With this book, Arie Kacowicz addresses the ongoing “norms debates” in the international relations literature and attempts a synthetic perspective on norms. The attempt at synthesis is an important one and well done, even if problematic at points.
The theoretical aims of the book are lofty and laudable. Kacowicz attempts to synthesize diverse perspectives on norms into a neo-Groatian approach, which, he argues, is a superior way to identify and assess the impact of norms on the behaviors of states. This approach is founded on the assumption that the norms inherent in societies of states matter for state behavior. The empirical questions that flow from this assumption and approach are the conditions for how and when these norms of international society will matter. The empirical target is explaining the puzzle of relative peace in Latin America in the last 120 years. The author argues that Latin America can be considered a distinct international society, and he uses a series of six territorial disputes and five security/peace initiatives to test his hypotheses on the impact of norms.
After lamenting “excessive epistemologism” (p. 2) in the international relations literature and advocating for a pragmatic neo-Grotian approach in the first chapter, Kacowicz turns to the development of his synthetic framework. Rather than glossing over different approaches, he provides an in-depth guide to norms perspectives and elucidates the common ground to be found. He is very explicit in his synthetic goal and Grotian approach, aiming to “take the best of all these schools” and reconciling them “through the empirical analysis of the instruments of international law” (p. 41). The definitional exercise and exploration of different perspectives lays the groundwork for his main theoretical contribution—outlining a framework for understanding the emergence, evolution, and impact of norms.
His ideas on emergence and evolution will be familiar to those ensconced in the norms literature, and so the real contribution is his discussion of norm impact. Here, he develops six paths through which the normative context influences states: constraining legitimate/possible behaviors, changing domestic discourse/behavior, acting as exogenous coordination mechanisms, shaping state interests/identity, defining the content of international law and institutions, and constituting the nonmaterial structures of international society. These paths are derived from different perspectives on norms, and the analysis of them signals Kacowicz's commitment to taking all perspectives on norms seriously. Because delimiting paths of influence only outlines possible ways that international norms could influence states, he takes the next step and derives hypotheses on when international norms are likely to have influence. His hypotheses rely on independent variable that are both domestic (salience of mobilizing actors, nature of the regime) and international (distribution of power, regional conflict, hegemonic presence, institutionalization of international society, fitness between normative framework and specifics of a case) in order to explain norm impact.
Kacowicz then justifies his assertion that Latin America is a distinct international society. This third chapter provides needed background for those unfamiliar with the region, as well as an opportunity to discuss the emergence and evolution of the particular “norms of peace” and “norms of security” that he sees as components of the Latin American international society. Specifically, the salient components of the normative framework for Latin American states are sovereignty, uti possidetis, territorial integrity, peaceful settlement of disputes, arms control, collective security, political legalism, democracy, and human rights. The two empirical chapters analyze the 11 historical incidents for norm impact. For each case, Kacowicz provides historical background, evidence for the impact of norms on international society, a discussion of the hypotheses on the conditions of impact, and potential alternative explanations for the behavior of states.
His analysis finds that the specific normative framework in Latin American international society has been relevant in keeping the peace and shaping state behaviors/relations—not surprising given that this was his stated working assumption. Exactly when the normative framework matters is a more complicated discussion, however. The author claims that norm impact has flowed through all six paths of influence to varying degrees in the cases. Further, the hypotheses on norm impact had varying levels of support—stable patterns across the cases are somewhat elusive. Nonetheless, he sees enough in the evidence to compare the Latin American case to other regions.
This is a careful, well-researched, and reasoned, serious study. However, at the risk of enacting epistemologism or perhaps perspectival chauvinism, I raise two theoretical concerns from a constructivist perspective. It is perhaps unfair to critique a synthetic enterprise from a single viewpoint, but if the essence of the perspectives being synthesized are lost, then the synthesis is problematic. The first issue is how Kacowicz ultimately provides a viewpoint on norms that makes them essentially equivalent to international legal instruments. This analytic move facilitates a clear assessment of compliance with the instruments as a (pseudopositivist) test for the impact of international norms. Yet in so doing, he freezes norms. International law contains within it many (if not most) of the characteristics of norms common to multiple perspectives, but the static conception developed here disconnects norms from actors in significant ways that constructivists would reject. While he is careful to note that it is problematic to treat norms and the paths through which they influence behavior as independent variables (p. 168), the hypothesis testing does this nonetheless. The norms being tested for impact are preconstituted, preexisting, and available for states to use, rather than being embedded in mutually constitutive social processes—a violation of the essence of the constructivist perspective.
Further and related, his understanding of norms as both inherent in international society and as independent variables that may or may not influence states in international society is problematic from a constructivist viewpoint. To claim that an international society with embedded norms exists is to presuppose the influence of those norms. If the norms did not have influence (i.e., were not expressed in the behavior that constitutes and reifies those norms), then they would not exist, and ergo neither would the international society. Constructivists will find it problematic that the “the degree of fitness between the preexisting international normative environment and the relative normative case” (p. 39, my emphasis) could possibly be an independent variable. Thus, while I applaud the attempt at synthesis, the enterprise cannot be considered a full success when it downplays a central aspect of the constructivist perspective on norms—their social quality (that they only exist when actors continually reproduce them through their thoughts, words, and actions).
These issues notwithstanding, I highly recommend The Impact of Norms in International Society. It appeals to those interested in both Latin America and the more general norms debates, and it combines theoretical innovation, methodological rigor, and empirical importance—a rare combination. The attempt at synthesis is likely to generate perspective-specific critiques like the one discussed here, yet the work is useful and significant in advancing the debate and our understanding of norms.
