footnote 14, Footnote 15, Footnote 16
Persistent Health Effects of Unjust Social Structures
Although segregation and overt discrimination are no longer legal, racist beliefs and stereotypes about African Americans persist and are absorbed by all, regardless of race. As a society, Americans implicitly associate African American race with negative traits and stereotypes.Footnote 17 Such bias and stereotyping can lead to health disparities, even when operating implicitly or subconsciously and even when operating in arenas that seem unrelated to the healthcare system, as we outline in the following discussion.Footnote 18
Housing and Education
When seeking a new home, African Americans are more likely than whites with comparable incomes to be denied the opportunity to purchase or even evaluate homes in desirable neighborhoods.Footnote 19 When purchasing a home, African Americans are more likely to be offered higher-interest mortgages than whites with identical credit scores and incomes.Footnote 20, Footnote 21 In the United States, public schools receive significant financing from property taxes, so neighborhood quality and public school quality are tightly linked. As a result, access to high-quality public education is also more difficult for African Americans.
Employment
White employers are more likely to offer a job to a white male, even one with a criminal record, than to a similarly qualified black male.Footnote 22, Footnote 23 Even with graduate degrees from prestigious institutions of higher learning, African American men have more difficulty finding employment commensurate with their education when compared to similarly educated white men.Footnote 24 Unemployment or low-wage employment is correlated with a number of adverse health effects, including poor medication adherence.Footnote 25
Income and Wealth
With restricted access to well-paying jobs, good neighborhoods, and high-quality schools, a larger proportion of African Americans than whites live in poverty. African Americans also have less wealth than whites, regardless of income.Footnote 26, Footnote 27 Wealth, a measure of assets minus liabilities, is a better gauge of economic well-being than income, indicating the ease with which households can survive an economic downturn. At all income levels, African American families have significantly less wealth than white families. In 2002, before the recent recession, the poorest quintile of white families (income ≤ $16,560) had a net worth of $25,500, whereas African American families at the same income level had a negative net worth; debts greater than their assets. For the richest 20 percent of American families (income ≥ $78,000), African American families have 31 cents in net worth for every dollar owned by white families.Footnote 28 By 2009, the median wealth of white households had grown to 20 times more than that of African American households.Footnote 29
The shocking inequalities that these statistics document are directly traceable to the effects of unjust social structures created long ago. Over hundreds of years, invisible social structures have worked to inequitably constrain the opportunities, power, and wealth of African Americans. The decreased quality of life and higher mortality of African American children with ESRD are only some of the tragic, unjust, and avoidable outcomes that are a result of these social structures.
Background: Pediatric ESRD
Incidence and Etiology
ESRD disproportionately affects African American children; nearly twice as many African American as non-Hispanic white children are diagnosed with the disease.Footnote 30 This higher incidence of ESRD in African Americans is primarily due to a higher rate of acquired kidney disease in African American than white adolescents. Although African American and white children develop ESRD for different reasons, the disease and its preferred treatment—transplantation—are identical regardless of race.
Treatment Options: Transplantation
Transplantation is the treatment of choice for pediatric ESRD. Although dialysis is lifesaving, it does not adequately support a child’s normal growth and development.Footnote 31 For that reason, nephrologists prefer to avoid dialysis altogether and arrange a preemptive transplant, a kidney transplanted as soon as ESRD is diagnosed or seems likely.
