Elizabeth F. Thompson's Justice Interrupted, an exploration of constitutionalism in the modern Middle East, is a bold, synthetic work on political struggles throughout the region over the past few centuries, seen through the eyes of a widely disparate group of political leaders, activists, and intellectuals. The book has aspects that are unexpected for a history of constitutionalism in the Middle East.
First, the focus is extremely broad. That is true in a historical sense, since it begins in the premodern Ottoman period and goes through the Egyptian revolution of 2011. And it is true in a geographical sense, covering the Arab world, Turkey, Iran, and Israel. Of course, historians have written works with broad focus before, but the diversity of eras and areas forces a project like this to rely heavily (though not exclusively) on secondary sources and the interpretations of others. Only a skilled and sure-footed scholar can find his or her way through past work and produce an original synthesis.
Second, for a book on constitutionalism, Thompson makes a very unusual choice. Past such works on the topic (including this reviewer's own) focus on the obvious: documents, drafting processes, and institutions. Such scholarship focuses on questions about outcomes and processes: What did a constitution say? Who wrote it? How was it interpreted and enforced? But Thompson mentions such issues only in passing. Instead, she chooses a succession of individuals—some well known, some not; some associated with specific constitutional projects, others not generally associated with constitutions at all. And generally a work on constitutionalism devotes a good deal of attention to ideas; Thompson discusses ideas but only through the individuals (many of them not intellectuals) who pursue them.
So this is a work that appears both idiosyncratic and brash. It would seem more likely to fail than succeed. Does it work when placed in her hands?
Yes, for three reasons.
First, the account is accessible enough to be read by a broad audience but novel enough in order to be helpful to specialists. Her overriding theme—of attempts to bring about something akin to constitutionalism (though in many different guises) that are real, deeply rooted, but generally frustrated—will help generalists make sense of a lot of material while still offering a helpful overarching idea to those who have approached these issues before.
Second, the decision to focus on individuals pays off in an unexpected way. Intellectual analyses often convey coherence and depth. But when ideas are attached to people, one sees them as they actually operate in the political world—they are confused, sometimes contradictory, and odd mongrels rather than codified or systematic.
Third, the approach allows Thompson to show—sometimes subtly and sometimes directly—both how specific ideas (the circle of justice, citizenship, political Islam, liberalism) arose over time and dominated specific periods and also how those ideas moved in evolutionary fashion, often blending into each other. More succinctly, she can show continuity and change in the same breath. The first is essential for her argument that constitutionalism is deeply rooted; the second is necessary for her to show the many diverse forms it has taken over time.
There are two costs to this approach. First, she is reliant not only on her own research and interpretations but also on the works of others; that requires very sound judgment to make good use of previous work. She seems sure footed in her use of past scholarship and adept at injecting her own considerable expertise.
Second, it is necessarily selective with the result that some very important figures and episodes (the Tunisian constitution and Khayr al-Din al-Tunisi) do not receive any treatment. Other figures not normally associated with constitutionalism (David Ben Gurion, Akram al-Hourani) receive extended treatment. She makes some odd choices, but they make much more sense when the reader remembers that what Thompson is working to provide is a tour of constitutionalist ideas and struggles, not a comprehensive history of all important documents and events. And in some ways, her focus is far broader than constitutionalism; she seems more concerned with justice, especially in the political sphere.
The result will not replace other scholarly accounts of the subject but help those other contributions be read in a new way. Future generations of scholars (and students as well, since the book is very accessible in its arguments and prose) will likely have a more nuanced understanding of constitutionalism and subsequent writings will be less likely to look past the broad intellectual and political milieu in which various efforts have been made.
