In 1915, poet and labor activist Ralph Chaplin put the finishing touches on a new song, “Solidarity Forever.” Set to the tune of “The Battle Hymn of the Republic,” the catchy ballad would go on to become one of the most recognizable labor anthems in the United States, Canada, and beyond. Bookending this origins story were two momentous crises. In June 1914, a great urban fire swept through Salem, Massachusetts, destroying large parts of the city; three and one-half years later, in December 1917, an enormous explosion ripped through the port of Halifax, Nova Scotia, killing nearly two thousand and leaving thousands more injured and homeless.
At first glance, these events might appear to have little in common, other than their proximate timing. “Solidarity Forever” was inspired by a protracted and violent coal miners' strike in West Virginia, not by either of these urban conflagrations. Most likely, no one in Salem or Halifax was familiar with Chaplin's recent creation, at least not yet.
But as Jacob A. C. Remes demonstrates in his excellent book, the theme of working-class solidarity, which lies at the heart of Chaplin's anthem, is equally central to the histories of the Salem fire and Halifax explosion. Both disasters disproportionately affected working-class neighborhoods and their residents. In their wake, survivors relied on existing community and kinship networks for material and emotional support while forging new obligations to one another. Through a close analysis of the mutual ties that bound working-class Salemites and Haligonians together, both before and after crises struck, Remes recovers the social and labor histories of these early twentieth-century urban calamities. His nuanced and thoughtful monograph makes valuable contributions to the histories of Progressive Era citizenship and state-building, U.S.-Canadian borderlands history, and the field of disaster studies.
Central to Remes's analysis, as the book's title suggests, is his concept of “disaster citizenship,” a term that describes survivors' shifting relationships with each other and with the Progressive Era state. During the 1910s, in both the United States and Canada, state power expanded significantly and into many new realms, including disaster relief. Government officials and their upper- and middle-class allies assumed a new social responsibility for providing aid to the victims of catastrophe. However, they sought to provide this aid on their own terms, and in exchange for greater control over aid recipients' labors, bodies, and behaviors.
Survivors of major calamities, on the other hand, increasingly began to conceive of disaster aid as a right of citizenship, yet wanted to maintain their independence from the state and its agents. Rather than consenting passively to relief authorities' expectations and demands, Remes argues, working-class individuals in Salem and Halifax instead constructed alternatives to the progressive state. While accepting some formal assistance, survivors preferred to depend on informal networks of families, neighbors, churches, unions, and mutual aid societies for relief and rehabilitation. Resentful of the hierarchical aid that middle- and-upper-class relief workers tried to impose, they embraced more reciprocal forms of help. Where the state offered charity, working-class survivors favored solidarity. In caring for and rescuing each other, Remes argues, Salemites and Haligonians constructed and practiced “disaster citizenship,” “a new form of citizenship for a new era of governance” (20).
As Remes shows, however, such alternative visions of citizenship did not go uncontested. Tensions arose between working-class disaster survivors and the middle- and upper-class individuals who endeavored to assist them, due in large part to their competing perceptions of order and disorder. Economic elites and government authorities, guided by a “progressive ideology of disaster relief” (13), saw technocratic approaches to disaster assistance, designed and administered by professional relief experts, as critical to restoring and preserving social order. Yet in privileging such a relief system, Remes argues, authorities failed to recognize the material and emotional importance of everyday forms of solidarity to working-class disaster survivors. Unable to comprehend the spontaneous post-disaster order that survivors constructed—one based on informal, local ties—elites perceived working-class responses to the crises as amateurish; irrational; and above all, disorderly.
Such competing visions of disaster relief led to confrontations between the providers and recipients of disaster relief. Such conflicts over aid were inherently political, for they put the growing power of the welfare state in direct conflict with survivors' desires to maintain their own agency. While Remes bases his interpretations on events in Progressive Era Massachusetts and Nova Scotia, he also contends that similar themes and conflicts resonate in the wake of many other catastrophes, including those in our own time. By extending his analysis beyond early twentieth-century Salem and Halifax, his book makes a useful theoretical contribution to disaster studies more broadly.
While Remes adds much to the scholarship on disasters and labor history, he also provides valuable insights on the transnational history of the United States and Canada. Focusing on an overlooked borderlands region of North America, Remes calls attention to the many intimate connections that linked Massachusetts and Nova Scotia. Working-class migrants traveled extensively between the two areas, creating “ties of literal and figurative kinship” (194). When disaster struck, monetary and material aid flowed along these preexisting networks, as solidarity crossed national boundaries. At the same time, middle- and upper-class U.S. and Canadian authorities exchanged ideas about disaster relief, while professional disaster experts and institutions offered their knowledge and resources on both sides of the border. In analyzing these various connections, Remes makes a persuasive case for studying U.S. and Canadian history in concert.
In sum, Disaster Citizenship is an impressive first book. Perhaps its most poignant message, though, is that disasters are not simply unmitigated tragedies; for survivors, they can also represent opportunities for social progress, “moments of empathy and solidarity that can take on political meaning” (199). Although Salemites and Haligonians may not have sung “Solidarity Forever” in response to the unbelievable devastation they experienced, its lyrics—and one line, in particular—surely would have resonated with them: “Now we stand outcast and starving midst the wonders we have made / But the union makes us strong.”