Children must be referred to the nephrologist before dialysis is needed to receive a preemptive transplant, and the pretransplant evaluation is time-consuming, requiring multiple visits over weeks or months.Footnote 32 Once a child is on the transplant list, he or she typically receives a new kidney within one year, regardless of race (although re-transplants can take longer). Since 2001, African American and white children have had similar wait times for a deceased donor kidney.Footnote 33
Kidneys from living donors are preferred because living donor kidneys function longer than deceased donor kidneys, and the surgery can be scheduled at a convenient time.Footnote 34 Donors are usually parents, family members, or close friends, and they must undergo a time-intensive evaluation to determine suitability similar to the pretransplant evaluation.Footnote 35 Donors also need a secure source of income. Although Medicare will pay for a donor’s pre- and postsurgical care, there is no additional compensation for lost wages during recovery, which can last from two to six weeks, depending on the physical requirements of the donor’s employment.Footnote 36 When employed, African Americans are more likely than whites to have low-wage jobs that do not offer paid time off, so the lack of an assured income during recovery can be a barrier for prospective African American donors.Footnote 37, Footnote 38
Disparities in Transplantation Rates
African American children with ESRD receive 19–20 percent of all kidney transplants. However, 25 percent of all children with ESRD are African American.Footnote 39 In comparison, 64 percent of all children newly diagnosed with ESRD are white, but white children receive 65–70 percent of the transplanted kidneys. The disparity in transplantation rate, although small, contributes to the higher mortality for African American children with ESRD because of the increased mortality associated with dialysis.Footnote 40
Posttransplant Course and Financing
Medicare pays for unlimited dialysis for patients of all ages with ESRD.Footnote 41 Coverage for essential but prohibitively expensive immunosuppressant medications ends three years after transplant for patients not eligible for Medicare.Footnote 42 Private health insurance must then be found to cover the cost of medications and posttransplant medical care. Although published data are scant, limited posttransplant financial coverage may be a disincentive to transplantation for some patients and families. Posttransplant financial coverage was not included in the recent health reform law, but new legislation is now under consideration.Footnote 43
Treatment Options: Dialysis
Children with ESRD who do not receive a preemptive transplant and those whose transplanted kidney has failed (graft failure) require dialysis. Dialysis poses a significantly greater risk of complications than transplant. The death rate of dialyzed children is three- to fourfold higher than that of children who receive transplants.Footnote 44, Footnote 45 Dialysis sessions last several hours and are needed several times each week. These obligatory sessions interfere with school attendance and participation in extracurricular activities. ESRD and dialysis are associated with poor academic performance.Footnote 46, Footnote 47 Parents rate their child’s quality of life while on dialysis lower than with a functioning transplant.Footnote 48, Footnote 49
Proposed Explanations for Racial Disparities in Preemptive Transplants
Although transplantation is clearly superior to prolonged dialysis, African American children are less likely than white children to receive preemptive transplants. They spend more time on dialysis awaiting transplant than white children, risking higher mortality and morbidity.Footnote 50, Footnote 51 Proposed reasons for this disparity include the following:
• Delayed presentation: Preemptive transplants are not possible if the child presents to the nephrologist with advanced disease in need of dialysis. Published data reveals that nephrologists evaluate similar proportions of African American and white children (just over 60%) before dialysis is needed.Footnote 52 Whether African American children have more advanced disease at the time of presentation than white children is unknown.
• Family preferences or distrust of the transplant process: Although African American adults report a higher quality of life on dialysis than white patients,Footnote 53 and distrust of the healthcare system fosters reluctance among African Americans to agree to a transplant,Footnote 54, Footnote 55 no such data are available for children. Nevertheless, only a small amount of the transplantation disparity in the adult population is explained by distrust and treatment preferences.Footnote 56 Little to no data are available concerning African American parents’ preferences regarding transplant and dialysis for their children.
• Failure to complete the pretransplant evaluation: African American adults are less likely than whites to complete the pretransplant workup, but no data are available about children.Footnote 57
• Lower rates of referral for transplant from nephrologists: The pretransplant workup occurs at the discretion of the nephrologist, who initiates the process and orders the necessary tests. Nephrologists are aware that African American children are, on average, less adherent than white children to the necessary posttransplant immunosuppressant medications, leading to a higher rate of graft failure in African American children. This knowledge may result in a conscious or subconscious reluctance to refer African American children and adolescents for transplant evaluation. Furth and colleagues used written vignettes to survey a national sample of 600 pediatric and adult nephrologists to examine associations of parental education, adherence, and race with nephrologists’ willingness to refer a child for a pretransplant evaluation. In responding to these hypothetical cases, nephrologists were twice as likely to refer children of compliant white parents for a pretransplant evaluation as children of similarly adherent African American parents.Footnote 58
A greater proportion of African American children than non-Hispanic white children are transplanted as adolescents, and adolescents of all races are less adherent to medical treatments. Although white adolescents are also less adherent than younger children, white adolescents are more likely to have been transplanted as young children, as congenital kidney disease is more common in white children. By the time they reach their teens, adolescents who were transplanted as young children usually have a simpler medication regimen and lower rejection risk compared to those transplanted as teenagers. Thus, normal adolescent behavior reinforces negative societal stereotypes of African Americans as noncompliant patients.
• Lack of living donors for African American children: Although chronic conditions such as diabetes and hypertension rarely disqualify children from receiving a kidney, the high prevalence of those conditions in African American adults limits the availability of living donors for African American children.Footnote 59, Footnote 60 African American children are also more likely than non-Hispanic white children to live in a single-parent home.Footnote 61 A single parent usually has less financial and social support available than a parent with a partner to care for the child(ren) during recovery from an organ donation and transplant, making it more difficult for a single parent to consider organ donation.
Unjust Social Structures and Pediatric ESRD Disparities: Implications for Bioethics
Justice requires that similar situations be treated in a similar fashion. Although poor adherence and a dearth of living donors are the proximate causes of the disparities in pediatric ESRD treatment, invisible social structures create and maintain the environment that promotes the existence of disparities. In the remainder of this article, we detail the manner in which the previously described past and present social norms limit the availability of preemptive transplants and living donors for African American children and create barriers to adherence, leading to a greater likelihood of graft failure and dialysis. We argue that through analysis and advocacy, bioethics and bioethicists have a duty to provide a framework to assist policymakers, institutions, and providers in ameliorating the effects of these unjust structures. We also suggest compensatory mechanisms to offset societal barriers, reducing health disparities in pediatric ESRD and potentially elsewhere.
