There is always a refreshing quality to reading a study on a major author that is written by a scholar from an entirely different background. Such an “outside” approach often enhances our understanding in quite significant ways, all the more so if the author under study, in this case François Rabelais, was a true polymath, monk, medical doctor, and humanist in the early modern fashion and thus far exceeded purely “literary” perspectives in his writing. The main interests of Timothy Haglund's study of Rabelais are political philosophy (and the link to pantagruelism), the rapport between Rabelais and Machiavelli, and the intricate links between private life, politics, and religion. Haglund develops a number of pertinent points, and through the lens of political philosophy, he opens up new critical angles on Rabelais. But his promising study is hampered by the critic's struggle with Rabelais's text and by a lack of engagement with the plethora of recent and important scholarly works on Rabelais.
Although the wealth of scholarly studies on Rabelais is hard to master, Haglund's study would have benefited especially from more engagement with recent sources in the main venues of research, such as the Études rabelaisiennes. There are important critical sources for a large number of topics, hard to neglect in any serious study. Haglund frequently touches on these topics seemingly without being aware of the essential scholarship on them. Examples are themes such as “scandal,” “reception theory,” the prologue to Gargantua, “paradox,” “comedy/satire,” “perplexity,” and “cynicism,” which have all benefited from essential recent scholarship that would have helped him strengthen, and sometimes nuance or modify, his findings. The following is a case in point: Machiavelli is the focal point of Haglund's study, but a quick look at any bibliography of Rabelais criticism would have unearthed five major studies on the topic—a scarcity that underlines the necessity of the present study. But Haglund ignores four of them, coincidentally the four published in French by major critics such as R. Cooper, I. R. Morrison, and F. Rouget. Such fundamental gaps unfortunately harm Haglund's argument considerably. Among many other examples, one thinks concretely of M. Clément's essential work on cynicism, N. Le Cadet's study of reader reception, S. Geonget's analysis of Renaissance perplexity, and T. Vigliano's on “pantagruelism.” Consequently, the reader is often puzzled by logical stretches or incomplete and underdeveloped, albeit potentially interesting, arguments throughout the study.
While it is certainly true that scholars write the books that they want to write, not necessarily the ones that critics want to read, these gaps appear formidable since Haglund integrates most of these aspects into his analyses and fails to address certain choices, such as his taking all of Rabelais's writings seriously despite the clear seriocomical bent of the French humanist. See, for example, the discussion of Panurge's obscene “wall-building” anecdote (Pantagruel XV) throughout the book (8, 9, 46–49, 75, 149), which nicely compares it to the Corinthian anecdote in the prologue to the Third Book, but strangely makes no mention of the lack of walls in the Abbey of Thélème or gives any thought to its inherent subversive comedy. Such selectiveness gives the impression that Rabelais's books are being forced into a mold to fit the argument. Take, for another example, the erroneous statement that Pantagruel is second in line to Utopia's first king, Gargantua; this statement conveniently erases the latter's father, Grandgosier, who ruled the kingdom in Gargantua, an erasure necessary to Haglund's establishing a parallel between “the religion of Numa in Machiavelli and Rabelais” (69, 70). A similar difficulty occurs in the discussion of Third Book, chapters 2–5, where the first part of Panurge's paradoxical praise, of “green sauce,” is omitted to postulate the lack of “the genre's lowly subject-matter” (83) which, in turn, makes the recategorization of the “praise of debts” as an entirely serious speech in the Machiavellian mold all the more problematic. See also the reading of the Diogenes episode in Third Book, prologue, as a manifestation of flawed self-interestedness, without mention of the debt to Lucian or a discussion of the narrator's comparison of himself and his writing to Diogenes in the second half of this very prologue (where “Pantagruelism” is called “Diogenic”); or the not less puzzling assertion that Paris is the capital of Rabelais's Utopia (47); or the highly selective take on Voltaire's judgment of Rabelais (27). Such unfortunate oversights tend to overshadow the benefits that readers can draw from this study.
Sloppy editing, numerous typographical and syntactical errors, and the occasional inaccurate quote from Rabelais further harm this promising book. Gargantua, for example, is given as published in 1535 at one time (1), in 1534 at another time (42). This complaint is more than a trifle, as the publication date is still a major point of debate, mostly owing to the timing of the infamous “Affaire des Placards” from October 1534, which led to a temporary crackdown on the “evangelical” matters that make up much of the book's critical framework and content. Chronology is of utmost importance when discussing the Rabelaisian chronicles, and Haglund acknowledges as much when he states that his “goal is to trace the chronological developments of philosophy as presented in Rabelais's books” (39). It seems odd, then, that he frequently develops comparisons between Pantagruel, the first book to be published (1532), and the Third Book (1546), but he presents the prologue of Gargantua (1534/35) as the opening sequence of the series, which privileges the internal chronology of the plot instead of the publication order, which would show the evolution of the author's thinking.
All this being said, there is still much to be learned from these pages, and one wishes the book had been twice as long to address the above shortcomings in a satisfactory manner. Haglund's knowledge of political philosophy is commendable. The juxtaposition of a morally benevolent reading and a philosophically benevolent reading of the Rabelaisian chronicles is certainly worthwhile, especially within the framework of the aforementioned main topics, and some chapters show the potential of the approach. The reading of Plutarch (71–73) and the discussion of Pantagruel's classical individualism (86–87) are but two examples that illustrate the varied sources and approaches sketched out in these pages. This ambitious book is certain to open up promising venues of interdisciplinary investigation that will enhance our understanding of political philosophy in early modern literature.