Unjust Social Structures Disadvantage African American Parents of Children with ESRD
The invisible disadvantage and barriers affirm providers’ conscious and unconscious negative stereotypes of African American parents. By comparison, white parents appear to be better at caring for their children with ESRD because they are relatively advantaged by the absence of the same financial, educational, and social barriers. Most damaging is the belief that African Americans are innately less adherent, less likely to follow the recommended treatment plan for their child, than whites.
The roots of poor adherence. African American families are less adherent than white families, as measured by missed appointments and medication doses.Footnote 62, Footnote 63 The greater proportion of African American children who need transplants as adolescents is only a partial explanation, as we have shown. Assuming that the only mediators of missed appointments and medication doses are personal preference and economic resources, it is easy to conclude that the differences in longevity and quality of life between African American and non-Hispanic white children with ESRD are the result of the autonomous choices made by parents and children.
Many transplant centers know that families with limited finances face greater difficulty in accessing healthcare (and that African American families are overrepresented in this category) and so provide a degree of instrumental help in the form of cab or bus fare for appointments. Some also offer assistance in applying for the public insurance programs of Medicaid and Medicare. Patients and families are educated about the importance of adhering to the schedule of medications and appointments. Community-wide programs challenge cultural beliefs about organ donation.Footnote 64 These assistance and educational programs have existed for many years, yet the disparities persist, suggesting that these are incomplete solutions.
Negative stereotypes about African Americans are reinforced by the limited availability of African American living donors and the poor completion rate of pretransplant evaluations. Beliefs that African American parents make poor choices and have less motivation than white parents to take proper care of their children are thus strengthened. The effects of invisible social structures—the differential distribution of employment opportunities, single-parent households, the health effects of repeated experiences of racism and discrimination, and so on—that limit African American parents’ ability to meet the requirements of ESRD treatment are overlooked. Reducing the effect of these invisible constraints on African American families must be part of any solution to eliminate or reduce the disparities in pediatric ESRD treatment and outcomes.
Health Disparities and Justice: Treating Similar Situations Similarly
A parent’s decision to donate a kidney for their child should be mediated primarily by the health of the parent. Secondary concerns may include potential for job loss or arranging care for other children. In a just society, secondary concerns should be proportionately distributed among all racial groups. However, as we have shown, African American parents are disproportionately affected. African American parents’ choices to donate a kidney or list their child for transplant can be unjustly constrained by the effects of social structures restricting their access to such fundamental resources as safe housing, well-paying jobs, and preventive healthcare. African American parents’ and adolescents’ choices are unjustly constrained by the effects of social structures that restrict the teen’s access to the basic resource of a high-quality education. A high-quality education prepares students with ESRD to find employment with health insurance sufficient to cover the necessary posttransplant medications and care. Because the United States couples health insurance with employment, education is the key to long-term transplant health. Although respect for parent and patient autonomy is a core tenet of bioethics,Footnote 65 an autonomous choice for transplant presumes the existence of circumstances allowing the moral agent a coercion-free choice between alternatives. In this situation, autonomy is a false promise, as social structures inequitably distribute basic resources, limiting and coercing choices.
Implications for Bioethics
The field of bioethics has substantial experience in the analysis and critique of the distribution of healthcare resources and access. Bioethics has played and continues to play a significant role in determining the manner in which materials and services are equitably allocated, whether they are organs, technology, or finances. We suggest broadening the perspective beyond the individual patient or institution and even beyond the field of healthcare. Determinations of whether the allocation of healthcare resources is just include an assessment of the advantage and disadvantage to specific populations. We suggest that this assessment should also examine the preexisting advantage and disadvantage of specific populations resulting from the differential distribution of resources necessary to achieve and maintain health.
African Americans have been and continue to be unjustly disadvantaged in the receipt of resources necessary to pursue a healthy lifestyle. The field of bioethics is in a unique position to assist in the amelioration and elimination of the health disparities resulting from this unjust disadvantage. A relevant precedent is found in end-of-life care, which demonstrates bioethics’ ability to foster societal-wide change. Ethical analysis and advocacy played a significant role in both promoting the recognition of a patient’s right to determine the level of care desired at the end of life and motivating physicians to discuss patient preferences long before guidance is needed. As a result, patients are encouraged to create legally binding advance directives and discuss the content with family and physicians. Physicians are now more likely to follow patient preferences than in the past. When there is disagreement about end-of-life treatments, physicians frequently hold in-depth discussions with patient and family, rather than seeking a more adversarial solution.
Reformulating theories of justice and fairness to include the effects of unjust social structures can provide a framework for a deeper ethical analysis of health disparities and the social structures that create and sustain them.Footnote 66 In their book, Social Justice: The Moral Foundations of Public Health and Health Policy, Madison Powers and Ruth Faden begin to construct such a framework, acknowledging that “achieving justice is an inherently remedial task.”Footnote 67 Remediation is needed to address the effects of the unjust inequalities in pediatric ESRD treatment and outcomes as well as other health disparities.
Remediation is needed at every level, from national and institutional policies to the parent-patient-physician interaction. For example, assessing patient adherence has both policy and individual ramifications. Current and future patient adherence is an important component of the pretransplant evaluation, as justice requires that scarce resources not be given to those who seem incapable of caring for them. As currently evaluated, nonadherence is seen as due primarily to a patient’s (or parent’s) autonomous choice. Implicit in this evaluation is an assumption that the resources necessary for adherence (transportation, social support, and permissive work schedules, among others) are equitably distributed. We have demonstrated that the presumption of equitable distribution of resources is false. This false presumption of equity creates a significant obstacle for African American parents. African American parents, unjustly disadvantaged by restricted access to high-quality education and well-paying jobs, are now disadvantaged by yet another social structure—institutional policies—that makes them less attractive candidates for transplant. Adherence will be more difficult for African American families if appointments are scheduled only during daytime business hours and if complex medication schedules require adult oversight.
A robust theory of remedial justice should not just describe and assess extant inequities but also provide a structure to determine when, how, and to what extent justice obligates compensatory measures to ameliorate the effects of inequity, and from whom remedial efforts are due. Bioethics proposed and advocated for greater respect for patient/family autonomy in end-of-life care. The resultant changes were viewed as morally obligatory changes, affecting individual physicians as well as national policy. In a similar fashion, bioethical analysis should elucidate what compensatory measures are needed (and from whom) to ameliorate the effects of the unjust social structures that create disparities in pediatric ESRD. In identifying compensatory measures, a robust theory of remedial justice would determine which treatment or outcome differences meet the definition of disparities and would then examine the contribution of invisible social structures to the disparity.
Using the example of ESRD treatment adherence in African American parents and children, we should examine the degree to which invisible unjust social structures make adherence disproportionately more difficult for African American families. In this case, our analysis would consider the fact that African American parents’ ability to care for their children with ESRD is related to a social reality in which they are more likely to be single parents in low-wage jobs without paid time off, and that they may be reliant on public transportation. The multiple appointments necessary for the care of a child with ESRD may be an inconvenient annoyance for every parent but may pose an insurmountable obstacle to minimum-wage and low-income single parents. Remediating the effects of this injustice requires a more significant change than offering transportation vouchers.
We suggest the following instrumental changes:
• The necessary pretransplant testing should be performed in only one or two days.
• Appointments should be offered at nontraditional hours to accommodate parents who cannot take time off during business hours and/or have no other adult available to transport the child.
• Medication schedules should be simplified or adapted, recognizing that the child of a single parent may spend many hours away from home under the supervision of multiple unrelated adult caregivers.
• Survey instruments, along with home visits, should be developed and used to identify real and perceived barriers to medication adherence.
• At the policy level, ethical analysis of pediatric ESRD disparities and the unjust social structures that create and maintain them should also result in recommendations for substantive change. For example, we assert that it is morally unacceptable to stop coverage for immunosuppressive medications three years posttransplant when the negative effect of this policy falls disproportionately on an already disadvantaged African American population.
Conclusion
In this article we illustrated how the effects of continued racism, discrimination, bias, and stereotyping unjustly disadvantage African Americans in the United States and create disparities. We described how these effects create and perpetuate the disparities identified in pediatric ESRD treatment and outcomes. The remediation and elimination of health disparities, in pediatric ESRD treatment and elsewhere, are issues of justice that sit squarely within the purview of bioethics. Western bioethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice assume an equality of opportunity, in which patients and families start on a level playing field. We have shown that in the United States that assumption is erroneous.
Although changing the social structures that result in African American disadvantage is daunting and beyond the scope of bioethics, we stress that determining where, how, and from whom compensatory measures should come is obligatory, and we sketched some of what remedial justice requires. The changes and modifications we suggest will benefit all parents regardless of race, but African Americans more so, commensurate with their greater disadvantage. Bioethics and bioethicists must broaden their focus and address the effects of the many unjust social structures that result in disparities not only in pediatric ESRD treatment but also in other areas of healthcare. Future work in bioethics theory should assess the impact of current and proposed policies, rules, and guidelines on disadvantaged populations and should help determine the extent of morally obligatory remediation for past injustice.
